Discussion BBL|10 SC: Team & In-Game Discussion - Home of #1 and #2 Leagues
- Thread starter Goodie's Guns
- Start date
Still have Richardson , Lalor & Boyce.
+ 1 of Prestwidge/Evans/Perry until Sutherland is available.
Rd 4 onwards though who misses out ? and why sign them if you are not playing them every game
seems weird to me
if Finch , SOS & Roussow all get going together early they might not even worry who they have to bowl 😀
+ 1 of Prestwidge/Evans/Perry until Sutherland is available.
Rd 4 onwards though who misses out ? and why sign them if you are not playing them every game
seems weird to me
if Finch , SOS & Roussow all get going together early they might not even worry who they have to bowl 😀
- Joined
- 6 Jan 2013
- Messages
- 19,512
- Likes
- 82,867
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Okay so I think this is how things work. Feel free to correct me if you think I'm wrong..
Scorchers batting first with Turner on field in SC and he's subbed out as part of the x-factor rule, his score WILL NOT count and your emergency will count instead.
Scorchers bowling first with Turner on field in SC and he's subbed out as part of the x-factor rule, his score WILL count.
Any player who is subbed in as part of the x-factor rule WILL score points.
Sub fielders WILL NOT score points.
Scorchers batting first with Turner on field in SC and he's subbed out as part of the x-factor rule, his score WILL NOT count and your emergency will count instead.
Scorchers bowling first with Turner on field in SC and he's subbed out as part of the x-factor rule, his score WILL count.
Any player who is subbed in as part of the x-factor rule WILL score points.
Sub fielders WILL NOT score points.
- Joined
- 6 Jan 2013
- Messages
- 19,512
- Likes
- 82,867
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Here we go. The exact definition below which is exactly what I had mentioned a few posts above;
"Points are awarded based on a participant’s Starting 11 players and any “emergency” who replaces a member of the participant’s Starting 11. An emergency will also replace a player who is named in the starting 11 for the team batting first, but is substituted OUT of the match under the X-Factor supersub rule. The player being substituted IN and ALL substituted players from the team bowling first will not be replaced by emergencies and will be deemed to have played in the match.
A substitute who comes on and off the field temporarily (i.e. fielding) in a match will NOT be deemed to have played, and will NOT be awarded any points."
"Points are awarded based on a participant’s Starting 11 players and any “emergency” who replaces a member of the participant’s Starting 11. An emergency will also replace a player who is named in the starting 11 for the team batting first, but is substituted OUT of the match under the X-Factor supersub rule. The player being substituted IN and ALL substituted players from the team bowling first will not be replaced by emergencies and will be deemed to have played in the match.
A substitute who comes on and off the field temporarily (i.e. fielding) in a match will NOT be deemed to have played, and will NOT be awarded any points."
That could have been worded better .... that very first sentence to me actually makes it confusing ....
- Probably should have used and any “emergency” who replaces a member of the participant’s Starting 11 that did not play etc .... as per usual ...
The other thing I'm still confused about ..... does the player that was a temporary "substituted" out receive any points by the temporary substitute ...
- Ie. Player A goes for a couple of overs, Player B replaces him and takes a catch. Does player A receive the points instead or are none awarded at all ???
- Wasn't it David Willey ?? who got injured in the warm up, never took part in the match but got awarded points for a catch he never took because he was listed in the starting XI ...
- Probably should have used and any “emergency” who replaces a member of the participant’s Starting 11 that did not play etc .... as per usual ...
The other thing I'm still confused about ..... does the player that was a temporary "substituted" out receive any points by the temporary substitute ...
- Ie. Player A goes for a couple of overs, Player B replaces him and takes a catch. Does player A receive the points instead or are none awarded at all ???
- Wasn't it David Willey ?? who got injured in the warm up, never took part in the match but got awarded points for a catch he never took because he was listed in the starting XI ...
Last edited:
Ingram subbed off for 0, replaced by Turner (E) subbed off for 0 different games, same round
Onfield donut as C to take VC score so you could end up with 2 donuts each round
or 3 if your bowler and bowler E are subbed off as well in the same round in the first innings
Might have to pick Bairstow to play it safe
Onfield donut as C to take VC score so you could end up with 2 donuts each round
or 3 if your bowler and bowler E are subbed off as well in the same round in the first innings
Might have to pick Bairstow to play it safe
Last edited:
Ingram subbed off for 0, replaced by Turner (E) subbed off for 0 different games, same round
Onfield donut as C to take VC score so you could end up with 2 donuts each round
or 3 if your bowler and bowler E are subbed off as well in the same round in the first innings
Might have to pick Bairstow to play it safe
Onfield donut as C to take VC score so you could end up with 2 donuts each round
or 3 if your bowler and bowler E are subbed off as well in the same round in the first innings
Might have to pick Bairstow to play it safe
- Joined
- 18 May 2015
- Messages
- 425
- Likes
- 1,219
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
the way i read it every starting 11 or X factor player who takes the field is deemed to have participated in the match and as a result their score will count.
so the only way a player will be regarded as a non playing donut is if they bat first and are subbed out without getting a hit (or fielding obviously)
sub fielders will not count
so the only way a player will be regarded as a non playing donut is if they bat first and are subbed out without getting a hit (or fielding obviously)
sub fielders will not count
Ingram subbed off for 0, replaced by Turner (E) subbed off for 0 different games, same round
Onfield donut as C to take VC score so you could end up with 2 donuts each round
or 3 if your bowler and bowler E are subbed off as well in the same round in the first innings
Might have to pick Bairstow to play it safe
Onfield donut as C to take VC score so you could end up with 2 donuts each round
or 3 if your bowler and bowler E are subbed off as well in the same round in the first innings
Might have to pick Bairstow to play it safe
However the other two I am ....
- Quite a few running with Holt, Pfeffer etc but what if your other Keeper gets subbed out .... unlikely but not impossible ...
- But it's the bowling line I'm most concerned about .... doesn't bowl (0) or bowls one over and gets tonked (- points) ... not a thing you can do if they are one of your on field players and get subbed out as the score will stand
- However if they are an E and you have another E selected on the same bench then you may be able to get out of trouble ... time to review my bowling setup ...
Last edited:
- Joined
- 18 May 2015
- Messages
- 425
- Likes
- 1,219
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Yeah I guess if you have a batsmen subbed out in the first game, you might have 2 choices available as the E.
I could see Holt & Pfeffer being subbed in if their team has bowled first and they then need to chase something down significantly (both sides probably have 6 bowling options)
Scorchers have keeping options that will play, so do the Hurricanes.
Stanlake could get smashed on his first over, no dot balls , a nb or a wide and off he goes.
How do you plan though for possible subs over the course of 61 games for what may or may not happen regularly ?
I could see Holt & Pfeffer being subbed in if their team has bowled first and they then need to chase something down significantly (both sides probably have 6 bowling options)
Scorchers have keeping options that will play, so do the Hurricanes.
Stanlake could get smashed on his first over, no dot balls , a nb or a wide and off he goes.
How do you plan though for possible subs over the course of 61 games for what may or may not happen regularly ?
Agree ... but you'd imagine if Holt or Pfeffer got subbed in then it was for a reason .... pinch hitters etc ....
TBH I don't have the answers ... just running through some scenarios with how strong a bench I might need to have at the moment ...
- only really got 2 players in my team that I would consider being at risk of being subbed out at the moment so don't need to change anything just yet ...
TBH I don't have the answers ... just running through some scenarios with how strong a bench I might need to have at the moment ...
- only really got 2 players in my team that I would consider being at risk of being subbed out at the moment so don't need to change anything just yet ...
Last edited: