Discussion 2024 NFL DREAM TEAM Discussion

Joined
20 Mar 2016
Messages
2,507
Likes
9,694
AFL Club
St Kilda
If anyone is looking for a POD captain I think Gibbs could be a good choice.
In his 3 games without Montgomery he has scored 51, 45 and 48.
Admittedly, those games have been against teams very generous with their run defence.
But Gibbs scored 59 away to Minnesota in wk 07 with Montgomary playing.
This week he's at home to them.
It's ideal for looping as the last game of the week - although with all the outs there shouldn't be any difficulty finding a loop-hole.

I'v got Jackson as "vc" so I probably won't need a "c".
If, on the odd chance, I do I'm tossing up between Gibbs and Darnold.
Not that I necessarily expect Gibbs to out-score Darnold - just for fun.
 
Joined
6 Sep 2023
Messages
1,042
Likes
2,665
AFL Club
Brisbane
My strategy was to win as many finals as possible and utilize my trades for that purpose, making week 18 irrelevant to me.
Overall Ranking is relevant to those who do find it important enough.... I actual tend to go for both and find them important, but that is every coaches own choice.... ten d to do do that in all competitions I play
 
Joined
20 Mar 2016
Messages
2,507
Likes
9,694
AFL Club
St Kilda
41 enough with the vc? I might take it, or QB options in Daniels or Darnold.
I'm taking Jackson's 45.
Darnold might score more but it's a fragile "might".
His only significantly higher score is his 68 against Atlanta. His 52 last week is his only other score above 50.
But he has had 7 scores below 40 including scores of 10, 18 and 24.
He is facing a Detroit who are poor against QBs but he only scored 33 against them earlier in the year and the opposition strength doesn't seem to matter to him
His 18 was against Jacksonville who are usually kind to QBs.

I might be tempted to play Daniels, if I had him, given his recent form and Dallas opposition.

I'm reasonably happy with my team so I'm not ready to go for broke with my "c".
As @Under The Dome advises: with donuts in other lines it would be different.
 
Last edited:
Joined
21 Jan 2016
Messages
8,460
Likes
32,188
AFL Club
Collingwood
NFL Week 18 injuries and benchings: With playoff seeds on the line, who’s starting or sitting? - The Athletic
NFL Week 18 injuries and benchings: With playoff seeds on the line, who’s starting or sitting?

Here’s a look at each Week 18 matchup game-by-game and how potential playoff implications and seeding could play a role in those games.

Sunday
Panthers at Falcons, Sunday, 1 p.m. ET (CBS)
Playoff scenarios: To win the NFC South, the Falcons need to win and for the Buccaneers to lose.

What we know: The Falcons have their season on the line so their key offensive players are a full go. Panthers running back Miles Sanders (ankle) was designated to return to practice and activated off injured reserve.

Key injuries: Panthers running back Chuba Hubbard (calf) was placed on injured reserve last weekend. Sanders is listed as questionable, but with his activation off IR, he should be playing. Rookie wide receiver Xavier Legette (hip/wrist) is also listed as questionable. Falcons wide receiver Darnell Mooney (shoulder) is questionable, but expect him to be active with a division title at stake.

What could change: Both Atlanta and Tampa Bay play at the same time, so the NFC South will be decided after the opening slate of Sunday games.

Fantasy analysis: As expected, Raheem Blackshear led over Mike Boone in Week 17, but it matters not, as Boone saw a bit more passing game work, which renders both useless. In the passing game, though, Legette returned and stepped right back into the No. 2 role with nine targets, despite Jalen Coker seeing six more routes. — Jake Ciely

Commanders at Cowboys, Sunday, 1 p.m. ET (FOX)
Playoff scenarios: The Commanders lock down the NFC’s No. 6 seed with a win. A loss and a Packers win pushes Washington to the No. 7 seed and a third date with the Eagles on Super Wild Card Weekend.

What we know: Commanders coach Dan Quinn wants to secure the best playoff positioning for his squad and said of the team’s hold on the No. 6 seed, “We’re going to fight like hell to keep it.” Expect to see Jayden Daniels, Terry McLaurin, Zach Ertz and more in this one. Cowboys coach Mike McCarthy was coy with the media when asked which of Cooper Rush or Trey Lance will start in Week 18 and if both will play.

Key injuries: Commanders running back Austin Ekeler (concussion) was designated to return to practice from injured reserve and has been a full participant, but is questionable for Sunday. Ekeler was activated from IR Sunday, so expect him to suit up. Cowboys wide receiver CeeDee Lamb (shoulder) has already been ruled out for the final week.

What could change: Nothing as Quinn has indicated that Washington is all about locking down the No. 6 seed.

Fantasy analysis: With Ekeler off IR, he’s a decent flex option. But Brian Robinson Jr. is the lead back for the Commanders and is an RB2 with or without Ekeler. Without Lamb in Week 17, Cooks led all Dallas receivers with eight targets, four receptions and 52 receiving yards, but Jalen Tolbert caught the Cowboys’ only touchdown. Cooks can be flexed in more desperate situations.

Bears at Packers, Sunday, 1 p.m. ET (FOX)
Playoff scenarios: The Packers are already in the NFC playoff field, but a win and Commanders loss moves them to the No. 6 seed. A loss or Commanders win leaves them at the No. 7 seed.

What we know: Packers coach Matt LaFleur said Wednesday the team’s healthy players will play in Week 18 as he sees value in having them play and play well. That means Jordan Love at quarterback and Josh Jacobs in the backfield as Green Bay gets ready for the playo***.

Key injuries: Packers wide receiver Christian Watson (knee bruise) got in a limited session Friday and is listed as questionable after missing Week 17.

What could change: Nothing likely before game time, especially since Green Bay and Washington play at the same time, but there is the potential that the Packers get up big on a Bears team with 10 straight losses and elect to pull Love and Jacobs and roll with backups at some point.

Fantasy analysis: Predicting who of the Packers’ receivers will produce for fantasy purposes is an impossible task. But in Week 17, Romeo Doubs was the most-targeted receiver (by far), with 11 targets for seven receptions and 58 yards. Dontayvion Wicks saw five targets while Jayden Reed saw four, and none of them had a touchdown reception. Watson’s injury or availability doesn’t impact this target share scenario too much.

Texans at Titans, Sunday, 1 p.m. ET (CBS)
Playoff scenarios: The Texans are locked into the No. 4 seed and have won the AFC South.

What we know: Titans quarterback Will Levis will start Sunday, but coach Brian Callahan said Mason Rudolph will also get some time in the season finale. Despite Houston’s seeding being secure, coach DeMeco Ryans indicated again Wednesday that his starters will play coming off a brutal loss to the Ravens — although how much they will play remains an open question and could depend on “how the game goes.”

Key injuries: Titans running back Tony Pollard (ankle) did not practice Friday after limited sessions Wednesday and Thursday, while Tyjae Spears (concussion) is out. Kicker Nick Folk (abdomen) is also out, so Matthew Wright will handle those duties. Though not injury-related, expect to see wide receiver Diontae Johnson make his Houston debut after being claimed off waivers last week.

What could change: Pollard’s status bares monitoring. If he can’t go, third-year back Julius Chestnut would be the next man up.

Fantasy analysis: No matter the quarterback, Calvin Ridley is the only reliable option. That includes Pollard being a major risk, missing Week 17, and with Spears out. — Ciely
 
Joined
21 Jan 2016
Messages
8,460
Likes
32,188
AFL Club
Collingwood
Jaguars at Colts, Sunday, 1 p.m. ET (FOX)
Playoff scenarios: There are no playoff stakes in this contest.

What we know: Both teams are finishing out the season in this one. Colts quarterback Anthony Richardson will be out for this one and Joe Flacco will start for Indianapolis.

Key injuries: Richardson (back spasms/soreness, foot) is out for the second straight week after not practicing.

What could change: Now that we know its Flacco at QB, not much. Both teams are looking to close out the season and move on to preparing for the 2025 season.

Fantasy analysis: Josh Downs is the Colts receiver to consider flexing. He is the Colts’ most-targeted wide receiver with 7.23 targets per game, followed by Michael Pittman Jr. with 6.73.

Bills at Patriots, Sunday, 1 p.m. ET (CBS)
Playoff scenarios: The Bills have nailed down the No. 2 seed in the AFC.

What we know: Buffalo quarterback and MVP candidate Josh Allen will start to keep his consecutive starts streak intact (114, counting the postseason) before quickly giving way to backup QB Mitch Trubisky. The same could be said for other skill players on Buffalo like running back James Cook and wide receiver Khalil Shakir. Bills coach Sean McDermott said Monday the team’s active roster will be a blend of starters and depth players they want to get an extended look at in a game setting. Patriots rookie quarterback Drake Maye is expected to playeven if there is a case to be made to not play him. A loss clinches the No. 1 pick for New England in the 2025 NFL Draft.

Key injuries: Despite OC Alex Van Pelt saying he’ll play, Maye (right hand) was limited all week and is listed as questionable. Patriots tight end Hunter Henry (foot) has been limited too. Bills wide receiver Curtis Samuel (rib) is questionable. Amari Cooper (personal) has been ruled out.

What could change: Sixth-round pick Joe Milton III has taken some first-team reps this week, so its possible Maye won’t play the whole way.

Fantasy analysis: The Patriots rank near the bottom of the league in most defensive stats, so Trubisky could be a QB2 in Superflex leagues this week. There’s really no reason for the Bills to play Cook. Ray Davis should be the lead back with Cook out, and he could be a decent flex option against New England. It’s a wait-and-see approach for Bills receivers. If Cooper and Shakir sit, Keon Coleman could be a sneaky flex play this week. While Henry (who could sit) is fantasy’s TE12 this year (145.4 PPR points), his 9.09 points per game are easy enough to replace with someone like Pat Freiermuth, Chig Okonkwo, Noah Gray or Mike Gesicki, one of whom should be available in free agency.

Giants at Eagles, Sunday, 1 p.m. ET (CBS)
Playoff scenarios: The Eagles are locked into the No. 2 seed in the NFC.

What we know: As it stands now, Tanner McKee looks to be in line to start for Philadelphia in a game that will do nothing to change their playoff seeding. Coach Nick Sirianni said Wednesday he will be resting some of his starters and one of those will probably be running back Saquon Barkley, who is 100 yards shy of tying Eric Dickerson’s rushing record. Star wide receivers A.J. Brown (knee) and DeVonta Smith (wrist) also look likely to get the game off as they are listed as doubtful. Much of the team’s first-string defense and offensive line are likely to sit or play limited amounts. On the other hand, tight end Dallas Goedert (knee) had his practice window opened in Week 18 and carries no injury designation.

Key injuries: Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts (concussion) remains in the concussion protocol and is out. Backup QB Kenny Pickett (ribs) did not practice this week and is questionable.

What could change: Who starts for Philadelphia will likely not be known until later this week, but all signs point to McKee.

Fantasy analysis: Hurts was unable to play in Week 17 as he was in concussion protocol, so he will sit in a meaningless game to rest up for the playo***. After Pickett left with a rib injury last week, McKee went 3-for-4 with two touchdown passes. If Brown and Smith both sit, there’s no reason to risk playing another Eagles WR with so many unknowns.

Saints at Buccaneers, Sunday, 1 p.m. ET (FOX)
Playoff scenarios: With a win or tie, the Buccaneers take the NFC South. With a loss, Tampa Bay needs Atlanta to also lose or tie to clinch the division.

What we know: Tampa Bay controls its path to a playoff spot and quarterback Baker Mayfield will look to keep rolling with 14 touchdowns in his last four games. After a full session Friday, rookie running back Bucky Irving was off of the injury report. The Saints have had a ton of offensive injuries and may be relying on recent pickup Clyde Edwards-Helaire to carry the backfield load with rookie quarterback Spencer Rattler under center.

Key injuries: Despite being limited in practice the last two days, Buccaneers tight end Cade Otton (knee) is listed as doubtful. Wide receiver Sterling Shepard (hamstring) is questionable. Saints wide receiver Chris Olave (concussion) continues to be a full practice participant and is listed as questionable and tight end Juwan Johnson (knee) is also questionable. Running back Alvin Kamara (groin) is tagged as doubtful, while RB Kendre Miller (concussion) quarterback Derek Carr (left hand) are both out.

What could change: Both Tampa Bay and Atlanta play at the same time, so the NFC South will be decided in Sunday’s early window.

Fantasy analysis: With Miller sidelined, Edwards-Helaire goes from, “Did you know he was on the Saints?” to, “Man, I might need CEH as a Flex RB in Week 18.” — Ciely

Irving has been rolling and is an RB1 this week. Since Week 6, Irving has averaged 16.97 PPR points and has gone over 100 yards rushing three times.

Chiefs at Broncos, Sunday, 4:25 p.m. ET (CBS)
Playoff scenarios: The Chiefs nailed down the AFC’s No. 1 seed and the first-round bye in Week 17. The Broncos need a win or tie to get in or losses/ties from the Dolphins and Bengals.

What we know: Chiefs coach Andy Reid tends to rest his stars in the final week of the season with a playoff berth/positioning secured — something that has become commonplace for Kansas City — and that will once again be the case. Quarterback Patrick Mahomes, tight end Travis Kelce, running back Kareem Hunt and multiple key defensive players are listed as doubtful. Carson Wentz is starting at QB for the Chiefs. For Denver, their season is on the line, so expect all their main cogs to be in the lineup.

Key injuries: Chiefs running back Isiah Pacheco (ribs) is out after not practicing all week and missing the latter part of the Week 17 win over the Steelers. Mahomes has been battling an ankle injury and an extra week of rest should do him some good. Wide receiver Mecole Hardman (knee) is out after having his practice window opened Wednesday

What could change: Nothing. While Cincinnati plays Saturday, Miami will take the field at the same time as Denver so the final AFC wild card will be determined in the late afternoon window.

Fantasy analysis: The Broncos are ranked second in yards per play allowed and yards per rush allowed and sixth in net yards per attempt allowed. While they are ranked 25th in passing yards per game allowed, trusting Wentz against Denver, which needs a win to get into the playo***, is tough. Kelce is aging and is the perfect rest candidate in Week 18, but the Chiefs love throwing to their tight ends. Noah Gray could see a lot of work and score some solid fantasy points. With Pacheco out and Hunt doubtful, expect the Chiefs backfield to be split between Samaje Perine and Carson Steele.
 
Top