Strategy 2023: Round 5 Trades

[MightyTiges]

Is Cole to JVR (via dpps) a decent or bad trade? It will net me 130k itb but also destroy all my mid/def, mid/fwd links. Any opinions? Thank you.
Still undecided whether to bring in S.Ryan, costs 50k to get him from Madden too. Hardwick does like him more as a fwd but he will surely get a decent amount of ruck time too with Nank out, tough call.

 

[mike89]

Is Cole to JVR (via dpps) a decent or bad trade? It will net me 130k itb but also destroy all my mid/def, mid/fwd links. Any opinions? Thank you.
Still undecided whether to bring in S.Ryan, costs 50k to get him from Madden too. Hardwick does like him more as a fwd but he will surely get a decent amount of ruck time too with Nank out, tough call.

If you have Sheezel/Ziebell you can get those links back when they get DEF status next round. Only breaks the links for one round and you'd presumably already be set up for it.

 

[OnTopBar]

Is Cole to JVR (via dpps) a decent or bad trade? It will net me 130k itb but also destroy all my mid/def, mid/fwd links. Any opinions? Thank you.
Still undecided whether to bring in S.Ryan, costs 50k to get him from Madden too. Hardwick does like him more as a fwd but he will surely get a decent amount of ruck time too with Nank out, tough call.

I wouldn't be surprised to see Ryan take most of the ruck minutes, just a gut feeling

 

[MightyTiges]

If you have Sheezel/Ziebell you can get those links back when they get DEF status next round. Only breaks the links for one round and you'd presumably already be set up for it.

I have Sheezel, but no Ziebell.

 

[quite ironic]

Jones -> Michalleney
Doc -> Dawson
Mackenzie -> JVR

243k in the bank to use on Ginbey, Chandler, Setterfield or whoever for upgrades across the field.

 

[Wheedus]

I wouldn't be surprised to see Ryan take most of the ruck minutes, just a gut feeling

Same. Pretty much played that role at VFL level. Very mobile player

 

[7/11]

Hmm, was hoping Rowston would get another look at it, but him being dropped means I will probably just swallow my pride and move him onto JVR (via Davey DPP) for the easy cash gen.

 

[Courtesans]

Now have Cole to deal with on top of Docherty. I give up.

 

[OnTopBar]

Same. Pretty much played that role at VFL level. Very mobile player

Yes he did, Miller is also quick and mobile, can act as an extra clearance player. Expecting Ryan to take most of the ruck with Balta chopping out down back and Miller doing the same forward

 

[xanderdom]

Wondering who you guys would field at F6 this week out of the following:

Samson Ryan - listed as ruck in replacment of Nank, but most likely playing key FWD role against Swans
Fergus Greene - against GWS, managed to kick 2 goals against the Cats last week and scored 73.
JVR - against ESS, didn't perform as well as we'd hope against the Eagles last week. Ben Brown returning almost certainly impacting his output

Bump

 

[mwross91]

Mackenzie named as sub. Might be time to move him on unfortunately.
Was hoping without Day he'd get a good run at it but looking unlikely now so I'll take my money and move on.

 

[bomberboy]

Just the one trade for me, Mackenzie to JVR. Need the cash for next week.

 

[mwross91]

xanderdom said:[/URL]
Wondering who you guys would field at F6 this week out of the following:

Samson Ryan - listed as ruck in replacment of Nank, but most likely playing key FWD role against Swans
Fergus Greene - against GWS, managed to kick 2 goals against the Cats last week and scored 73.
JVR - against ESS, didn't perform as well as we'd hope against the Eagles last week. Ben Brown returning almost certainly impacting his output

Bump

I've kept Davey so that I can put Ryan on the bench with the E.
If he goes well I'll take that, if not I'll swap Davey for Green or Phillipou.

 

[Miller is a Steele]

Bump

If you’re available for the start of the Tigers/Swans game then have a look where Miller and Ryan line up at the first CBA, field Ryan if he’s rucking. If not, JVR.

 

[Miller is a Steele]

Who to trade out, Mackenzie or Callaghan?

 

[mike89]

Who to trade out, Mackenzie or Callaghan?

Still Callaghan for me. Remember injury subs were used at a rate of roughly 50/50 last year, so there's a good chance he still comes on early enough to put up a score. BE 13 so should still at least make a little.

Either way it looks like the other one's going to Johnson next week.

 

[Miller is a Steele]

Still Callaghan for me. Remember injury subs were used at a rate of roughly 50/50 last year, so there's a good chance he still comes on early enough to put up a score. BE 13 so should still at least make a little.

Either way it looks like the other one's going to Johnson next week.

Yeah looks like one will be out next week anyway. Down to either Johnson or Williams. Might be able to upgrade a MP to someone too, maybe Hopper if he duds.

 

[Gruffles]

Who to trade out, Mackenzie or Callaghan?

I reversed my trade. Got to be Mackenzie now with him being the sub.

 

[mwross91]

Still Callaghan for me. Remember injury subs were used at a rate of roughly 50/50 last year, so there's a good chance he still comes on early enough to put up a score. BE 13 so should still at least make a little.

Either way it looks like the other one's going to Johnson next week.

I reversed my trade. Got to be Mackenzie now with him being the sub.

Nah backing in Callaghan.
He got heaps of it last week, just didn't score well. Week before was wet and he's obviously not the right size for that.
I've still got faith that he's a good pick and will make cash.

 

[wt44]

I think my SC is glitching out, wont let me swing Ginbey into the Mckenzie hole to bring in Tylar Young. Everyone else is swingable... Guess I have to get Ryan instead.