Discussion 2021: Strategy, Team & Player Discussions

Goodie's Guns

Leadership Group
Joined
21 May 2012
Messages
22,312
Likes
31,152
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Logan McDonald at pick 4 is an absolute steal for the Swans. I hope he plays early on.
Can't see why he won't be ready to go from the get go for the Swans next year. Will be expensive as a FWD rookie, but did see his WAFL SC numbers were pretty impressive, so there'll be scope there for sure.
 
Joined
7 Jul 2012
Messages
11,737
Likes
34,734
AFL Club
West Coast
Position Changes for 2021 are out from the Herald Sun but as per usual behind a paywall article... Anyone have the full list of changes?

Surprised the Team Picker didn't get first look at the new positions.

All I can see so far is...

Ben McEvoy will be a DEF/RUCK
Sam Simpson is now a FWD
Jarrod Brander moving from FWD/DEF to FWD/MID
Bailey Williams moving from DEF/RUCK to FWD/RUCK
 
Last edited:
Joined
20 May 2014
Messages
3,346
Likes
8,275
AFL Club
St Kilda
Position Changes for 2021 are out from the Herald Sun but as per usual behind a paywall article... Anyone have the full list of changes?

Surprised the Team Picker didn't get first look at the new positions.

All I can see so far is...

Ben McEvoy will be a DEF/RUCK
Sam Simpson is now a FWD
Jarrod Brander moving from FWD/DEF to FWD/MID
Bailey Williams moving from DEF/RUCK to FWD/RUCK
GAINED DPP
Josh Dunkley FWD/MID
Dayne Zorko FWD/MID
Patrick Dangerfield FWD/MID
Rowan Marshall RUC/FWD
Steele Sidebottom FWD/MID
Brodie Smith DEF/MID
Zac Bailey FWD/MID
Deven Robertson MID/FWD
Jamie Elliott FWD/MID
Jye Caldwell FWD/MID
Rory Lobb RUC/FWD
Brett Bewley FWD/MID
Isaac Smith FWD/MID
Will Brodie FWD/MID
Tom Phillips FWD/MID
Ben McEvoy DEF/RUC
Orazio Fantasia DEF/FWD
Shai Bolton FWD/MID

LOST DPP
Christian Petracca MID
Bailey Smith MID
Jy Simpkin MID
Hugh Greenwood MID
Brandon Starcevich DEF
Oscar McInerney RUCK
Darcy Cameron RUCK
Darcy Parish MID
Devon Smith MID
Andrew Brayshaw MID
Blake Acres MID
Jack Lukosius DEF
Connor Budarick DEF
Jon Ceglar RUC
Lachie Whitfield DEF
Dan Houston DEF

NEW POSITIONS
James Aish MID
Sam Simpson FWD
Darcy Fort RUCK
Jarrod Brander FWD/MID
Bailey Williams FWD/RUCK
 
Joined
7 Jul 2012
Messages
11,737
Likes
34,734
AFL Club
West Coast
GAINED DPP
Josh Dunkley FWD/MID
Dayne Zorko FWD/MID
Patrick Dangerfield FWD/MID
Rowan Marshall RUC/FWD
Steele Sidebottom FWD/MID
Brodie Smith DEF/MID
Zac Bailey FWD/MID
Deven Robertson MID/FWD
Jamie Elliott FWD/MID
Jye Caldwell FWD/MID
Rory Lobb RUC/FWD
Brett Bewley FWD/MID
Isaac Smith FWD/MID
Will Brodie FWD/MID
Tom Phillips FWD/MID
Ben McEvoy DEF/RUC
Orazio Fantasia DEF/FWD
Shai Bolton FWD/MID

LOST DPP
Christian Petracca MID
Bailey Smith MID
Jy Simpkin MID
Hugh Greenwood MID
Brandon Starcevich DEF
Oscar McInerney RUCK
Darcy Cameron RUCK
Darcy Parish MID
Devon Smith MID
Andrew Brayshaw MID
Blake Acres MID
Jack Lukosius DEF
Connor Budarick DEF
Jon Ceglar RUC
Lachie Whitfield DEF
Dan Houston DEF

NEW POSITIONS
James Aish MID
Sam Simpson FWD
Darcy Fort RUCK
Jarrod Brander FWD/MID
Bailey Williams FWD/RUCK
Champion!! Thanks Mate!!
 
Joined
7 Sep 2020
Messages
12,069
Likes
42,465
Is that Tom Phillips x collingwood now hawk? If so you start him based he will play on wing to replace I Smith.
Was looking at his 90 avg year(2018) and had a like a 6 game stretch that pushed him up but faded half way and got worse by the end. Averaged 101 in the first 11 games (7 tons with 6 above 115). Finished with an average of 78 over the last 11 with 1 ton. Should be priced around that 415k mark.
 
Last edited:
Joined
7 Jul 2012
Messages
11,737
Likes
34,734
AFL Club
West Coast
Does this mean we don't get the rest of the fixture? No bye or loophole planning.
Heard we'll get the full first 6 weeks with dates, venue's & Host broadcaster.... plus we'll also get the rest of the fixture but without dates.

So we'll know who each team plays twice in the season but not when they will play them.

Not sure if they will announce locked in Bye rounds or not.
 
Joined
24 Dec 2019
Messages
351
Likes
598
AFL Club
Essendon
In a supercoach keepers league, need your help please. Out of the current draftees which forward would be the best supercoach scorers?
1. ?
2. ?
3. ?
Much appreciated your thoughts.
The reason is we play a rookie keeper league.
 
Joined
6 Jul 2012
Messages
2,301
Likes
1,721
AFL Club
North Melb.
In a supercoach keepers league, need your help please. Out of the current draftees which forward would be the best supercoach scorers?
1. ?
2. ?
3. ?
Much appreciated your thoughts.
The reason is we play a rookie keeper league.
Very hard to know who will actually play early in the season, but my guess would be:
1. Archie Perkins - I expect him to probably get games early since the Bombers really need some forward prowess. If he pinch hits in the midfield, he might score ok.
2. Finlay Macrae - Should score well if he gets games on a HFF/wing. I think he's a chance to play with Stephenson gone and Mayne getting on a bit.
3. Riley Thilthorpe - While a key forward, he's got a ready-made AFL body and could become a key target for the Crows.
4. Bailey Laurie - Melbourne need a small forward so he should get games, but is unlikely to score particularly well.
 
Joined
6 Jul 2012
Messages
2,301
Likes
1,721
AFL Club
North Melb.
Despite the plethora of forward premiums, there are question marks over all of them!

Danger, Zorko, Dusty and Sidebottom are all approaching 30, while Marshall started playing less ruck as the season went on (Ryder played first ruck). Meanwhile, Dunkley is a big risk of playing forward more often with Treloar coming in.
 
Joined
12 Jan 2014
Messages
3,760
Likes
11,755
AFL Club
West Coast
Despite the plethora of forward premiums, there are question marks over all of them!

Danger, Zorko, Dusty and Sidebottom are all approaching 30, while Marshall started playing less ruck as the season went on (Ryder played first ruck). Meanwhile, Dunkley is a big risk of playing forward more often with Treloar coming in.

While I hear where you are coming from I look a it like this. Danger could drop 10pts an still be one of the top fwds. Zorko is a personal choice-some like him some don't. His only question for mine really is when he is tagged. Dusty is someone I won't start with. Past few seasons he is in cruise mode early and only seems to get serious at the end of the season. So he will be cheaper at some point. The Bum had his best season ever so you are playing top dollar and can he do it again? Ryder will be 33 next year and has not played more than 17 games in the last 3 seasons. I think Marshall will have plenty of opportunity-especially if Paddy is injured. Dunkley is a risk but like Danger I think he will still end up being one of the top fwds. Would not have him as a mid though.
 
Top