Discussion 2023: Rate My Team

[Old Big 'Ead]

Bump

Keen to hear people’s thoughts. I don’t love the Lloyd selection or the 1.1k cash in bank!!

What about Ridley, he is far better than Lloyd this season

 

[Old Big 'Ead]

I keep needing a ~$400k forward or defender that I like and can't really find one (Cunnington would be closest but he's a no for me).

Anyone jump out? It's such a nothing price point

Ziebell, Fyfe, or Bruhn are the only ones near that amount I would go for.

 

[inwhiterooms]

I keep needing a ~$400k forward or defender that I like and can't really find one (Cunnington would be closest but he's a no for me).

Anyone jump out? It's such a nothing price point

If I was moving Yeo sideways the only guys I don't mind (but don't love) are Day and Hunter Clark. Lead me to finding cash for a Daicos type instead.

 

[inwhiterooms]

I ended up with almost this exact team as well as one of my Yeo options, some slight tweaks here or there.

The thing I'm hesitant on is that there's not much room to move on bench rookies. If guys like McLean/Hollands/Bytel come out and score 60+ (not unreasonable) they are going to be great rookies and you'll have to be content with skipping that cash gen.

Valid concern for sure. The tradeoff for me is that I'm seeing very few teams with 13 premos so quite like the idea of trying to start one ahead of the pack. I've got a bunch of value guys which might not come off but I'm happy to gamble given I see upside there.

 

[Vicwood]

I keep needing a ~$400k forward or defender that I like and can't really find one (Cunnington would be closest but he's a no for me).

Anyone jump out? It's such a nothing price point

One of your North Men.

Zieball seems the obvious, should rack up those cheap +6 pts accross half back when the Roos slow down the game. Which should happen alot this year.

Going to be fun this year watching clarkson in the coaches box. The pay TV should sell subscription.

 

[Miller is a Steele]

Thoughts? Seem pretty settled on this structure now. Only changes that I can see being made are rookie swaps or Stewart and Ziebell to Ridley and Gulden, sideways Jones to Crozier (very 50/50 on this one). $53k in the bank.

 

[Under The Dome]

Thoughts? Seem pretty settled on this structure now. Only changes that I can see being made are rookie swaps or Stewart and Ziebell to Ridley and Gulden, sideways Jones to Crozier (very 50/50 on this one)
View attachment 53909

View attachment 53908

I have 26 of the 30 so I like it.

 

[DojoWarrior]

Thoughts? Seem pretty settled on this structure now. Only changes that I can see being made are rookie swaps or Stewart and Ziebell to Ridley and Gulden, sideways Jones to Crozier (very 50/50 on this one)

Seems strong to me - the mid would scare me but I just get cold feet and tend to go more conservative. FWIW I would probably do the Stewart and Zieball move but both have merit

 

[mike89]

Thoughts? Seem pretty settled on this structure now. Only changes that I can see being made are rookie swaps or Stewart and Ziebell to Ridley and Gulden, sideways Jones to Crozier (very 50/50 on this one)
View attachment 53909

View attachment 53908

Been coming around to the idea of the three DEF premos today and I like where it puts me. Only major structural difference is I've got Steele in place of one of your forward premos (likely Rozee).

 

[Herbie66]

No doubt it will change again when teams drop

DOCHERTY (VC) , Cumming , RIOLI , Jones , Cole , Constable * / COWAN , McKenna (?)

Bont , CRIPPS , Green , Gulden * , HOPPER , Ashcroft , Mackenzie , Ginbey * / HOLLANDS, Phillips , Chesser *

Darcy , Marshall / Madden *

Dunkley * , TARANTO * , Rozee * , Ziebell , Fyfe * , McLean * / Ratugolea * , Greene

$ 29,000.00 to play with

No use die wondering, if it works it works , if not try again next year

Out : McKenna & Gulden
In: Baker & Titch

 

[Zim^zuM]

Is it too much to have all of Stewart, doch and Dawson round 1

 

[Feerits Elf]

Is it too much to have all of Stewart, doch and Dawson round 1

Pending structure, no

 

[Russty_]

Is it too much to have all of Stewart, doch and Dawson round 1

That's what I ended up doing after learning about Yeo, thought Ridley would suffice but went off him, 3 guns across the top of the backline looks good.

 

[tso]

 

[Shaunpro1]

No idea what to do with the 140K I have left right now but pretty happy with this.

 

[Connoisseur]

No idea what to do with the 140K I have left right now but pretty happy with this. View attachment 53952

Have you considered replacing one of L Jones/L Stocker with H Clark/W Day?

 

[Shannon]

No idea what to do with the 140K I have left right now but pretty happy with this. View attachment 53952

No need to spend that 140k if happy

That money in the bank will be very handy when you start upgrading.

 

[Shaunpro1]

Have you considered replacing one of L Jones/L Stocker with H Clark/W Day?

I have, little sceptical if they are actually worth what we have to pay though, think its essentially Setterfield and Stocker or Callaghan and Hunter Clark, can't see myself changing anything else at this point.

 

[Shaunpro1]

No need to spend that 140k if happy

That money in the bank will be very handy when you start upgrading.

Always been accustomed to the old school adage that money in the bank equals points lost on field, don't mind having a bit left over for some pre price change flexibility but think north of 140K is a bit extreme.

 

[Zimmer]

Need feedback guys: every line I feel like I'm heavy. Definitely feel short in Def. Am I too heavy with the first three mids. Have only brought Gulden in for the first time, hadCameron there before.