Discussion 2024 Round 8: Teams & In Game Discussion

Joined
19 Jun 2013
Messages
1,362
Likes
3,865
AFL Club
Carlton
How good would that be, if your player is subbed out can replace with you E if you choose. Would be like having your own sub in SC.
Would just eliminate a little bit of the bad luck that comes with this game. You are most likely only replacing with a rookie so doesn't give you a huge boost, but will give a little more interest in how you build your bench, especially later in the season. Yes you may still have to trade the player, but allows you to maintain a competitive score still.
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
39,512
Likes
128,600
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Excellent. Was still entertaining the Roberts to Moore trade over the Rogers inclusion before the Thomas sub news. Kept Dempsey and traded Cadman to allow the Wilson loop with Garcia at F6 (instead of Cadman). To top it off watch Thomas outscore Roberts and Green combined and beat his breakeven. :ROFLMAO:
Time for some fun now with Green subbed out, rather than watching the second half.
IMG_3034.jpeg
 
Joined
23 Mar 2019
Messages
2,150
Likes
7,046
33 touches for 91 points is a good SC game to you? I've owned Walsh before and he often doesn't score as well as his stats suggest he should. He picks up a lot of meaningless touches.
Wasn't suggesting this was a great outcome, but on average his game is fine. In the last 4-5 years he's averaged maybe 4 games <100 every year.

Bontompelli, who has without doubt been the gold standard for midfield consistency for this period, has still thrown in at least 1 below 90 every year. (Already a 73 this year). It happens to everyone. Tom Green is the flavour of 2024 and has 2 * <85 in the last 3 etc. If Walsh throws in a couple in the 90s, that's just the reality of life I reckon. We have very high standards, but everyone has poor games. Hopefully 90ish is Walsh's floor. That would be fantastic.

Edit:posted before I realised the Green situation. Eeek.
 
Joined
18 Sep 2012
Messages
3,405
Likes
7,197
AFL Club
Essendon
Wasn't suggesting this was a great outcome, but on average his game is fine. In the last 4-5 years he's averaged maybe 4 games <100 every year.

Bontompelli, who has without doubt been the gold standard for midfield consistency for this period, has still thrown in at least 1 below 90 every year. (Already a 73 this year). It happens to everyone. Tom Green is the flavour of 2024 and has 2 * <85 in the last 3 etc. If Walsh throws in a couple in the 90s, that's just the reality of life I reckon. We have very high standards, but everyone has poor games. Hopefully 90ish is Walsh's floor. That would be fantastic.
As I said, I've owned Walsh before and I've seen him have plenty of games that should be 125+ that end up being 100-110 (specifically last year).. He often doesn't maximise scoring from his touches the way other premium midfielders do. He handballs a lot and is usually good for a couple of clanger kicks under no pressure each game. Not saying he's a bad pick or anything, just maybe not a must-have SC player.
 
Last edited:
Joined
15 Feb 2021
Messages
1,322
Likes
5,438
AFL Club
Geelong
Green & Rozee down = disaster round for us owners!
Got Williams to deal with as well :eek:
 
Top