Strategy 2023: Player X v Player Y

[Ironhawk]

Knevitt v Humphrey

Knevitt vs Atkins

Too late for these two with Knevitt starting, but Atkins > Knevitt > Humphrey

 

[Montyjnr]

Who scores more over the next 2 weeks?

Worpel (Dees & Eagles) vs Ashcroft (Bombers & Suns)

 

[Ironhawk]

Who scores more over the next 2 weeks?

Worpel (Dees & Eagles) vs Ashcroft (Bombers & Suns)

Probably Ashcroft

 

[AverageJoe]

McKenna or Davey Jr to trade out? Trade plans for next week are starting to solidify and might save a boost by making the trade this week

 

[Ironhawk]

McKenna or Davey Jr to trade out? Trade plans for next week are starting to solidify and might save a boost by making the trade this week

If you are not fielding either, trade out McKenna, higher BE.

 

[Tamuhawk]

McKenna or Davey Jr to trade out? Trade plans for next week are starting to solidify and might save a boost by making the trade this week

I would trade Davey out.

 

[BarginHunter]

Oliver vs Bont vs Dawson vs English for C

 

[Ironhawk]

Oliver vs Bont vs Dawson vs English for C

Oliver usually seems to do well against the Hawks.

 

[whiteTiga2k]

B Smith (dogs) VS Whitfield VS McGrath

 

[Ironhawk]

B Smith (dogs) VS Whitfield VS McGrath

Smith

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Hopper to Rowell in 1 trade
OR
Hopper/Wilmot > Clarry/Rookie with 2

Yes I still don't have Oliver

 

[dicksilverman]

Hopper to Rowell in 1 trade
OR
Hopper/Wilmot > Clarry/Rookie with 2

Yes I still don't have Oliver

Clarry

 

[dicksilverman]

Shut down the Gulden negative POD or bring in Walsh and hope Gulden starts to fail (no disrespect to Gulden owners 😉)

 

[Russty_]

Shut down the Gulden negative POD or bring in Walsh and hope Gulden starts to fail (no disrespect to Gulden owners 😉)

He's only failed once this season with the 47, I wouldn't bet against him, Walsh would be very handy also and if he gets dpp.

 

[Ironhawk]

Hopper to Rowell in 1 trade
OR
Hopper/Wilmot > Clarry/Rookie with 2

Yes I still don't have Oliver

Oliver is probably the way to go - don't worry, I have only just picked him up recently too.

Shut down the Gulden negative POD or bring in Walsh and hope Gulden starts to fail (no disrespect to Gulden owners 😉)

Walsh is looking like being the #1 forward. I don't see his price getting out of hand though (BE 125). Gulden with a BE of 7 seems the go to me. He might fail, but hasn't shown many signs of it.

 

[Nothing]

Oliver is probably the way to go - don't worry, I have only just picked him up recently too.

Walsh is looking like being the #1 forward. I don't see his price getting out of hand though (BE 125). Gulden with a BE of 7 seems the go to me. He might fail, but hasn't shown many signs of it.

Gulden was averaging 90.7 after 6 rounds and people were considering trading him out. He's had 3 very good weeks to push that average to 108.3 and now he is a target. In my opinion, if you don't already have him, he will be available for cheaper at some point.

Walsh has kept his average consistent and at a level above Gulden (a privilege you're paying $50K for). He will lose some value because of price regression but if he gets FWD status I can't see how he misses out on top 2-3.

 

[Russty_]

Gulden was averaging 90.7 after 6 rounds and people were considering trading him out. He's had 3 very good weeks to push that average to 108.3 and now he is a target. In my opinion, if you don't already have him, he will be available for cheaper at some point.

Walsh has kept his average consistent and at a level above Gulden (a privilege you're paying $50K for). He will lose some value because of price regression but if he gets FWD status I can't see how he misses out on top 2-3.

He was averaging over 100 in the first 4 rounds and 99 at round 5, most people would've been very happy with that, one low score dragged his ave down for one week, two weeks later it's up to almost 110, anyone who was considering trading him out after one low score is nuts.

 

[Nothing]

He was averaging over 100 in the first 4 rounds and 99 at round 5, most people would've been very happy with that, one low score dragged his ave down for one week, two weeks later it's up to almost 110, anyone who was considering trading him out after one low score is nuts.

I agree, but people do strange things.

Is Gulden a 108 avg player, 100 or 91? I think he's closer to 100 than the other two, so is he a good trade now? Are there better value options?

If Gulden goes on to average 108 then he is good value now. If he regresses to his mean, he'll be available cheaper at some point.

 

[Russty_]

I agree, but people do strange things.

Is Gulden a 108 avg player, 100 or 91? I think he's closer to 100 than the other two, so is he a good trade now? Are there better value options?

If Gulden goes on to average 108 then he is good value now. If he regresses to his mean, he'll be available cheaper at some point.

I think he's still a bit of an unknown quantity at this stage, one thing's for sure though, he has a big ceiling on him, which can be fun to own

 

[mike89]

Prioritise Oliver or Walsh this week?