A few thoughts from last night having gone to the game:
Dogs:
It’s a bit strange to think that less than three games ago we were a goal or two away from icing a Grand Final, but here we are. It’s much the same really: an undersized defence, a largely one-way midfield, and conceding bulk HOtA.
Bont: doing what he can with the ankle, he’s always been largely quality over quantity, but that’s even more so the case now. Could be a sneaky chance for DPP.
Dunkley: like the team as a whole, much of the same. Plenty of the footy but lacking polish.
Dale and Daniel: the latter moved to the wing a bit to accomodate Richards, but not enough for it to be a cause for concern. Both should be good picks considering how often the ball will be down there.
English: fairly scored IMO. Think that’s around a base game for him.
Macrae: keeps on keeping on. Will have much better games, but thought he was just about our best.
Treloar: disposal might be lacking and he can run one-way at times, but at least the effort is there.
Carlton:
They’ve got a super list profile. Keys at both ends entering their prime, a solid midfield and pretty settled all over the ground. Only major queries at the moment is how long they can sustain it, and whether they e got enough polish in midfield.
Cripps: one of the things I noticed was that he wasn’t just lean, his conditioning looked superb. Clear best-on, and he’s now got support around him.
Curnow: looked good, but it was an undersized defence. Will probably have a few more of those games this season.
Hewett: wowee, the last time I can remember hands that good, Simon Black was running around. Pretty-much the prefect game for the role he was playing. Tidied-up a lot, gave cover and swept well - all while keeping accountable. Rated him at the Swans, but reckon there’s still an attacking layer to his game that can take him to the next level.
McGovern: this is a tricky one. Thought he was scored harshly, but could have also given away a couple of 50s. Role was good for an interceptor - was the corridor option at half-back, so could cover both sides if needed, but it also meant he hardly got involved in transition. Will move him on if there aren’t any other things needing addressing, but the big scores will come.
Walsh: didn’t notice him as much as I thought. Cobwebs were there and will be better for the run.