- Joined
- 6 Jul 2012
- Messages
- 4,890
- Likes
- 11,150
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Im not sure what going back to posts 12 months ago looking for dirt achieves but good on you for that one, wasn't the only one questioning him before we saw it in their two pre season games either, if Fyfe shows me the role is better than I think Im prepared to alter my thinking but weve seen nothing on the track to suggest that to date.
I wasn't looking for dirt, I was looking for information on Brodie. I just happened to stumble across the dirt
Agreed
Agreed
I'd personally be very surprised if Fyfe wasn't used as a midfielder.
I dont think he's going to average 115 again, albeit he'd be a couple of injuries from having to take that role, but no reason he can't push 95-100 quite easily if he can stay fit.
This is a guy who averaged 73 as a skinny kid playing as a forward and then jumped to 108 in his second season still playing about 50/50. He only needs 85 so the cut-off is pretty damn low. For comparison a gimpy and completely broken Dusty got that playing as a pure forward in what was an ordinary side last year.
Will be watching closely in the preseason, to me there's very little reason for Fyfe to train with the mids, he already knows the position and his forward craft needs a lot of work.
Definitely not a lock yet but there's plenty of cheaper alternatives and I like to placehold the expensive option in the group as far easier to go cheaper but gets hard to move up.
Fyfe is one of the prime guys who could wreck your season. He's going to be in a majority of teams if he's fit come round one, not taking him is going to be the risky choice and it could be the right one but it's still high risk and relatively low reward, your best case is you're right and you gain a trade and some points over other sides come round 3 and that a few ride him right to the bottom and ruin their seasons. Your worst case is you're one of the few having to trade him in or you have your entire season ruined by doubling down (see wogitalia, 2022 with Sicily, James...).
I dont think he's going to average 115 again, albeit he'd be a couple of injuries from having to take that role, but no reason he can't push 95-100 quite easily if he can stay fit.
This is a guy who averaged 73 as a skinny kid playing as a forward and then jumped to 108 in his second season still playing about 50/50. He only needs 85 so the cut-off is pretty damn low. For comparison a gimpy and completely broken Dusty got that playing as a pure forward in what was an ordinary side last year.
Will be watching closely in the preseason, to me there's very little reason for Fyfe to train with the mids, he already knows the position and his forward craft needs a lot of work.
Definitely not a lock yet but there's plenty of cheaper alternatives and I like to placehold the expensive option in the group as far easier to go cheaper but gets hard to move up.
Fyfe is one of the prime guys who could wreck your season. He's going to be in a majority of teams if he's fit come round one, not taking him is going to be the risky choice and it could be the right one but it's still high risk and relatively low reward, your best case is you're right and you gain a trade and some points over other sides come round 3 and that a few ride him right to the bottom and ruin their seasons. Your worst case is you're one of the few having to trade him in or you have your entire season ruined by doubling down (see wogitalia, 2022 with Sicily, James...).
Fyfe as a forward is 40-100 player. The best thing he has going for him is those 5 first games that Ferrit has pointed out. He is not the best kick for goal and has high variation in possession when playing forward. Can he make money - yes. I do think there is a number of cheaper options, high desirable forward premiums to pick and hopefully a couple of cheap rookies. I don't love Sheeds for the Eagles as he is a weak fwd compared to Yeo or Hopper who potentially look better scoring potential. The question is how many $300k players can you team sustain.
I had written Fyfe off given I have owned him and then seen him play forward for a 75-80, yet that run means I will not completely rule him out and Freo are a better team last year. Note Suns are no easy beats, then Bulldogs and Lions, so he needs to nail those 4 initial games.
Despite the comments, you guys have kept it above board, well done. It is not hard to spiral given emotions. Think it is good to have our views challenged.