Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[BomberSam]

Cumming vs. CJ?

 

[Crabby Skills]

Cumming vs. CJ?

I like Cumming's role. All the kickouts = points points points

 

[BomberSam]

I like Cumming's role. All the kickouts = points points points

Did you end up grabbing him? I remember you asking him v Atkins. It's quite possible they both come into my team this week

 

[Crabby Skills]

Did you end up grabbing him? I remember you asking him v Atkins. It's quite possible they both come into my team this week

I went Walker after Bruce's 10 made me too scared to ignore KPPs.....

I was only leaning Atkins due to H. Young already being my D6... would have much preferred having Cumming there though.

 

[Tamuhawk]

@Tamuhawk Mills for me. Think his new role as a mid gives him a lot of potential to push up both his floor and ceiling. If he does need to play down back occasionally, he has shown last year that he can score pretty well there too. Houli is also not far away which may affect Short.
Have both, picked Short ahead of Mills for round 1 due to funds and to see whether Mills would actually play as a mid. Love both as picks

Picked Mills in the end 😁

 

[30BucketsofRo]

Picked Mills in the end 😁

Could have been a 120+ game today, missed a few kicks that he'd normally hit.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Could have been a 120+ game today, missed a few kicks that he'd normally hit.

I'm happy, went him over Short for a 24 point gain.

 

[Darkie]

Picked Mills in the end 😁

Nice one!

 

[teamcustard]

Dunkley v Ridley ?

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Dunkley v Ridley ?

Ridley for consistent role, also averaging 10pts higher for same price.

 

[Blue Bloods]

Dunkley v Ridley ?

Both are must have at some point. Ridley first if I was forced to make the call this round.

 

[Blue Bloods]

Imply or Walker?

Which one most likely to become a low end keeper (F6)?

 

[meataxe]

Imply or Walker?

Which one most likely to become a low end keeper (F6)?

Have to say Impey.

Weight of history is against Walker having a career best season in season 13.

A player that has averaged 100 once, and 80s 4 times. The rest 50s and 60s.

I can't get my head around this guy averaging 100 from R4-22. Coaches will start focusing on shutting him down, Taylor Walker is not Tony Lockett or Peter Hudson (averaging 5.7 goals per game).

 

[kadog]

Impey vs CJ

 

[meataxe]

Option A:
Out: Duggan and Bruhn
In: J Lloyd and Waterman

Option B:
Out: Bruhn
In: Impey
(Impey would be replacing one of Brockman/Rowe/Fullarton onfield).

 

[Johnsy44]

Tex vs Impey and 100k

 

[Crowls]

Looking at Hunter> Hickey as well as Phillips>Impey. 1300 short of getting both trades done this week. Hunter is R3 Have Grundy, Flynn
Fwds are Dunkley, Danger (mid bench), Phillips, Ziebell, Daniher, Campbell, Warner, - Rowe, Jones 28 trades and 107,600 ITB

Thought I could get 120 cash gen from Hickey and points gain per week as well as get closer to a Gawn trade. Phillips>Impey will get smaller points gain in short term but more cash and points by time trade is ready R14/15 at this stage.

 

[Billyboy171920]

Who should I get rid of out of
C Daniel
T Stewart
P Dangerfield

 

[Darkie]

Who should I get rid of out of
C Daniel
T Stewart
P Dangerfield

Ideally it would be none of them. Three fit keepers, and while Danger will miss this game, he’s probably F1 or maybe F2 this year.

Do you have a need to trade one of them for another reason (eg to fund a major restructure)?

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Who should I get rid of out of
C Daniel
T Stewart
P Dangerfield

None for mine.

You’ve held Dangerfield 2 weeks already. Seems silly to trade him now with only 1 week suspension remaining. And I personally wouldn’t be trading either of Stewart or Daniel. I’m still confident that they both finish Top 6-8 range in DEF.