Strategy 2022: Round 3 Trades
- Thread starter Tamuhawk
- Start date
- Joined
- 14 Jul 2020
- Messages
- 1,192
- Likes
- 2,132
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Joined
- 14 Jul 2020
- Messages
- 1,192
- Likes
- 2,132
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
After looking around all i can find is Cripps, L MacDonald (OR Lipinski), and Skinner/ Mountford as rookies
(Option 1^^)
Lippa gets me an extra 20k to spend but its just not enough for me to grab Hinge who is the only def rookie on the bubble
Alternatively, i could grab Caldwell, Hinge and Cripps, but i feel option 1 has more potential
(Option 2^^)
OR
Cripps, Bowey/Foley, Stephens/Naish/Davis
(Option 3^^)
(Option 1^^)
Lippa gets me an extra 20k to spend but its just not enough for me to grab Hinge who is the only def rookie on the bubble
Alternatively, i could grab Caldwell, Hinge and Cripps, but i feel option 1 has more potential
(Option 2^^)
OR
Cripps, Bowey/Foley, Stephens/Naish/Davis
(Option 3^^)
- Joined
- 14 Jul 2020
- Messages
- 1,192
- Likes
- 2,132
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Very true, obviously worth looking at
Do we know how long Lever and Salem are out for?
And are 60s enough for price rises?
I do feel he could be this years Alir Alir, i havent got the faintest idea why im struggling so much on Bowey myself, as pre season i was 100% for him, now he scores 150 and gets attention and im on the back foot??
Do we know how long Lever and Salem are out for?
And are 60s enough for price rises?
I do feel he could be this years Alir Alir, i havent got the faintest idea why im struggling so much on Bowey myself, as pre season i was 100% for him, now he scores 150 and gets attention and im on the back foot??
First of all. Hayes is a must so scrap option 1. However Hayes at R2 is very risky aswell so I'd probably scrap option 2 aswell.
My suggestion for you is prioritise rookies over sideways trading out your big guns. I'd say Cripps could be a priority.
Here's my suggestion for you.
OUT: Chapman, McGovern & Berry.
IN: Hinge, Hayes & Cripps.
Not the worst thing in the world to be holding Owens as a donut for now. You could turn Owens to Skinner in round 4 if you'd like. Good luck with whatever you decide.
My suggestion for you is prioritise rookies over sideways trading out your big guns. I'd say Cripps could be a priority.
Here's my suggestion for you.
OUT: Chapman, McGovern & Berry.
IN: Hinge, Hayes & Cripps.
Not the worst thing in the world to be holding Owens as a donut for now. You could turn Owens to Skinner in round 4 if you'd like. Good luck with whatever you decide.
- Joined
- 8 Mar 2012
- Messages
- 638
- Likes
- 1,587
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
But if you don't have him now you have to use 2 trades to access that $150K (trade in then trade out) therefore you are only getting $75K per trade.
He needs to make $200K plus to be worth trading in and then out.
If he makes $200K though he is then at keeper lever so you probably would not trade him out.
The question is then can Bowey become a premium (95+ average)?
His scoring history is:
52, 85, 62, 45, 42, 80, 66, 58 and 151
Pros: Young player so improving, Salem out so spot is open
Cons: 60-80 appears his true average with 151 an outlier
Personally I don't think he is going to be a keeper this year so I will give him a miss. Although I'm not 100% on this.
He needs to make $200K plus to be worth trading in and then out.
If he makes $200K though he is then at keeper lever so you probably would not trade him out.
The question is then can Bowey become a premium (95+ average)?
His scoring history is:
52, 85, 62, 45, 42, 80, 66, 58 and 151
Pros: Young player so improving, Salem out so spot is open
Cons: 60-80 appears his true average with 151 an outlier
Personally I don't think he is going to be a keeper this year so I will give him a miss. Although I'm not 100% on this.
Mate, Heeney is like a 60% probability of being a trap. He’s playing the role that has been pure poison for him in the past. A clear 2H trade in target when Papley is back and he actually gets a few CBAs. I love him, I’m not getting sucked into 9 goals in 2 games.
Butters is uncomfortable not holding - but I still don’t think he’ll ruin non-owners season. He’s 80 kgs dripping wet, and has decided that a fearless crash and bash style is his ticket to ride. I’m seeing injury coming.
Butters is uncomfortable not holding - but I still don’t think he’ll ruin non-owners season. He’s 80 kgs dripping wet, and has decided that a fearless crash and bash style is his ticket to ride. I’m seeing injury coming.
- Joined
- 27 Feb 2021
- Messages
- 171
- Likes
- 1,009
- AFL Club
- Carlton
He is clearly fit enough to be out there, as his TOG was 90%.
Someone mentioned that a commentator said he came to the bench and was lifting his leg up and out (don't know which leg). Hip flexor, adductor/abductor, stomach muscle on one side? Maybe something that affects running at top pace and potentially kicking? He had 13 kicks and 10 handballs, but I didn't particularly notice whether he avoided his right foot for example. He did kick across ground on his left and turned it over (3rd Q I think) so maybe avoiding kicking with a full action on his right?
A guy on BF who gets Giants info suggested an issue last week and said "watch this space" again Sunday night. The worst case is he keeps getting picked but isn't quite right. Total guesswork unfortunately, unless he actually misses a game/s.
Someone mentioned that a commentator said he came to the bench and was lifting his leg up and out (don't know which leg). Hip flexor, adductor/abductor, stomach muscle on one side? Maybe something that affects running at top pace and potentially kicking? He had 13 kicks and 10 handballs, but I didn't particularly notice whether he avoided his right foot for example. He did kick across ground on his left and turned it over (3rd Q I think) so maybe avoiding kicking with a full action on his right?
A guy on BF who gets Giants info suggested an issue last week and said "watch this space" again Sunday night. The worst case is he keeps getting picked but isn't quite right. Total guesswork unfortunately, unless he actually misses a game/s.
