Discussion 2022: Round 1 Teams & In Game Discussion
- Thread starter KLo30
- Start date
I don't think Boyd will play and if he does I really don't see him being in the side long term, Docherty will be back. I fear Sinn will be the 23rd man for Port as well. I've prepared a contingency side with just McCartin, Gibcus and SDK in the backs and Hewett at D5, I think it's ok but reliant on fwd rookies who I am not 100% certain of either (specifically Martin).
The other option is to take a punt on a mid pricer at D5, Heath Chapman is one i've considered but it's really not an option I want to go with.
The other option is to take a punt on a mid pricer at D5, Heath Chapman is one i've considered but it's really not an option I want to go with.
This is my main headache ATS. Dropped Hinge and brought in Chapman at D5 but I have a worry about his output as the AAMI game was just circle work for the back 6 and I'm not sure that will continue into the season. I have Luke Ryan at D2 too with the same question marks.
So if it isn't Chapman who might have a spike in their scoring then who does around the same price? I have Rioli as well.
So if it isn't Chapman who might have a spike in their scoring then who does around the same price? I have Rioli as well.
- Joined
- 18 Feb 2019
- Messages
- 1,370
- Likes
- 5,768
- AFL Club
- Carlton
My point was the lack of Bargain Players in Defence.
RE: ...........Rioli, Blakey, Chapman, Bowey, Richards...........
I don't rate any of those 5 players you mentioned as bargain players, not confident they can be Cash Cows or Keepers.
If I get desperate for one of them in Defence, who do you recommend?
RE: ...........Rioli, Blakey, Chapman, Bowey, Richards...........
I don't rate any of those 5 players you mentioned as bargain players, not confident they can be Cash Cows or Keepers.
If I get desperate for one of them in Defence, who do you recommend?
No probs , some are similar to Cogs in price.
Hewett + Hinge is probably close in price to Bowey + Chapman.
3-2-3 probably allows $$$ to be pumped into the mids , I guess it depends on how many value F you want and if you want Rowell , Berry in the mids , assuming most will start JHF & Daicos.
Was keen on Rioli preseason , but Bowey & Chapman are gaining popularity on another site , I guess they would all be stepping stones though.
Don't know enough about how the Swans setup without Dawson , but Blakey interests me (so does McInerney though)
Hewett + Hinge is probably close in price to Bowey + Chapman.
3-2-3 probably allows $$$ to be pumped into the mids , I guess it depends on how many value F you want and if you want Rowell , Berry in the mids , assuming most will start JHF & Daicos.
Was keen on Rioli preseason , but Bowey & Chapman are gaining popularity on another site , I guess they would all be stepping stones though.
Don't know enough about how the Swans setup without Dawson , but Blakey interests me (so does McInerney though)
Had a quick play
The 5 mentioned + 3 rookies
3 ultra premiums + Neale , Berry , standard 6 rookies
Darcy , Grundy
Dunkley , Sidey price , Heeney , Butters , Cogs , McG / Durdin , Baldwin
10 premiums so probably 2 short
Might be easier getting $ 500k defenders & forwards though as upgrades starting 3 ultra mids & Neale
The 5 mentioned + 3 rookies
3 ultra premiums + Neale , Berry , standard 6 rookies
Darcy , Grundy
Dunkley , Sidey price , Heeney , Butters , Cogs , McG / Durdin , Baldwin
10 premiums so probably 2 short
Might be easier getting $ 500k defenders & forwards though as upgrades starting 3 ultra mids & Neale
I think he might have a potentially decent insurance role as the "swingman" .... but got to work with me here ...
- McGovern came off with possible Hammy tightness and didn't run out the match ...
- Durdin had a shin knock and didn't play but apparently should be fine for round 1....
- Curnow got a knee knock and didn't play but apparently should be fine for round 1....
- Kemp didn't play but was apparently managed and right to go ...
Think he is ahead of Boyd for flexibility ... and possibly could stay even when Doc comes back ....
- Damm hard team to read .... think I'll take him if named ...
- McGovern came off with possible Hammy tightness and didn't run out the match ...
- Durdin had a shin knock and didn't play but apparently should be fine for round 1....
- Curnow got a knee knock and didn't play but apparently should be fine for round 1....
- Kemp didn't play but was apparently managed and right to go ...
Think he is ahead of Boyd for flexibility ... and possibly could stay even when Doc comes back ....
- Damm hard team to read .... think I'll take him if named ...
