Discussion 2022: Rate My Team

Joined
18 Jul 2016
Messages
3,772
Likes
26,269
AFL Club
Sydney
Lucky we have @wogitalia here 😉

My understanding is Stephens is set to play wing/ taking Dawson’s position.
I can only scratch the surface of what Horse will do :LOL:

Honestly have no idea.

You can add Mills dealing with achilles issue and struggling for round 1. Basically means that right now we've got Parker from our 1st midfield unit fit and at the club and that we've got Rowbottom from the 2nd unit realistically.

First question is where in the midfield we plan to play Heeney. If it's inside, then I think he is a straight replacement for JPK and would expect them to essentially swap roles with JPK probably getting 30% midfield time. JPK is a solid forward, leads well and strong one on one mark with obviously great stoppage work. He's not Heeney for sure but Heeney should provide more dynamism in the midfield and we need that.

Stephens seems to be leading for a wing role, Dawson was the best wing in the league over the last 10 rounds last year so it's a big role to fill, Stephens does not have his size or kicking skills so there is no like for like going on, which is why I do suspect Heeney might play a lot of wing as we desperately need that midfield marking target type still. Stephens could end up inside as well, my comparison for him is kind of halfway between Macrae and Gaff, not going to hit their level this year though I wouldn't think, aka I'd be absolutely shocked if he did.

I would expect it would be Rowbottom to get the defensive role, assuming he's in the best 22 (I don't think he should be but that's another story) and realistically it's probably his best path to staying in the best 22, he's a team oriented guy and doesn't really have any tangible offensive skills but is a good contested player, basically the profile.

Logically that's the spots filled. I expect we could see an awful lot of Gulden through the middle and I wouldn't be at all surprised if he pushes premium numbers this year, his first year was among the best I've seen and he's got all the natural SC sloot skills, contested, tackles, elite kicking and he did all that in his first year and I don't know if I've ever seen Horse rave about o***eason improvement the way he has about Gulden. I'm excited to see it but it wouldn't surprise me if he has a very good role.

Midfield group is very speculative though right now. Mills is elite, Parker is somewhere around that and Heeney could be the best of the 3 if he's fit but it does fall away after that so if Gulden can step up to be the 4th, some JPK mixed in and I'm personally still hopeful that Warner is the 6th guy based on last year and that's a good group. With McInerney, Stephens and Florent manning the wings and hopefully some Heeney, I don't want him forward because he's less dangerous as a goal scorer when there.

Need to see how we go though, I think the backline is pretty settled, I expect we see Rampe, T. McCartin, Lloyd, Cunningham, Blakey with McInerney pushing through and whoever wins the 2nd KP role out of Reid, P. McCartin and Melican. Forwards I also think are fairly well set, be surprised if it's not Buddy, Ladhams, Papley, Hayward and JPK with whoever wins out of Reid, McDonald, McLean and Amartey as the 2nd KPF.

Looking forward to the matches for some clarity. Horse's biggest positive is he is almost always honest about roles, doesn't try and hide things in preseason and while not always a positive will stubbornly persist with things to ensure he's wrong before changing it which gives guys longer than they'd normally get in roles to work it out.

Stephens definitely in the mix and should have a good role if he makes the cut. Would expect he's an on-field level rookie pick, as essentially a mature ager he really should be capable of pushing 80 I'd think. From what I've seen he's a far more natural accumulator than Florent who pushes that region of scoring.
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
I can only scratch the surface of what Horse will do :LOL:

Honestly have no idea.

You can add Mills dealing with achilles issue and struggling for round 1. Basically means that right now we've got Parker from our 1st midfield unit fit and at the club and that we've got Rowbottom from the 2nd unit realistically.

First question is where in the midfield we plan to play Heeney. If it's inside, then I think he is a straight replacement for JPK and would expect them to essentially swap roles with JPK probably getting 30% midfield time. JPK is a solid forward, leads well and strong one on one mark with obviously great stoppage work. He's not Heeney for sure but Heeney should provide more dynamism in the midfield and we need that.

Stephens seems to be leading for a wing role, Dawson was the best wing in the league over the last 10 rounds last year so it's a big role to fill, Stephens does not have his size or kicking skills so there is no like for like going on, which is why I do suspect Heeney might play a lot of wing as we desperately need that midfield marking target type still. Stephens could end up inside as well, my comparison for him is kind of halfway between Macrae and Gaff, not going to hit their level this year though I wouldn't think, aka I'd be absolutely shocked if he did.

I would expect it would be Rowbottom to get the defensive role, assuming he's in the best 22 (I don't think he should be but that's another story) and realistically it's probably his best path to staying in the best 22, he's a team oriented guy and doesn't really have any tangible offensive skills but is a good contested player, basically the profile.

Logically that's the spots filled. I expect we could see an awful lot of Gulden through the middle and I wouldn't be at all surprised if he pushes premium numbers this year, his first year was among the best I've seen and he's got all the natural SC sloot skills, contested, tackles, elite kicking and he did all that in his first year and I don't know if I've ever seen Horse rave about o***eason improvement the way he has about Gulden. I'm excited to see it but it wouldn't surprise me if he has a very good role.

Midfield group is very speculative though right now. Mills is elite, Parker is somewhere around that and Heeney could be the best of the 3 if he's fit but it does fall away after that so if Gulden can step up to be the 4th, some JPK mixed in and I'm personally still hopeful that Warner is the 6th guy based on last year and that's a good group. With McInerney, Stephens and Florent manning the wings and hopefully some Heeney, I don't want him forward because he's less dangerous as a goal scorer when there.

Need to see how we go though, I think the backline is pretty settled, I expect we see Rampe, T. McCartin, Lloyd, Cunningham, Blakey with McInerney pushing through and whoever wins the 2nd KP role out of Reid, P. McCartin and Melican. Forwards I also think are fairly well set, be surprised if it's not Buddy, Ladhams, Papley, Hayward and JPK with whoever wins out of Reid, McDonald, McLean and Amartey as the 2nd KPF.

Looking forward to the matches for some clarity. Horse's biggest positive is he is almost always honest about roles, doesn't try and hide things in preseason and while not always a positive will stubbornly persist with things to ensure he's wrong before changing it which gives guys longer than they'd normally get in roles to work it out.

Stephens definitely in the mix and should have a good role if he makes the cut. Would expect he's an on-field level rookie pick, as essentially a mature ager he really should be capable of pushing 80 I'd think. From what I've seen he's a far more natural accumulator than Florent who pushes that region of scoring.
Interested in your thoughts on Ladhams, he's been in and out of my side thus far. I imagine he'll be suited to the smaller SCG. Do you envisage him getting much time in the ruck? As I've read that's where he'd like to play. What do you think he could average?
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,810
AFL Club
Collingwood
I like it. I know a lot of people seem to insist you need to start X gun midfielders to do well, but this is a good chance to score well enough elsewhere on field to prove that wrong.
I guess at the end of the day we have to follow the Round 1 rookies to determine our final sides/structures.

Just whether all those rookie mids can actually score enough to generate enough $$$.

Still seemingly easier to upgrade to D & F ultra premiums rather than ultra premium mids (especially if you would need 7 of them)

I guess with the anticipation of DPP for Daicos & JHF they could swap lines and a Coleman/Milera & Coniglio/Curnow then become a ultra premium mid

Forward rookies look scarce as (at this stage) , a few numbers look more promising in defence.

I still like Berry , Coleman , Coniglio , Curnow , Milera etc as starting picks so just need the right balance.

Those $ 450k forward options makes this interesting if they all do start hitting close to that 100 PPG average.
 
Last edited:
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,810
AFL Club
Collingwood
I know it is early days yet and the scratch matches will probably tell us more with rookies but I find as I tinker with my team that there are not that many dp rookies ending up in my mids. That is not to say there isn't dp rookies available it is just that when I structure up I find myself with the current preferred rookies in def or fwd. For example I have O'Driscoll and Chesser D5 and D6 at the moment. I could put one of them in the mids for flexibility but I have other rookies I want to play there and I get squeezed because they are all pure mids. Have noticed quite a few teams posted with no dp rookies in the mids. I like the flexibility of at least one dp rookie in the mids. Will see what the practice matches toss up. Will be interested to see what Ely Smith and Ned Long do. Sure I read Hollands is injured.
Currently have Sinn & O'Driscoll pencilled in on my mid bench , Chesser (& Dean) defender bench , like the linkage together and with Whitfield.

That is with my Hinge D6 side though (Kiddy starting forward)

Hollands has been "playing" with the possible side mostly in any case from what I have read , maybe that's to give him more CBA exposure though , even before his recent injury (not sure how severe)
 
Joined
14 Feb 2022
Messages
298
Likes
908
AFL Club
Collingwood
I can only scratch the surface of what Horse will do :LOL:

Honestly have no idea.

You can add Mills dealing with achilles issue and struggling for round 1. Basically means that right now we've got Parker from our 1st midfield unit fit and at the club and that we've got Rowbottom from the 2nd unit realistically.

First question is where in the midfield we plan to play Heeney. If it's inside, then I think he is a straight replacement for JPK and would expect them to essentially swap roles with JPK probably getting 30% midfield time. JPK is a solid forward, leads well and strong one on one mark with obviously great stoppage work. He's not Heeney for sure but Heeney should provide more dynamism in the midfield and we need that.

Stephens seems to be leading for a wing role, Dawson was the best wing in the league over the last 10 rounds last year so it's a big role to fill, Stephens does not have his size or kicking skills so there is no like for like going on, which is why I do suspect Heeney might play a lot of wing as we desperately need that midfield marking target type still. Stephens could end up inside as well, my comparison for him is kind of halfway between Macrae and Gaff, not going to hit their level this year though I wouldn't think, aka I'd be absolutely shocked if he did.

I would expect it would be Rowbottom to get the defensive role, assuming he's in the best 22 (I don't think he should be but that's another story) and realistically it's probably his best path to staying in the best 22, he's a team oriented guy and doesn't really have any tangible offensive skills but is a good contested player, basically the profile.

Logically that's the spots filled. I expect we could see an awful lot of Gulden through the middle and I wouldn't be at all surprised if he pushes premium numbers this year, his first year was among the best I've seen and he's got all the natural SC sloot skills, contested, tackles, elite kicking and he did all that in his first year and I don't know if I've ever seen Horse rave about o***eason improvement the way he has about Gulden. I'm excited to see it but it wouldn't surprise me if he has a very good role.

Midfield group is very speculative though right now. Mills is elite, Parker is somewhere around that and Heeney could be the best of the 3 if he's fit but it does fall away after that so if Gulden can step up to be the 4th, some JPK mixed in and I'm personally still hopeful that Warner is the 6th guy based on last year and that's a good group. With McInerney, Stephens and Florent manning the wings and hopefully some Heeney, I don't want him forward because he's less dangerous as a goal scorer when there.

Need to see how we go though, I think the backline is pretty settled, I expect we see Rampe, T. McCartin, Lloyd, Cunningham, Blakey with McInerney pushing through and whoever wins the 2nd KP role out of Reid, P. McCartin and Melican. Forwards I also think are fairly well set, be surprised if it's not Buddy, Ladhams, Papley, Hayward and JPK with whoever wins out of Reid, McDonald, McLean and Amartey as the 2nd KPF.

Looking forward to the matches for some clarity. Horse's biggest positive is he is almost always honest about roles, doesn't try and hide things in preseason and while not always a positive will stubbornly persist with things to ensure he's wrong before changing it which gives guys longer than they'd normally get in roles to work it out.

Stephens definitely in the mix and should have a good role if he makes the cut. Would expect he's an on-field level rookie pick, as essentially a mature ager he really should be capable of pushing 80 I'd think. From what I've seen he's a far more natural accumulator than Florent who pushes that region of scoring.
Great insight, do you think Heeney's role changing much when Mills returns?
 
Joined
17 Feb 2013
Messages
1,474
Likes
3,407
AFL Club
Collingwood
I do wish that Fly McRae and co would stop getting in the papers, telling everyone about Maynard going to the mid rotation...

1645403776624.png
5.6k left over.

I've got most of the high priced rookies covered. If one misses, I'll be looking to the likes of Reef McInnes at 123k who is bound to get games. He missed most of last year with a foot injury but has been getting talked up by the coaching panel a bit. Only concern is that a lot of his work will be down forward, though with us not playing Buckleyball anymore, our forwards should at least be seeing a bit more of it this year.

Finn Macrae will get games and will probably make some money. He's come back bigger and the panel wants him in the CS rotation so the 60s he was pulling late last year could go to 75+ which is his target at 207k. But damn I have a lot of Collingwood in the squad so far. I'm really hesitant to go for more.

DeGoey has missed a bit of match sim this week with his ribs but has been getting the kms in on the track which, frankly, is what he needs most. If I don't take him, I'll probably take a nice deep breath and go Heeney again. Jordy can miss games which sucks. Doesn't suck as much as Heeney pulling a 40 or 60 point game though which he has done too much of for my liking.

All going well, that should be 13 keepers + Cogs there with all but Steele of the ultra premos bought and paid for. (Love Touk Touk but he's gotta back it up to be worth that starting price). I've got all the marquee draftees that clubs will be wanting to parade before the members early in the year, some of whom have been copping glowing reports in their intraclubs. They are on field and so should hopefully outscore everyone else's on field rookie picks and they've already got 40k to 80k worth of price rises baked into their prices before the first price jump.

I've left room down back for 2 of Stewart, Dawson, Ridley and Ryan and getting 5 * 600k midfielders is easy enough with even just 30 trades. It leaves just 1 forward and maybe a Cogs upgrade.

2 Backs: 2 * 2.5 trades = 5 trades
2 top mids: 2 * 3 trades = 6 trades
3 Mids: 2 * 2.5 trades = 7.5 trades
1 forward: 2.5 trades
Cogs upgrade: 2 trades
Fully upgraded in 23 trades

Bearing in mind also that some of those expensive rookies might make it past 400k, I might be able to go one down one up to a premo in 2 trades. I think it's a decent set up.

Oh and for the cherry on top? My keepers are at 10/9+Cogs/7+Cogs for the bye rounds - 22/20/18 overall. I think this is how I need to start.
 
Joined
6 Mar 2013
Messages
10,190
Likes
31,121
AFL Club
Carlton
I do wish that Fly McRae and co would stop getting in the papers, telling everyone about Maynard going to the mid rotation...

View attachment 39681
5.6k left over.

I've got most of the high priced rookies covered. If one misses, I'll be looking to the likes of Reef McInnes at 123k who is bound to get games. He missed most of last year with a foot injury but has been getting talked up by the coaching panel a bit. Only concern is that a lot of his work will be down forward, though with us not playing Buckleyball anymore, our forwards should at least be seeing a bit more of it this year.

Finn Macrae will get games and will probably make some money. He's come back bigger and the panel wants him in the CS rotation so the 60s he was pulling late last year could go to 75+ which is his target at 207k. But damn I have a lot of Collingwood in the squad so far. I'm really hesitant to go for more.

DeGoey has missed a bit of match sim this week with his ribs but has been getting the kms in on the track which, frankly, is what he needs most. If I don't take him, I'll probably take a nice deep breath and go Heeney again. Jordy can miss games which sucks. Doesn't suck as much as Heeney pulling a 40 or 60 point game though which he has done too much of for my liking.

All going well, that should be 13 keepers + Cogs there with all but Steele of the ultra premos bought and paid for. (Love Touk Touk but he's gotta back it up to be worth that starting price). I've got all the marquee draftees that clubs will be wanting to parade before the members early in the year, some of whom have been copping glowing reports in their intraclubs. They are on field and so should hopefully outscore everyone else's on field rookie picks and they've already got 40k to 80k worth of price rises baked into their prices before the first price jump.

I've left room down back for 2 of Stewart, Dawson, Ridley and Ryan and getting 5 * 600k midfielders is easy enough with even just 30 trades. It leaves just 1 forward and maybe a Cogs upgrade.

2 Backs: 2 * 2.5 trades = 5 trades
2 top mids: 2 * 3 trades = 6 trades
3 Mids: 2 * 2.5 trades = 7.5 trades
1 forward: 2.5 trades
Cogs upgrade: 2 trades
Fully upgraded in 23 trades

Bearing in mind also that some of those expensive rookies might make it past 400k, I might be able to go one down one up to a premo in 2 trades. I think it's a decent set up.

Oh and for the cherry on top? My keepers are at 10/9+Cogs/7+Cogs for the bye rounds - 22/20/18 overall. I think this is how I need to start.
I'd be getting rid of Duncan, still got a calf issue and I don't think he is even training properly with the main group at Geelong. Going him to Heeney/Thomas allows you to go Rachele to Curnow as well, not sold on Rachele myself, a small forward in a bottom four side for $185k, not sure about it. Really like the structure of this team.
 
Joined
16 Jun 2013
Messages
5,465
Likes
11,297
AFL Club
Adelaide
I do wish that Fly McRae and co would stop getting in the papers, telling everyone about Maynard going to the mid rotation...

View attachment 39681
5.6k left over.

I've got most of the high priced rookies covered. If one misses, I'll be looking to the likes of Reef McInnes at 123k who is bound to get games. He missed most of last year with a foot injury but has been getting talked up by the coaching panel a bit. Only concern is that a lot of his work will be down forward, though with us not playing Buckleyball anymore, our forwards should at least be seeing a bit more of it this year.

Finn Macrae will get games and will probably make some money. He's come back bigger and the panel wants him in the CS rotation so the 60s he was pulling late last year could go to 75+ which is his target at 207k. But damn I have a lot of Collingwood in the squad so far. I'm really hesitant to go for more.

DeGoey has missed a bit of match sim this week with his ribs but has been getting the kms in on the track which, frankly, is what he needs most. If I don't take him, I'll probably take a nice deep breath and go Heeney again. Jordy can miss games which sucks. Doesn't suck as much as Heeney pulling a 40 or 60 point game though which he has done too much of for my liking.

All going well, that should be 13 keepers + Cogs there with all but Steele of the ultra premos bought and paid for. (Love Touk Touk but he's gotta back it up to be worth that starting price). I've got all the marquee draftees that clubs will be wanting to parade before the members early in the year, some of whom have been copping glowing reports in their intraclubs. They are on field and so should hopefully outscore everyone else's on field rookie picks and they've already got 40k to 80k worth of price rises baked into their prices before the first price jump.

I've left room down back for 2 of Stewart, Dawson, Ridley and Ryan and getting 5 * 600k midfielders is easy enough with even just 30 trades. It leaves just 1 forward and maybe a Cogs upgrade.

2 Backs: 2 * 2.5 trades = 5 trades
2 top mids: 2 * 3 trades = 6 trades
3 Mids: 2 * 2.5 trades = 7.5 trades
1 forward: 2.5 trades
Cogs upgrade: 2 trades
Fully upgraded in 23 trades

Bearing in mind also that some of those expensive rookies might make it past 400k, I might be able to go one down one up to a premo in 2 trades. I think it's a decent set up.

Oh and for the cherry on top? My keepers are at 10/9+Cogs/7+Cogs for the bye rounds - 22/20/18 overall. I think this is how I need to start.
I think you could make room for Crispy, Fin Mac and maybe Pendles and Kruges. Other than that, looks good. (y)
 
Joined
14 Jul 2020
Messages
1,192
Likes
2,132
AFL Club
Collingwood
My rough pre prac-match squad, havent bothered to change much up yet, although i have plans for it

Def- Lloyd, Stewart, Sicily, Coleman, Chesser, S.De Koning /Mcdonagh, Dean

Mid- Macrae, Steele, Oliver, Merrett, Neale, JHF, Daicos, Ward/ Erasmus, Hollands, Clark

Rucks- Grundy, Marshall/ Comben

Fwd-Thomas, Butters, Rayner, Cogs, Curnow, Maginness/Skinner, Butler

Most of the rookies are place holders,
Same with some of the MPs and Merrett

Would love some feedback of any sort
 
Joined
18 Jul 2016
Messages
3,772
Likes
26,269
AFL Club
Sydney
Interested in your thoughts on Ladhams, he's been in and out of my side thus far. I imagine he'll be suited to the smaller SCG. Do you envisage him getting much time in the ruck? As I've read that's where he'd like to play. What do you think he could average?
Not a fan for fantasy purposes. Really like him as a player but think he's 2nd ruck as he's the weaker ruck and much better forward.

If Hickey were to get hurt he'd be relevant though.

Next year or two when Hickey is done will be his time.

Great insight, do you think Heeney's role changing much when Mills returns?
Shouldn't do, both similar types of strong inside and outside mids that can mark and make good decisions. Wouldn't be shocked if we don't use them together a lot but would hope we have one of them always in the mix and would think often would be in together. The gap from the Parker/Heeney/Mills group to our 2nd group is pretty vast so definitely could see us balancing those three into the rotations, probably trying to keep 2 in at most times.

Still not 100% that Heeney plays inside though, could definitely take Dawson's wing role instead. Would still be a great role for him fantasy wise.
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,960
Likes
126,628
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
My rough pre prac-match squad, havent bothered to change much up yet, although i have plans for it

Def- Lloyd, Stewart, Sicily, Coleman, Chesser, S.De Koning /Mcdonagh, Dean

Mid- Macrae, Steele, Oliver, Merrett, Neale, JHF, Daicos, Ward/ Erasmus, Hollands, Clark

Rucks- Grundy, Marshall/ Comben

Fwd-Thomas, Butters, Rayner, Cogs, Curnow, Maginness/Skinner, Butler

Most of the rookies are place holders,
Same with some of the MPs and Merrett

Would love some feedback of any sort
Merrett is an interesting selection. Usually available around the $550,000 mark come the byes and others around a similar price range provide a higher upside and a greater return on investment as a starter.
 
Joined
14 Jul 2020
Messages
1,192
Likes
2,132
AFL Club
Collingwood
Merrett is an interesting selection. Usually available around the $550,000 mark come the byes and others around a similar price range provide a higher upside and a greater return on investment as a starter.
Yeah, purely picked him as a starter as a pod but then realised hes not in the same league as the others and the cash can be better spent elsewhere
 
Joined
18 Jul 2016
Messages
3,772
Likes
26,269
AFL Club
Sydney
Merrett is an interesting selection. Usually available around the $550,000 mark come the byes and others around a similar price range provide a higher upside and a greater return on investment as a starter.
Definitely looking at him as upgrade only right now. Talk of playing HB so could even end up a defender but that's a threat given his best work is inside and his ratio falls to pieces when not there.

Also struggles immensely with a tag and the aforementioned ratio issues mean he can put up stinkers more than most at that level do. I love him as a player but he's been available for less than 550k in each of the last 5 seasons, sometimes substantially less.

This is the first season in a while that I think I've accepted that he's not going 120+, so he'll probably finally do it after being in my starting side for I'm pretty sure the last 7 seasons :LOL:
 
Joined
9 Feb 2015
Messages
9,440
Likes
57,908
AFL Club
West Coast
What is his past SC record like?

States that he is picking Gould as he surely replaces Dawson .... Dawson was playing on a wing 2nd half of last season, he was the most damaging wingman in the game with his elite kicking into the fwd line last year.

Duncan at F1 despite calf issue, De Goey at F2 & no mention at all about the prospects of Butters :unsure: - a little surprising.
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
What is his past SC record like?

States that he is picking Gould as he surely replaces Dawson .... Dawson was playing on a wing 2nd half of last season, he was the most damaging wingman in the game with his elite kicking into the fwd line last year.

Duncan at F1 despite calf issue, De Goey at F2 & no mention at all about the prospects of Butters :unsure: - a little surprising.
Not too sure, he's probably waiting for the injury updates, re Gould, he is dreaming lol
 
Joined
17 Feb 2013
Messages
1,474
Likes
3,407
AFL Club
Collingwood
I'd be getting rid of Duncan, still got a calf issue and I don't think he is even training properly with the main group at Geelong. Going him to Heeney/Thomas allows you to go Rachele to Curnow as well, not sold on Rachele myself, a small forward in a bottom four side for $185k, not sure about it. Really like the structure of this team.
Thanks for the tip, Ant. I haven't been able to verify it anywhere though. Have you got a link?

I dropped Duncan for Heeney anyway to see what it looks like. I've been burned by Heeney before so would have to trust in him getting more midfield minutes. Was tempted by going to Thomas, especially after checking out their scratch match. He looks a really likely type now. But how far down the midfield pecking order is he? I'm already carrying Butters in that boat. At least DeGoey and Heeney project as being high up in the rotation

Anyway, the downgrade allows me to go Rachele to Brodie, who I think I like more than Curnow. Slightly lower injury risk maybe and Longmuir said Brodie was set for an inside mid role, which I'll take over tall forward any day. He got a knock to his hip a week or two ago but it was rated as minor and he's probably back from that already.

The downgrade also funded the upgrade from Greg Clark to D Stephens.

It looks a more solid side now, so thanks again
 
Joined
18 Jul 2016
Messages
3,772
Likes
26,269
AFL Club
Sydney
What is his past SC record like?

States that he is picking Gould as he surely replaces Dawson .... Dawson was playing on a wing 2nd half of last season, he was the most damaging wingman in the game with his elite kicking into the fwd line last year.

Duncan at F1 despite calf issue, De Goey at F2 & no mention at all about the prospects of Butters :unsure: - a little surprising.
Does anyone know where the whole Gould thing came from? He seems to constantly pop up and I just don't get it, there's never been an inkling over the last 3 years to suggest he was in the best 22 or even really that close to it and yet he's a constant in preseason teams of people that have at least done enough to have people asking their opinions.

Is it an inside joke that I just missed?
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
Thanks for the tip, Ant. I haven't been able to verify it anywhere though. Have you got a link?

I dropped Duncan for Heeney anyway to see what it looks like. I've been burned by Heeney before so would have to trust in him getting more midfield minutes. Was tempted by going to Thomas, especially after checking out their scratch match. He looks a really likely type now. But how far down the midfield pecking order is he? I'm already carrying Butters in that boat. At least DeGoey and Heeney project as being high up in the rotation

Anyway, the downgrade allows me to go Rachele to Brodie, who I think I like more than Curnow. Slightly lower injury risk maybe and Longmuir said Brodie was set for an inside mid role, which I'll take over tall forward any day. He got a knock to his hip a week or two ago but it was rated as minor and he's probably back from that already.

The downgrade also funded the upgrade from Greg Clark to D Stephens.

It looks a more solid side now, so thanks again
View: https://mobile.twitter.com/FantasyFreako/status/1494786190008274946
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
Does anyone know where the whole Gould thing came from? He seems to constantly pop up and I just don't get it, there's never been an inkling over the last 3 years to suggest he was in the best 22 or even really that close to it and yet he's a constant in preseason teams of people that have at least done enough to have people asking their opinions.

Is it an inside joke that I just missed?
It has now become a joke, as we've been waiting 3 years for him to debut. Apparently the dude that wrote the original article is thinking he'll play this year, or was it tongue in cheek.
 
Top