Opinion 2022: Player X v Player Y
- Thread starter Ben's Beasts
- Start date
Rematch, I pick Shiel too and Essendon
View: https://mobile.twitter.com/9NewsMelb/status/1526485738174414850
View: https://mobile.twitter.com/9NewsMelb/status/1526485738174414850
- Joined
- 3 Jul 2017
- Messages
- 37,343
- Likes
- 121,309
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
L Parker quite comfortably and ideally a midfielder such as Steele, etc instead, as Shiel should not feature in any considerations to occupy a valuable midfield spot, as too many points will be leaked.
Inconsistent and his ceiling is not high enough to compensate for the lows. Declining kick to handball ratio, disposal averages and time on ground whilst he is not noted for amassing a large amount of contested possessions and are all danger signs in this format. Improbable that he continues recording 7+ tackles to reach that 100 range and therefore will be reliant on those matches around the 30+ range which also did not translate to high Supercoach relevancy earlier in his career at GWS.
$100,000 cheaper with dual position status would be the only time I would consider Shiel for the remainder of his career.
Inconsistent and his ceiling is not high enough to compensate for the lows. Declining kick to handball ratio, disposal averages and time on ground whilst he is not noted for amassing a large amount of contested possessions and are all danger signs in this format. Improbable that he continues recording 7+ tackles to reach that 100 range and therefore will be reliant on those matches around the 30+ range which also did not translate to high Supercoach relevancy earlier in his career at GWS.
$100,000 cheaper with dual position status would be the only time I would consider Shiel for the remainder of his career.
I think Dawson is worth getting, a lot more consistent. Vlastuin seems to score better against the stronger sides rather than weaker ones, but would be an interesting POD.
Going to go for an Other here and say Tom Lynch. As per the above X v Y they have a good upcoming draw. Bit risky, but I think he's the best option in this range. Baker is a safer option from the same club, with a lower ceiling. Unfortunately Darcy Cameron is just out of your price range, as he would have been my suggestion.
Going to go for an Other here and say Tom Lynch. As per the above X v Y they have a good upcoming draw. Bit risky, but I think he's the best option in this range. Baker is a safer option from the same club, with a lower ceiling. Unfortunately Darcy Cameron is just out of your price range, as he would have been my suggestion.
I don't mind Hall. How lucky do you feel in terms of him staying injury free? Whitfield is not the worst alternative if you want to save some cash here.
Dawson & Petracca seems the better combo to me, although I note I was burned by starting Ridley earlier in the season, he has sightly improved since.
Dawson & Petracca seems the better combo to me, although I note I was burned by starting Ridley earlier in the season, he has sightly improved since.
- Joined
- 14 Jul 2020
- Messages
- 1,175
- Likes
- 2,115
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Yeah good point, completely forgot bulldogs were on tonight but should be fine as im leaning towards Witts
Only reason choosing Witts is his scorring this season plus the 50% ownership
Just worried that his next matchups are going to wreck him as the only 2 games he might keep his consistency is hawks and pies games
Only reason choosing Witts is his scorring this season plus the 50% ownership
Just worried that his next matchups are going to wreck him as the only 2 games he might keep his consistency is hawks and pies games