Strategy 2023: Round 5 Trades
- Thread starter quite ironic
- Start date
Out: Docherty, Hurn, Allen
In: Dawson, Oliver, JVR
30k ITB
Ended up yolo-ing after hearing the Hurn news. Seeing him rested so early into the season does not fill me with any confidence it won't happen again so took the opportunity to close off the two biggest POD's. Probably a waste of a trade or two (and a boost) but think having them will make SC a bit more enjoyable, if not anything else
Kinda hoping Hopper scores a 70 so i can trade him to Laird next week with a clear conscience.
In: Dawson, Oliver, JVR
30k ITB
Ended up yolo-ing after hearing the Hurn news. Seeing him rested so early into the season does not fill me with any confidence it won't happen again so took the opportunity to close off the two biggest POD's. Probably a waste of a trade or two (and a boost) but think having them will make SC a bit more enjoyable, if not anything else
Kinda hoping Hopper scores a 70 so i can trade him to Laird next week with a clear conscience.
Wondering who you guys would field at F6 this week out of the following:
Samson Ryan - listed as ruck in replacment of Nank, but most likely playing key FWD role against Swans
Fergus Greene - against GWS, managed to kick 2 goals against the Cats last week and scored 73.
JVR - against ESS, didn't perform as well as we'd hope against the Eagles last week. Ben Brown returning almost certainly impacting his output
Samson Ryan - listed as ruck in replacment of Nank, but most likely playing key FWD role against Swans
Fergus Greene - against GWS, managed to kick 2 goals against the Cats last week and scored 73.
JVR - against ESS, didn't perform as well as we'd hope against the Eagles last week. Ben Brown returning almost certainly impacting his output
- Joined
- 3 Jul 2017
- Messages
- 38,952
- Likes
- 126,605
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
What is your expectation in terms of average and total points for Darcy between now and the rest of the season compared to English?
Callaghan’s cash growth has slowed with the 37 in price cycle and then set to exit this round and if he was a starting selection then you should be able to free up $140,000 for Van Rooyen whilst getting similar production from a bench rookie moved onfield. Given there does not look to be any holes that need fixing and a nice rookie batch, then I would proceed with using a boost if you do not intend on making any moves in the next few rounds.
Callaghan’s cash growth has slowed with the 37 in price cycle and then set to exit this round and if he was a starting selection then you should be able to free up $140,000 for Van Rooyen whilst getting similar production from a bench rookie moved onfield. Given there does not look to be any holes that need fixing and a nice rookie batch, then I would proceed with using a boost if you do not intend on making any moves in the next few rounds.
Interesting. Do you think he's going to be competitive with Stewart from here on in. I was thinking of bringing in Stewart this round but he could still lose some money over the next couple of rounds and is 30 as opposed to Dale at 26 who also hasn't missed any games in the last couple of years(?).
Dale might be a nice POD whose also 40 grand cheaper than Stewart with a nice upward scoring trend and a pleasing last round 136 sitting there, piqued my interest you have.
Dale might be a nice POD whose also 40 grand cheaper than Stewart with a nice upward scoring trend and a pleasing last round 136 sitting there
, piqued my interest you have.
Last edited:
- Joined
- 18 Sep 2012
- Messages
- 3,404
- Likes
- 7,197
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Joined
- 18 Sep 2012
- Messages
- 3,404
- Likes
- 7,197
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Will be going Davey > EVR
Plan is to go Liam Jones > Dawson next week ( ) so will need every $$$ I can find ASAP.
Haven't done the exact maths but should be able to get there with Jones/Baker/Mackenzie to Dawson/Williams/3rd rookie {Roberts/Johnson etc)
Otherwise Hopper/Setterfield would also be expendable depending on scores.
Plan is to go Liam Jones > Dawson next week (
) so will need every $$$ I can find ASAP. Haven't done the exact maths but should be able to get there with Jones/Baker/Mackenzie to Dawson/Williams/3rd rookie {Roberts/Johnson etc)
Otherwise Hopper/Setterfield would also be expendable depending on scores.
Who do I trade for him out of: Setters, JHF, Hopper, Ashcroft, Mackenzie, Baker, Phillips, Chandler, Pickett or Pou? They all have potentially 10s of thousands left in them, reducing the value of what JVR is offering if I trade prior to them topping out. A week later and sure, maybe Baker as he will probably have topped out. I'd also have one of the North guys going back, making my back rookies tradable. (Can't get at them for a forward at the moment.) If I trade one of the MPs, I'm bringing a rookie on field - something I'm trying to avoid.
JVR is bad timing for me. A week later, then sure, I'd give it a crack. This week I was more interested in getting Pickett though as he should be fieldable (moving Mackenzie to the bench) and will hopefully get me close to a premo in a month's time.
Thinking Johnson is still available next week in the mids. I'll lose out a bit if he goes up by more than say Baker, but it saves me a boost.
JVR is bad timing for me. A week later, then sure, I'd give it a crack. This week I was more interested in getting Pickett though as he should be fieldable (moving Mackenzie to the bench) and will hopefully get me close to a premo in a month's time.
Thinking Johnson is still available next week in the mids. I'll lose out a bit if he goes up by more than say Baker, but it saves me a boost.
With dpp changes next week I'm considering something different as my docherty trade. Which originally was docherty to Stewart.
I'm now thinking with the Davey out I can bring in Oliver. That means I need to to trade docherty to one of Wagner and Young and then field them as a D6 or take Cowans score.
I can then trade Davey to Oliver which takes one of Phillips or Mackenzie off field.
Thoughts?
That leads me to Young vs Wagner lol
I'm now thinking with the Davey out I can bring in Oliver. That means I need to to trade docherty to one of Wagner and Young and then field them as a D6 or take Cowans score.
I can then trade Davey to Oliver which takes one of Phillips or Mackenzie off field.
Thoughts?
That leads me to Young vs Wagner lol
