Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

Joined
9 Feb 2015
Messages
9,440
Likes
57,908
AFL Club
West Coast
Petracca v Fyfe v Titch
Young v Webster
Dow v Campbell
Petracca just over Fyfe - think he can go to another level this year, Titch has fitness issues.

Big fan of Young’s, excellent preseason/ elite kick.

Dow just - more mature body, been in the system for a few years now.
 
Last edited:
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,810
AFL Club
Collingwood
Who averages more :-

Caldwell
Green
Harmes
Hately
Heppell
Martin , S
Sier

Caldwell could be a F6 keeper , Harmes could be a D6 keeper.

The others probably would all need to be upgraded.
 
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
6,769
Likes
14,766
AFL Club
Fremantle
Who averages more :-

Caldwell
Green
Harmes
Hately
Heppell
Martin , S
Sier

Caldwell could be a F6 keeper , Harmes could be a D6 keeper.

The others probably would all need to be upgraded.
I would have
Green
Stef
Heppell
Harmes
Hately
Sier
I have no idea how to place Caldwell to be honest. He could be Marlion Pickett!
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,810
AFL Club
Collingwood
I would have
Green
Stef
Heppell
Harmes
Hately
Sier
I have no idea how to place Caldwell to be honest. He could be Marlion Pickett!
Me neither , maybe halfway between all the hype and the reality.

The problem I find is they get talked up so much of what they might be able to do at this level that you can easily forget they haven't even established themselves yet.

Martin is starting to intrigue me , if Heppell is 100% right then he has proven himself consistently in the past.

Caldwell with DPP certainly could be appealing though as a possible keeper.

Might be a case of monitoring for the first few games then jumping in if need be.
 
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
6,769
Likes
14,766
AFL Club
Fremantle
Me neither , maybe halfway between all the hype and the reality.

The problem I find is they get talked up so much of what they might be able to do at this level that you can easily forget they haven't even established themselves yet.

Martin is starting to intrigue me , if Heppell is 100% right then he has proven himself consistently in the past.

Caldwell with DPP certainly could be appealing though as a possible keeper.

Might be a case of monitoring for the first few games then jumping in if need be.
I'm not sure Heppell won't still be managed. Talk of icing after training a few weeks ago. The only two from your list I would fade are Hately and Sier. The others could all be in play.
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,810
AFL Club
Collingwood
I'm not sure Heppell won't still be managed. Talk of icing after training a few weeks ago. The only two from your list I would fade are Hately and Sier. The others could all be in play.
They actually showed vision of Heppell a few weeks ago on the News here and he was at training in his moon boot , yet posts that same day was he was 100% so who knows with the media.

Maybe they had old vision.

Opportunity is their for Sier , if he wants it or is actually good enough to take it.

Calculator is working over drive at the moment.

Take out Lloyd , take out Danger , take out Gawn.

Load the backs 5 deep , mid price the mids.

Dow fails tonight and will be back to square one.

Cripps , Walsh , Martin , Williams , Dow etc all wanting mid time but when it happens at another club people mention it constantly.

Funny how we view things.

Interesting post the other day about the Freo midfield Brayshaw , Cerra , Serong still with Fyfe , Mundy , Walters.

I struggle to see any difference to the WB mid situation.

Anyway , trying to keep count on whether Dunkley or Taranto is getting posted more about.
 
Joined
24 Mar 2015
Messages
4,154
Likes
14,751
AFL Club
North Melb.
Head scratching around the last few spots.

Mills/Green/Dow vs ZWilliams/A Brayshaw/123k rookie
 
Joined
19 Jan 2016
Messages
722
Likes
2,250
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
I just rotate fyfe, jelly and zerrett in my team. Wondering if a change in rucks will impact their scores? Probably going to pick two of them.
 
Joined
14 Mar 2020
Messages
53
Likes
256
AFL Club
Collingwood
Decided I'm going 4 premos deep in the backs.

Laird a given.

Looking at 3 of: Daniel/Mills/Stewart/Short/LMac

Alternatively one of them and Lloyd + Zilliams.
 
Top