Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[Woodsey]

Maybe I shouldn’t have been so absolute in my response but as you can see took over half the teams kick-ins and three times more than the next player!

 

[jaca]

Danger and Mid rookie (e.g. Bowey) vs. Daniher and Cripps.

 

[stephen]

Danger and Mid rookie (e.g. Bowey) vs. Daniher and Cripps.

Second one by a fair way for me.

Just between you and me I reckon Cripps scores more than danger this year.

 

[jaca]

Second one by a fair way for me.

Just between you and me I reckon Cripps scores more than danger this year.

Thanks mate. I Like him too, seems insane value vs. potential.

 

[Game of Sloanes]

Maybe I shouldn’t have been so absolute in my response but as you can see took over half the teams kick-ins and three times more than the next player!

All good appreciate your thoughts, he was the most preferred over the game, maybe when luke ryan is back its 50/50 split
We cant rely on kick ins to score us our points, I think Cumming took all GWS kick ins and his score wasn't that great

 

[SuchIsLife]

Daniher vs Impey vs Ziebell?

Currently have it in that order, have some doubt that Ziebell will retain that half back role once he directly contributes 3-5 goals to opposition team via his turnovers.

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Daniher vs Impey vs Ziebell?

Currently have it in that order, have some doubt that Ziebell will retain that half back role once he directly contributes 3-5 goals to opposition team via his turnovers.

Ziebell miles ahead. Yes, the injury history is there but he’s playing as a half-back and he’s been given kick-out duties. SC gold right there.

Daniher ahead of Impey.

 

[SuchIsLife]

Ziebell miles ahead. Yes, the injury history is there but he’s playing as a half-back and he’s been given kick-out duties. SC gold right there.

Daniher ahead of Impey.

Thanks. Although if I'm not mistake Impey also plays a very similar half-back role, and he seems to have the skillset to be actually good in that role?

Agree Daniher is an attractive option due to potential scoring spikes.

 

[jaca]

Yea, Ziebell is relatively no brainer for me. Daniher only recently into my side.

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Thanks. Although if I'm not mistake Impey also plays a very similar half-back role, and he seems to have the skillset to be actually good in that role?

Agree Daniher is an attractive option due to potential scoring spikes.

Has Impey been taking the kick-outs though?

Also, no decent scoring history for him either which Ziebell does.

 

[SuchIsLife]

Has Impey been taking the kick-outs though?

Also, no decent scoring history for him either which Ziebell does.

Good point he did not. Although even without them, had he not been taken off as a pre-caution, he probably would've hit 80-85 regardless.

The 45k price difference is also a big deal in terms of the average required to make 150k. Just out of interest, would you take Impey ahead of Dow/Campbell?

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Good point he did not. Although even without them, had he not been taken off as a pre-caution, he probably would've hit 80-85 regardless.

The 45k price difference is also a big deal in terms of the average required to make 150k. Just out of interest, would you take Impey ahead of Dow/Campbell?

I prefer Campbell to both Impey and Dow. He is just a brilliant user of the footy playing an SC friendly role. Helps that he’s cheaper than both too. A con is that it’s his first year in the system as opposed to the other two but he has looked right at home from what I’ve seen of him.

Impey and Dow are quite hard to split. I was on both early but haven’t had either in my side for a while. I think both will put in decent scores at times but there will also be some 40’s and 50’s thrown in as both have done consistently throughout their careers. Dow in particular looked a million bucks after that first praccy match but came crashing back down to earth in the AAMI Series match and we were all reminded how inconsistent he is.

 

[Grundogging]

Maybe I shouldn’t have been so absolute in my response but as you can see took over half the teams kick-ins and three times more than the next player!

Once again that was without their designated kick-in guy in the team.

I keep scratching my head over the apparent train of thought that Ryan is somehow going to vanish into thin air, thus allowing Young to take over his role.

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Rowell makes me nervous with all those CP's

Upgraded Phillips to Rowell and take some money out of Cahill. rookie dependent.

 

[BarginHunter]

Not sure who seems to like the new rules more?

Stewart vs Daniels?

 

[Backbone]

Not sure who seems to like the new rules more?

Stewart vs Daniels?

Daniel more likely to be tagged
Stewart scores well in any role. He can lockdown and still rack up 20 and get 8-10 marks
If Daniel has someone sitting on him besides lockouts he can be stopped

Easy answer is Stewart

 

[telephone]

Wil Powell vs Jye Caldwell

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Wil Powell vs Jye Caldwell

Powell, cheaper and could be within 10 points of Caldwell.

 

[inwhiterooms]

Neale/Doc vs Titch/Lloyd

 

[inwhiterooms]

Wil Powell vs Jye Caldwell

Caldwell. Not in my team but I like the pick.