Strategy Round 7: Trades
- Thread starter IDIG
- Start date
- Joined
- 18 Sep 2012
- Messages
- 1,229
- Likes
- 3,129
- AFL Club
- Geelong
As much as every fibre in my body wants to kick Cripps to the curb, I think the smarter play is probably making my first upgrade.
Debating two possible combos being Cripps/Dunkley out for Walsh/Bont (the sexy route) vs Campbell/Dunkley out for Zorko/Sidebottom (the unsexy route).
Thoughts and feelings? Fellow Cripps owners where we at?
Debating two possible combos being Cripps/Dunkley out for Walsh/Bont (the sexy route) vs Campbell/Dunkley out for Zorko/Sidebottom (the unsexy route).
Thoughts and feelings? Fellow Cripps owners where we at?
- Joined
- 21 Feb 2021
- Messages
- 475
- Likes
- 1,201
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I think you're missing the key condition that is Danger missing.
Gutherie has had extraordinary SC points per minute statistics over the past 2 years, but simply lacks TOG and midfield minutes to score at a premium. (Although after double checking, the difference is only 5-10% ish in TOG/CBA, so maybe this lacks evidence?)
Gutheris has averaged 134 this season without Danger, with a similar trend last year, think 120 without Danger is conservative.
Gutherie has had extraordinary SC points per minute statistics over the past 2 years, but simply lacks TOG and midfield minutes to score at a premium. (Although after double checking, the difference is only 5-10% ish in TOG/CBA, so maybe this lacks evidence?)
Gutheris has averaged 134 this season without Danger, with a similar trend last year, think 120 without Danger is conservative.
Last edited:
I wouldn't have too much FOMO on the Heeney front. < @Herbie66 don't read this part but he is a perpetual accident waiting to happen. > 
Zorko could be a real beneficiary in terms of CBAs and general on-ball time with Neale missing games so I'm definitely interested there and was kind of kissed bringing him into my RDT side last week. If he can clean up his stupid frees against and clanger count he will be an even better fantasy scorer.
But if you really want Heeney he is fairly cheap already and can score quite nicely WHEN fit and firing, even playing predominantly forward. I'm certainly not going to argue with the 5th ranked coach for the round. You should be giving the rest of us advice this week not the other way around.
Zorko could be a real beneficiary in terms of CBAs and general on-ball time with Neale missing games so I'm definitely interested there and was kind of kissed bringing him into my RDT side last week. If he can clean up his stupid frees against and clanger count he will be an even better fantasy scorer.
But if you really want Heeney he is fairly cheap already and can score quite nicely WHEN fit and firing, even playing predominantly forward. I'm certainly not going to argue with the 5th ranked coach for the round. You should be giving the rest of us advice this week not the other way around.
- Joined
- 6 Jul 2012
- Messages
- 4,890
- Likes
- 11,150
- AFL Club
- West Coast
64 really tests the resolve. although has been 90 ave prior to this. May bottom out 30-40k less, not a lot in the scheme of things.
Does have Essendon this week, could they play him into form. Most mids go real large vs them.
Really a question of how many trades used for injuries. Can always trade him later in the season, cannot get the trade back,
If you haven't used that many, trade him out. he doesn't look as if he will recover to 105 levels which would make him a reasonable M8.
The bar is coming down with all these injuries though, where a 90 ave may be acceptable, not as a M8, just as a warm body.
I have Taranto who is a 94 player currently, difference is because I paid $450k for him there is no mental anguish. It is about what his value is today and what you think he averages.
Does have Essendon this week, could they play him into form. Most mids go real large vs them.
Really a question of how many trades used for injuries. Can always trade him later in the season, cannot get the trade back,
If you haven't used that many, trade him out. he doesn't look as if he will recover to 105 levels which would make him a reasonable M8.
The bar is coming down with all these injuries though, where a 90 ave may be acceptable, not as a M8, just as a warm body.
I have Taranto who is a 94 player currently, difference is because I paid $450k for him there is no mental anguish. It is about what his value is today and what you think he averages.
If you think you have enough trades in the bank to do the sideways options now without harming the chance to complete your team later on, then by all means you can go down the luxury route you suggested.
I'm not a Cripps owner myself but the second option sounds better IMO. Cripps form can always turn around however a rookie in Campbell is dropping in price (and form!) hence should be upgraded. Zorko is a solid option but not too sure about Sidebottom. Regardless, they're both better than Campbell.
Push comes to shove, you can always sideways trade Cripps later on once your team is complete.
I'm not a Cripps owner myself but the second option sounds better IMO. Cripps form can always turn around however a rookie in Campbell is dropping in price (and form!) hence should be upgraded. Zorko is a solid option but not too sure about Sidebottom. Regardless, they're both better than Campbell.
Push comes to shove, you can always sideways trade Cripps later on once your team is complete.
I'm not 100% convinced it matters whether he is or not. Certainly he seems to miss out on frees for (and give away frees against) that the average player would get. Not to mention the Giants do not look a good side at all so he could get stranded at times.
Of course even despite that he's still averaging 100 so it's absolutely not a bad shout, and captaincy seems to suit him. I'd be lying if I said he wasn't on my radar.
Of course even despite that he's still averaging 100 so it's absolutely not a bad shout, and captaincy seems to suit him. I'd be lying if I said he wasn't on my radar.
- Joined
- 3 Jul 2017
- Messages
- 38,958
- Likes
- 126,611
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
18 as I have used all possible trades so far. A couple of stupid trades which involved Grundy and Dow to S Martin and D Martin in RD2 as well as having to deal with the likes of Clark, Hunter, Neale, etc. Hopefully the underperforming premiums can start to get a roll on to compensate for the poor start. Will be targeting Ridley, Mitchell, Heeney and Gawn to replace Chapman, Warner, Jordon and Flynn over the next 4-8 rounds.
He is in pretty good form. For me it's just the ole durability chestnut rather than the "no d***head policy" as I think he's actually become a better leader than Cogs. But he hasn't played more than 16 games in a season in over 5 years!
If I was to take a flutter on any of these injury prone pricks like Buddy, Greene or Heeney - it would probably the latter once he's dropped to below $375K and posted at least one ton, if not two. Not keen at paying over $500K for a FWD who is liable to fall apart any any point. I've already had my fill of injuries this season and trades are dwindling.
If I was to take a flutter on any of these injury prone pricks like Buddy, Greene or Heeney - it would probably the latter once he's dropped to below $375K and posted at least one ton, if not two. Not keen at paying over $500K for a FWD who is liable to fall apart any any point. I've already had my fill of injuries this season and trades are dwindling.
Last edited:
North supporters, what's Atu Bosenavulagi's job security like? Have been impressed with this first two games for North, has started games well but along with the rest of his team in the last two games he hasn't finished games off, has been on 50 and 40 odd at half time in the last two games, playing across the half back line. Not the greatest price but with a bit of forward line carnage he could be a decent on field option for the next few weeks whilst worse rookies are upgraded/removed off field elsewhere.
I dunno, but your team looks ok. I wouldn't panic yet, but I'm relying on Flynn playing 1 more game, by then he's done his job and is ripe for upgrading. You can't rely on him playing more than 3 or so games in a row, so he'd be the 1st on my upgrade list, particularly with no bench cover. There's a few options available with that amount of dosh that will only cost 1 trade. Will give you 16 'premos' and 18 trades left to upgrade 6 players. A lot of players would be happy to be in your position, hell, there's even room for luxury trades later.
These are some good suggestions which had me thinking (sometimes outside of the box!)...
Ok so just gonna leave this here in case I forget later on...!
This round:
Out: Neale & Dunkley
In: Zorko + either Heeney/Sidebottom or if I'm feeling super brave...Hawkins
Will leave me with around $300k in the bank.
Can then upgrade either Warner or Gulden to a Steele/Bont/Marshall in round 8
Round 9:
Out: Chapman and one of Warner/Gulden
In: May (should be worth around the 400k mark) + rookie
Round 10:
Out: Powell + one of Scott/McNeil
In: Dusty + rookie
Will leave me with 5 upgrades left to do and 17 trades to do them.
Then again...this is all assuming no other premo player gets a long term injury...!
Ok so just gonna leave this here in case I forget later on...!
This round:
Out: Neale & Dunkley
In: Zorko + either Heeney/Sidebottom or if I'm feeling super brave...Hawkins
Will leave me with around $300k in the bank.
Can then upgrade either Warner or Gulden to a Steele/Bont/Marshall in round 8
Round 9:
Out: Chapman and one of Warner/Gulden
In: May (should be worth around the 400k mark) + rookie
Round 10:
Out: Powell + one of Scott/McNeil
In: Dusty + rookie
Will leave me with 5 upgrades left to do and 17 trades to do them.
Then again...this is all assuming no other premo player gets a long term injury...!