Discussion 2021 Round 7: Teams & In Game Discussion
- Thread starter KLo30
- Start date
- Joined
- 6 Jul 2012
- Messages
- 4,890
- Likes
- 11,150
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Agree, Tex needs to go, winter coming as well, not sure who to go is the issue. Would prefer a midfielder, forward getting to baron though. Zorko serviceable. Ben Brown?
Glad I played you a few weeks ago in SCS Final Siren. Projected +2350 and you would pip me by 60-70 this week. Having a huge game, well done.
Great to see Taranto give us a return. Kelly looks incredible value, would need to see another game before pulling the trigger, then there is the risk factor as you say of change of position. Up to 6 premium mids with no Bont/Neale yet so will likely not go there, it is tempting.
13/1352 C - Gawn Petrrock Ridley Walsh Merrett Olivier Ziebell Powell Jordon to come. If players deliver, likely entry into Top 1000 which is a bonus. Very happy with Bergman and Butts. Bench looking razor thin now.
Glad I played you a few weeks ago in SCS Final Siren. Projected +2350 and you would pip me by 60-70 this week. Having a huge game, well done.
Great to see Taranto give us a return. Kelly looks incredible value, would need to see another game before pulling the trigger, then there is the risk factor as you say of change of position. Up to 6 premium mids with no Bont/Neale yet so will likely not go there, it is tempting.
13/1352 C - Gawn Petrrock Ridley Walsh Merrett Olivier Ziebell Powell Jordon to come. If players deliver, likely entry into Top 1000 which is a bonus. Very happy with Bergman and Butts. Bench looking razor thin now.
Last edited:
- Joined
- 3 Jul 2017
- Messages
- 38,958
- Likes
- 126,611
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
15/1370
Played: A Scott, J Macrae (VC), C Daniel, J Short, B Grundy, J Farrar, S Berry, R Laird, T Taranto, J Rowe, J Kelly, T Stewart, J Daniher, C Warner and J Impey
Yet to play: M Gawn (C), C Oliver, J Jordon, J Ziebell, S Docherty, P Cripps and H Chapman
After a couple of poor rounds, it finally looks like my side is starting to turn a corner with the return to form for J Kelly and C Daniel along with T Taranto and J Short putting in some great performances after a quiet last couple of rounds with D Martin and R Sloane still to come back to replace S Berry and A Scott. Rowe received his token fielding this week and I now finally understand the pain endured by those who have had to field him most rounds. Out he goes for May next round via several dpp moves.
Was very tempted to grab Mumford or Hickey over Gawn this round to still allow Zorko to be selected over Farrar but decided against it due to the recent or potential injury concerns for both rucks. This will be unwarranted when Gawn takes his streak to 3 consecutive seasons of suffering an injury during the first 3 weeks of my ownership.
Played: A Scott, J Macrae (VC), C Daniel, J Short, B Grundy, J Farrar, S Berry, R Laird, T Taranto, J Rowe, J Kelly, T Stewart, J Daniher, C Warner and J Impey
Yet to play: M Gawn (C), C Oliver, J Jordon, J Ziebell, S Docherty, P Cripps and H Chapman
After a couple of poor rounds, it finally looks like my side is starting to turn a corner with the return to form for J Kelly and C Daniel along with T Taranto and J Short putting in some great performances after a quiet last couple of rounds with D Martin and R Sloane still to come back to replace S Berry and A Scott. Rowe received his token fielding this week and I now finally understand the pain endured by those who have had to field him most rounds. Out he goes for May next round via several dpp moves.
Was very tempted to grab Mumford or Hickey over Gawn this round to still allow Zorko to be selected over Farrar but decided against it due to the recent or potential injury concerns for both rucks. This will be unwarranted when Gawn takes his streak to 3 consecutive seasons of suffering an injury during the first 3 weeks of my ownership.
Shame on you @Connoisseur - you shouldn't speak of injury and The Beard in the same sentence!
I’m sure I heard the ump say ‘touched’ when the ball was kicked to Cameron. In any event it evened up the bad Lloyd decision earlier in the quarter that gifted Close a goal. I have zero problems with it... plus as others have said Jezza probably would’ve missed the shot given he was next to the behind post with a shot after the siren and no ability to improve the angle.
- Joined
- 3 Jul 2017
- Messages
- 38,958
- Likes
- 126,611
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
I didn't take any notice, but it didn't happen to be that number 32 umpire was it ?
Only 3 weeks ago Hickey got tackled with the most obvious holding the ball decision ever. (play on the call.)
Essendon robbed in the last few seconds, and now Geelong robbed. (was at least 20 metres, and then the next ball decision)
Not sour grapes at all, just an observation.
Only 3 weeks ago Hickey got tackled with the most obvious holding the ball decision ever. (play on the call.)
Essendon robbed in the last few seconds, and now Geelong robbed. (was at least 20 metres, and then the next ball decision)
Not sour grapes at all, just an observation.
- Joined
- 3 Apr 2016
- Messages
- 436
- Likes
- 762
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Disagree. Definitely didn’t say touched, but DID say not 15, play on, which as I said amazes me as Gary Rohan got a similar kick and was no doubts about the 15m then. Not to mention the hold on Gleeson at the time.
Highlighting the fact that the umpires consistently look after Sydney at their home ground year after year after year. It’s not even about whether Jeremy Cameron kicked the goal or not. It’s about being paid the mark he deserved.
Essendon copped the shaft with Sydney a few weeks back when umpire Jacob Mollison thought he was in playing for the swans awarding them 16 free kicks to 1 for Essendon. They allowed Tom Hickey to grab the ball out of the ruck and be tackled without a HTB call many times for far too long.
Anyway, each to their own. People aren’t gonna change their mind but I find it very very obvious.
Highlighting the fact that the umpires consistently look after Sydney at their home ground year after year after year. It’s not even about whether Jeremy Cameron kicked the goal or not. It’s about being paid the mark he deserved.
Essendon copped the shaft with Sydney a few weeks back when umpire Jacob Mollison thought he was in playing for the swans awarding them 16 free kicks to 1 for Essendon. They allowed Tom Hickey to grab the ball out of the ruck and be tackled without a HTB call many times for far too long.
Anyway, each to their own. People aren’t gonna change their mind but I find it very very obvious.
- Joined
- 3 Jul 2017
- Messages
- 38,958
- Likes
- 126,611
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Possibly belongs in the rant thread, but umpires really need to be taught exactly how far 15 metres is. They make a lot of mistakes on this with both kick to marks and the distances players run before bouncing. I know it's a very tough job, but the kicking one in particular is very inconsistent, the running too far just rarely gets paid.
You conveniently don’t discuss the free to Close that nearly handed Geelong the game..
as for the HTB non call against Hickey - that rule changed years ago allowing the ruckman to grab the ball out of the ruck and not count as prior opportunity - I didn’t actually think it was the wrong call at the time - 50/50 at best
as for the HTB non call against Hickey - that rule changed years ago allowing the ruckman to grab the ball out of the ruck and not count as prior opportunity - I didn’t actually think it was the wrong call at the time - 50/50 at best
As long as you don't win the SCS Hawks league match against me, you're welcome to win those two, especially if you can get over 2300! My projected score is a bit off due to looping, think we'll end up pretty close, depending on just how well the Beard goes. Still want him to smash it, even though he is your captain.
