Discussion 2023: Rate My Team

[freowho]

I agree, there is more security in the midfield mid pricers, I think there are a couple of really decent options there.

I agree. I think any of Worpel, Sheed, Hopper, Setterfield, Bruhn, Ash and even JHF are well underpriced and have decent roles. Some are more solid than others but all could do the job. The only reason I chose Ash is the probable DPP.

 

[HoleyFrijole$]

 

[donnybuang]

H

View attachment 53509

That's is a bold ruck line. Bold with a capital B, O, L and D, underlined, italicised and in size 200 font.

The rest of the team.looks good, but not strong enough to justify it.

 

[HoleyFrijole$]

H

That's is a bold ruck line. Bold with a capital B, O, L and D, underlined, italicised and in size 200 font.

The rest of the team.looks good, but not strong enough to justify it.

risk/reward….if rats fails, will drop a prem to fyfe and he becomes Cameron

 

[Eagling]

risk/reward….if rats fails, will drop a prem to fyfe and he becomes Cameron

I think Fyfe is good enough to do a job but Cameron's role is putrid right now.

 

[Shannon]

View attachment 53509

What’s the plan B in the ruck if Rat gets dropped?

Very risky move in my opinion

 

[Shannon]

Never mind - just saw your answer above 👍

 

[HoleyFrijole$]

I think Fyfe is good enough to do a job but Cameron's role is putrid right now.

If I go cincotta over Chesser then it would be English not Cameron

 

[HoleyFrijole$]

What’s the plan B in the ruck if Rat gets dropped?

Very risky move in my opinion

Can’t see rat getting dropped in new role with Henry on the sidelines for a while…moreso an injury risk?

 

[Eagling]

If I go cincotta over Chesser then it would be English not Cameron

Yeah English is much better imo.

If Darcy interests you are you able to squeeze him in with Chesser anyway?

 

[Leroy]

What’s the plan B in the ruck if Rat gets dropped?

Very risky move in my opinion

I'm setting up this way as well!

Rat R3 with the E on Friday night and three options to run with depending on how he looks...

A) Revert to 2 premium rucks
B) Jackson F5, Madden R2 to loop Sav and Sheezel for an on-field spot
C) All out, balls out Esava to R2

 

[NT.Thunder]

Always happens - I find

View attachment 53509

Holy @#%$ - I'm out

 

[BC]

Getting close. Splitting hairs over these two teams.
Thoughts welcome.
A:


B:

 

[Mudflap]

Is this the year of the midpricer?
This is actually a random team I just put together. I’ve been sitting with my same structure now for a week which is different to this, but I don’t mind some of these speculative picks.
View attachment 53488
View attachment 53489

Don't love the team but Cameron is a great POD. Nice work

 

[Juzzo]

Getting close. Splitting hairs over these two teams.
Thoughts welcome.
A:
View attachment 53515

B:
View attachment 53516

B for me.

 

[BIGB0Y]

Getting close. Splitting hairs over these two teams.
Thoughts welcome.
A:
View attachment 53515

B:
View attachment 53516

I like A

 

[BIGB0Y]

Getting close. Splitting hairs over these two teams.
Thoughts welcome.
A:
View attachment 53515

B:
View attachment 53516

To much coin in the fwd line no room for dpp.

 

[Hondo]

So here's a team with exactly $0 remaining.....

Things I like:

• In-form premiums (I count 11 with Ridley and Green) - all of them scored well during Preseason
• Majority of the popular mid-pricers / breakout contenders (Yeo, Hopper, Callaghan, Gulden, Bruhn, Flanders)
• DPP-links for DEF<>MID and MID<>FWD.

Things I don't like:

• Zero spare cash for corrective trades
• DEF Bench rookies are probably competing for the same spot. Alternative could be Cowan out, Wagner in
• R15 Bye will be carnage in the midfield.

Any feedback appreciated.

View attachment 53508

You could consider Allen, Sheezel, McLean price range for F6 to free up some cash.Allen I think is a bit overlooked through the recent teams
I feel running with no cash is a bad idea. It’s a real handbrake on early moves
I feel you could pick your fav out of Bruhn and Flanders and downgrade the other.

 

[RIAI]

Just gonna copy all the rookie picks due to my lack of research tyvm

 

[dlanod]

I've ended up at a point where I kind of comfortable with the this team, except for Bowes - if there was a decent swap for Bowes+Macrae to faux premium+premium I'd probably take it.



Just generally curious about anyone else's opinion on it.