Discussion Cricket Discussion
- Thread starter Goodie's Guns
- Start date
- Joined
- 3 Jul 2017
- Messages
- 39,508
- Likes
- 128,579
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Joined
- 3 Jul 2017
- Messages
- 39,508
- Likes
- 128,579
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Joined
- 3 Jul 2017
- Messages
- 39,508
- Likes
- 128,579
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Not in my opinion.
He has been so solid in the number 3 spot which we have been crying out for so long I would not change him at all. Marnus & Smith are the rocks of the batting order - no need to change that, need that stability/ reliability.
Personally, I couldn’t pick Burns even if Warner isn’t fit, looks way out of form.
Pucovski & Green have the technique/ form/ temperament to warrant test selection.
Both are elite talents, I am a firm believer of backing young prodigious talents in when their confidence is high.Don’t buy into the “can’t have 2 debutants” argument - pick your best team, these 2 young guns are clearly in the top 6 batsmen we have so deserve selection.
If Warner isn’t fit, I would back Harris in over Burns myself.
He has been so solid in the number 3 spot which we have been crying out for so long I would not change him at all. Marnus & Smith are the rocks of the batting order - no need to change that, need that stability/ reliability.
Personally, I couldn’t pick Burns even if Warner isn’t fit, looks way out of form.
Pucovski & Green have the technique/ form/ temperament to warrant test selection.
Both are elite talents, I am a firm believer of backing young prodigious talents in when their confidence is high.Don’t buy into the “can’t have 2 debutants” argument - pick your best team, these 2 young guns are clearly in the top 6 batsmen we have so deserve selection.
If Warner isn’t fit, I would back Harris in over Burns myself.
So if both Pucovski & Green don't debut together you would go
Harris
Pucovski
Labuschagne
Smith
Head
Wade
no Green 😅
If they bring Harris in and open him with Burns I will be pissed off.
Won't happen but I think I would prefer Khawaja or SOS to open until Warner returns.
I think they need to pick both Green & Pucovski and guarantee them the series , let's get them in the team and see what they can do.
Been too long of a wait since we have had young players of this potential.
Paine can open (if we bat first)
Harris
Pucovski
Labuschagne
Smith
Head
Wade
no Green 😅
If they bring Harris in and open him with Burns I will be pissed off.
Won't happen but I think I would prefer Khawaja or SOS to open until Warner returns.
I think they need to pick both Green & Pucovski and guarantee them the series , let's get them in the team and see what they can do.
Been too long of a wait since we have had young players of this potential.
Paine can open (if we bat first)
- Joined
- 6 Jan 2013
- Messages
- 19,753
- Likes
- 84,482
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
I wonder who will open? Warner in extreme doubt and Burns spudding it up. Hopefully Pucovski can make a 50 in this second innings..
Let’s say we go with Pucovski, who opens with him if Warner is ruled out?
Reckon the seven batsman should be Pucovski, Head, Wade, Smith, Labuschagne, Paine and Green (all-rounder).
Let’s say we go with Pucovski, who opens with him if Warner is ruled out?
Reckon the seven batsman should be Pucovski, Head, Wade, Smith, Labuschagne, Paine and Green (all-rounder).
I would open with Paine (if we bat first)
I actually would have added Khawaja to the Squad as soon as Warner got injured but they won't do that.
I think if they expect Green to play as the all rounder they will destroy him by the second test.
Just keep his bowling to 2 x 4 over spells at this stage.
50 red ink for Pucovski would be a nice confidence boost.
I actually would have added Khawaja to the Squad as soon as Warner got injured but they won't do that.
I think if they expect Green to play as the all rounder they will destroy him by the second test.
Just keep his bowling to 2 x 4 over spells at this stage.
50 red ink for Pucovski would be a nice confidence boost.
Harris for mine - if he can produce a nice innings here it would be very handy for his prospects.
He obviously bats well with Pucovski - those 2 have a real chemistry/ bat well together which can only help Pucovski's first test nerves.
I would drop Wade for Green - had a poor test series v NZ last summer averaging about 30, Head has made a very good start to the summer in the Sheffield Shield (he still has too many brain fades/ gives his wicket away too easily but the talent is there).
If no Warner I would go with :-
Harris
Pucovski
Labuschagne
Smith
Head
Green
Paine
as our top 7.
He obviously bats well with Pucovski - those 2 have a real chemistry/ bat well together which can only help Pucovski's first test nerves.
I would drop Wade for Green - had a poor test series v NZ last summer averaging about 30, Head has made a very good start to the summer in the Sheffield Shield (he still has too many brain fades/ gives his wicket away too easily but the talent is there).
If no Warner I would go with :-
Harris
Pucovski
Labuschagne
Smith
Head
Green
Paine
as our top 7.