Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[BarginHunter]

I think I would go Guthrie out of that lot.

Guthrie

Cool thank you

Just worried about that basement score he had a few weeks ago, haven't seen him play all season but has something changed for him to start scoring well again?

Could he have taken Duncans spot on the field orr?

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Touk Miller + Bolton vs Luke Parker + Sidebottom

Currently have Taranto/Bolton - both situations use two trades.

 

[Darkie]

Touk Miller + Bolton vs Luke Parker + Sidebottom

Currently have Taranto/Bolton - both situations use two trades.

To be honest I’m not sure either of those options is worth using two trades on, unless you have heaps or are in a genuine must win situation. If you were committed to one or the other, I’d probably go the Touk option and back Bolton to improve. I believe Sidey has had fitness issues.

 

[Chumpion]

Have to trade Dusty and Pendles.. weighing up some combinations. Currently:

Guthrie + Sidebottom + 67k cash left over vs Miller + Rioli + 20k cash

Either way I have 2 trades left for other injures. Rioli a big risk but the new role looks good.. Sidebottom could get good mid time with Pendles out for the season. Miller should outscore Guthrie.. but the extra cash could be handy if there is another 1st quarter injury..

Any thoughts welcome! Including any other candidates at the same price points that can sub with the above options..

 

[meataxe]

What is more likely to happen this round?

A: Jelly a late out; or
B: CCJ a late inclusion for Richmond

Trying to figure out the least risky captain donut to use.

 

[teatai]

with Mills still out gonna use my last trade

Rich v Crisp

 

[dicksilverman]

Last trade - Hurn to Helmet (leave me $0 exactly) vs Whitfield??

 

[onmyway]

Appears its tough decisions for all with trades remaining with all the known carnage so far, any opinions on the following trades:

1) Brayshaw to Bont & Lloyd to Dawson
2) Brayshaw to Marshall (Via DPP) & Lloyd to Rich/Crisp - this also opens a mid-forward link which I don’t have atm.
3) Brayshaw to Lyons & Lloyd to Rich/Crisp

One trade would be left for the last round (still have danger/walsh/kelly)

 

[onmyway]

with Mills still out gonna use my last trade

Rich v Crisp

I think im leaning towards Rich here, 6 of the last 7 107+ haven’t seen enough of Collingwood/Crisp play to comment.

 

[onmyway]

Last trade - Hurn to Helmet (leave me $0 exactly) vs Whitfield??

I like Whitfield’s last two games

 

[benderiffic]

Who to trade?
Briggs v madden

 

[BarginHunter]

Bont vs Trac?
I think its a coin toss but id like some input on which one to go if possible??

 

[Darkie]

Bont vs Trac?
I think its a coin toss but id like some input on which one to go if possible??

I think Bont is the better player/scorer, but maybe some role risk for him with Bruce out? Equally Beveridge seems to have been a lot “better” this year in not moving the magnets around so much.

Both very durable.

Maybe base it on draw/who you think is least likely to be tagged if you’re not worried about role.

 

[benderiffic]

Happy final sc day of 2021!
Massive call for my cash league which looks to be a handful of points!!!
Bianco v 65?
thanks for another great year