Discussion JLT Community Series 2019 Week 1 Teams and In Game Discussions
- Thread starter KLo30
- Start date
Supercoach Scores
CARLTON
P. Cripps 124
W. Setterfield 113
S. Walsh 102
D. Cuningham 100
N. Newman 97
J. Weitering 92
D. Thomas 88
S. Petrevski 86
A. Phillips 81
E. Curnow 75
Z. Fisher 72
H. McKay 71
M. Gibbons 68
P. Dow 65
K. Simpson 62
C. Curnow 62
M. Murphy 61
J. Garlett 54
J. Silvagni 50
M. Lobbe 43
L. Jones 42
L. Plowman 38
M. McGovern 27
C. Polson 22
A. Schumacher 4
ESSENDON
J. Ridley 97
M. Brown 97
J. Stringer 93
Z. Clarke 89
A. Francis 85
A. McGrath 85
A. McDonald-Tipungwuti 82
M. Hartley 82
C. McKenna 80
A. Saad 79
D. Zaharakis 79
P. Ambrose 72
M. Guelfi 64
M. Hurley 61
J. Long 56
D. Heppell 56
D. Smith 54
D. Shiel 50
D. Parish 44
J. Laverde 41
K. Langford 35
J. Daniher 35
Z. Merrett 27
M. Baguley 25
T. Jok 22
S. McKernan 10
CARLTON
P. Cripps 124
W. Setterfield 113
S. Walsh 102
D. Cuningham 100
N. Newman 97
J. Weitering 92
D. Thomas 88
S. Petrevski 86
A. Phillips 81
E. Curnow 75
Z. Fisher 72
H. McKay 71
M. Gibbons 68
P. Dow 65
K. Simpson 62
C. Curnow 62
M. Murphy 61
J. Garlett 54
J. Silvagni 50
M. Lobbe 43
L. Jones 42
L. Plowman 38
M. McGovern 27
C. Polson 22
A. Schumacher 4
ESSENDON
J. Ridley 97
M. Brown 97
J. Stringer 93
Z. Clarke 89
A. Francis 85
A. McGrath 85
A. McDonald-Tipungwuti 82
M. Hartley 82
C. McKenna 80
A. Saad 79
D. Zaharakis 79
P. Ambrose 72
M. Guelfi 64
M. Hurley 61
J. Long 56
D. Heppell 56
D. Smith 54
D. Shiel 50
D. Parish 44
J. Laverde 41
K. Langford 35
J. Daniher 35
Z. Merrett 27
M. Baguley 25
T. Jok 22
S. McKernan 10
- Joined
- 15 Oct 2018
- Messages
- 3,912
- Likes
- 12,177
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Looked the same to me, he put on about 3kg of muscle between 2017 and 2018 and I was hoping he'd actually lose some of that because he'd lost some of his zip in the process. Essendon haven't updated their players weights on their website since the start of 2017, Merrett looked noticeably bigger in the JLT of 2018 and I kept checking to see an update but it never came. Champion Data must receive the clubs more recent information because they list him at 83kg in the 2019 prospectus, 3 kilos heavier than he is on our website and 3 kilos heavier than in the 2018 prospectus.
- Joined
- 18 Jan 2016
- Messages
- 735
- Likes
- 2,127
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
What I got for that game -
No to Zerrett
Lock in Walsh, Setters and Cripps
Newman - into consideration, his TOG was up 14% on last year and looks to be playing the Doch role. Im not sure whether to be concerned if Williamson takes his spot, anyone think he'll stay best 22?
McGrath - Wasnt ever going to pick him but not the worst selection.
No to Zerrett
Lock in Walsh, Setters and Cripps
Newman - into consideration, his TOG was up 14% on last year and looks to be playing the Doch role. Im not sure whether to be concerned if Williamson takes his spot, anyone think he'll stay best 22?
McGrath - Wasnt ever going to pick him but not the worst selection.
Loving AFLratings this preseason
Carlton 100 v Essendon 91
Ikon Park, February 28
Carlton had an overwhelming number of Inside 50s early in the first half, Essendon scored a number of Goals over the back of the Carlton defensive structure.
Article by @aflratingsPete
Player Notes (Not all players covered)
Patrick Cripps
Was extremely dominant finishing with a game high 20 Contested Possessions, had his knee strapped but that is now a trade mark for Crippa. Looked great!
Sam Walsh
What a jet, found time & space inside traffic, was clean with his ball handling, recorded 28 Disposals.
Nic Newman
Found a perfect scoring role in defence, recorded 17 Disposals in the opening 3 QTRS.
Zac Fisher
Worked hard & found a heap of the ball finishing with 26 Disposals .
Will Setterfield
Settled in nicely for the Blues, scored at a high rate, automatic Round 1 selection.
Sam Petrovski-Seton
Fast start by SPS but similar to last week slowed down late in the game, copped a knock midway through the game which may have impacted.
Michael Gibbons
Kicked 3 Goals as a small Forward, may have been a slow grind if he didn’t hit the scoreboard finishing with 9 Disposals.
Kade Simpson
Played 87% game time to finish with 14 Disposals, the Nic Newman role likely impacted.
? JLT Series 1 Injuries
Andrew McGrath
Exploded late in the game winning the ball with ease, was able to get to contest after contest while others laboured in the heat. Very impressive!
Zac Clarke
Outstanding game in the Ruck, Bombers looked more dynamic in the middle of the ground with Clarke, definitely something to consider for Worsfold.
Dylan Shiel
Started to score well then copped a leg cork early in Q4 & didn’t return.
David Zaharakis
Slow day for Zaharakis finishing with 18 Disposals from 86% game time.
Dyson Heppell
Played the 1st half only, looked solid.
Devon Smith
Showed no impact from a recent bicep injury, played the 2nd half only, recorded 12 Disposals & 2 Tackles
Zach Merrett
Was quiet finishing with 7 Disposals, played in the first half only.
Team Disposals
Carlton 360
Essendon 350
Top Scorers
Carlton
115 Patrick Cripps
100 Sam Walsh
97 Nic Newman
Essendon
104 Andrew McGrath
104 Zac Clarke
92 Jordan Ridley
Points Per Game Time Leaders
Carlton
1.34 Patrick Cripps
1.30 Will Setterfield
1.25 Sam Walsh, Zac Fisher
Essendon
1.35 Andrew McGrath
1.28 Dyson Heppell
1.20 Dylan Shiel
Carlton 100 v Essendon 91
Ikon Park, February 28
Carlton had an overwhelming number of Inside 50s early in the first half, Essendon scored a number of Goals over the back of the Carlton defensive structure.
Article by @aflratingsPete
Player Notes (Not all players covered)
Patrick Cripps
Was extremely dominant finishing with a game high 20 Contested Possessions, had his knee strapped but that is now a trade mark for Crippa. Looked great!
Sam Walsh
What a jet, found time & space inside traffic, was clean with his ball handling, recorded 28 Disposals.
Nic Newman
Found a perfect scoring role in defence, recorded 17 Disposals in the opening 3 QTRS.
Zac Fisher
Worked hard & found a heap of the ball finishing with 26 Disposals .
Will Setterfield
Settled in nicely for the Blues, scored at a high rate, automatic Round 1 selection.
Sam Petrovski-Seton
Fast start by SPS but similar to last week slowed down late in the game, copped a knock midway through the game which may have impacted.
Michael Gibbons
Kicked 3 Goals as a small Forward, may have been a slow grind if he didn’t hit the scoreboard finishing with 9 Disposals.
Kade Simpson
Played 87% game time to finish with 14 Disposals, the Nic Newman role likely impacted.
? JLT Series 1 Injuries
Andrew McGrath
Exploded late in the game winning the ball with ease, was able to get to contest after contest while others laboured in the heat. Very impressive!
Zac Clarke
Outstanding game in the Ruck, Bombers looked more dynamic in the middle of the ground with Clarke, definitely something to consider for Worsfold.
Dylan Shiel
Started to score well then copped a leg cork early in Q4 & didn’t return.
David Zaharakis
Slow day for Zaharakis finishing with 18 Disposals from 86% game time.
Dyson Heppell
Played the 1st half only, looked solid.
Devon Smith
Showed no impact from a recent bicep injury, played the 2nd half only, recorded 12 Disposals & 2 Tackles
Zach Merrett
Was quiet finishing with 7 Disposals, played in the first half only.
Team Disposals
Carlton 360
Essendon 350
Top Scorers
Carlton
115 Patrick Cripps
100 Sam Walsh
97 Nic Newman
Essendon
104 Andrew McGrath
104 Zac Clarke
92 Jordan Ridley
Points Per Game Time Leaders
Carlton
1.34 Patrick Cripps
1.30 Will Setterfield
1.25 Sam Walsh, Zac Fisher
Essendon
1.35 Andrew McGrath
1.28 Dyson Heppell
1.20 Dylan Shiel
Don’t you love JLT? Players who you hadn’t considered up until this point suddenly end up in your side 
Newman certainly has the Tuohy 2017 feel about him
Newman certainly has the Tuohy 2017 feel about him
That said, I think his likely average is higher given he hasn't been played in his best position for year due to being up against McVeigh.
I will admit a bit of bias towards Newman as I have had him in a keeper league for the last 5 years
Last edited:
If Newman goes on to average 90 I wouldn't consider it a fail... am I not expecting enough from a mid pricer? You either keep him for 90 or you take the price gain to turn him over to a fallen premium?
That said, I think his likely average is higher given he hasn't been played in his best position for year due to being up against McVeigh.
I will admit a bit of bias towards Newman as I have had him in a keeper league for the last 5 years
That said, I think his likely average is higher given he hasn't been played in his best position for year due to being up against McVeigh.
I will admit a bit of bias towards Newman as I have had him in a keeper league for the last 5 years
I still am slightly skeptical of his ability to play each week. I might be silly, but I feel like his scores don't always reflect his contribution to the team...
If Newman goes on to average 90 I wouldn't consider it a fail... am I not expecting enough from a mid pricer? You either keep him for 90 or you take the price gain to turn him over to a fallen premium?
That said, I think his likely average is higher given he hasn't been played in his best position for year due to being up against McVeigh.
I will admit a bit of bias towards Newman as I have had him in a keeper league for the last 5 years
That said, I think his likely average is higher given he hasn't been played in his best position for year due to being up against McVeigh.
I will admit a bit of bias towards Newman as I have had him in a keeper league for the last 5 years