Opinion Player X vs Player Y

[All is Wells]

I dont really ask for opinions on trades much but...

Wells vs Dahlhaus (trading Deledio out)

- Wells is my favourite player as my username suggests, but i cant have bias at this stage of the year when im going for top 10 (currently 26th)
- Wells has scored over 100 the last 3 times he has played hawks and syndey who are his next 2 opponents
- probably more likely to miss than dahl in the next 3 weeks
- 100k more expensive which could be helpful for future trades if i choose Daglhaus
- Dahlhaus is racking the ball up, but isnt scoring well at the moment

Who would you pick and why? I cant afford any other options over 505k

 

[DoggyODFL]

I dont really ask for opinions on trades much but...

Wells vs Dahlhaus (trading Deledio out)

- Wells is my favourite player as my username suggests, but i cant have bias at this stage of the year when im going for top 10 (currently 26th)
- Wells has scored over 100 the last 3 times he has played hawks and syndey who are his next 2 opponents
- probably more likely to miss than dahl in the next 3 weeks
- 100k more expensive which could be helpful for future trades if i choose Daglhaus
- Dahlhaus is racking the ball up, but isnt scoring well at the moment

Who would you pick and why? I cant afford any other options over 505k

Surely you want the best available both are POD enough to help make up ground
Based on Dahl's scores since coming back I'd go Wells - and as you have mentioned he has history of scores against his next 2 opponents
Also given you also have trades left you could still potentially target Dahl for cover later

 

[Courtesans]

I dont really ask for opinions on trades much but...

Wells vs Dahlhaus (trading Deledio out)

- Wells is my favourite player as my username suggests, but i cant have bias at this stage of the year when im going for top 10 (currently 26th)
- Wells has scored over 100 the last 3 times he has played hawks and syndey who are his next 2 opponents
- probably more likely to miss than dahl in the next 3 weeks
- 100k more expensive which could be helpful for future trades if i choose Daglhaus
- Dahlhaus is racking the ball up, but isnt scoring well at the moment

Who would you pick and why? I cant afford any other options over 505k

Personally I would go with Dahlhaus. He is a premium. Not an easy choice, I see Wells as being more fragile, but a great player. Both have had many weeks out.
Your choice, line ball.
But I would pick the premium.

 

[Adrenaline]

jj vs boyd?
who is likely to score more and play out the rest of the season?

 

[All is Wells]

Personally I would go with Dahlhaus. He is a premium. Not an easy choice, I see Wells as being more fragile, but a great player. Both have had many weeks out.
Your choice, line ball.
But I would pick the premium.

Surely you want the best available both are POD enough to help make up ground
Based on Dahl's scores since coming back I'd go Wells - and as you have mentioned he has history of scores against his next 2 opponents
Also given you also have trades left you could still potentially target Dahl for cover later

Thanks guys. At this stage im leaning towards Wells. However this could change if Dahlhaus is unaffordable for me next week.

 

[All is Wells]

Thanks guys. At this stage im leaning towards Wells. However this could change if Dahlhaus is unaffordable for me next week.

Ended up going Dahlhaus. Quite happy with the 113 from tonights match plus the extra 100k

 

[Zimmer]

Who do I play out of Motlop and Hall?

With Hall against the Bombers, I'm leaning towards him. Motlop sure to come out with a 140 if he's on my bench though.

 

[Darkie]

Who do I play out of Motlop and Hall?

With Hall against the Bombers, I'm leaning towards him. Motlop sure to come out with a 140 if he's on my bench though.

If you're choosing one straight up (no loophole), I would say Hall comfortably.

Even with his injuries, he is averaging around 10 points higher, and he has two 70s, a 129 and a 139 against Essendon. Against Richmond, Motlop has scored 77, 35, 67 and 93.

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Bartel replacement if required;

Z Williams v Pittard v Howe v McVeigh

Thoughts?

 

[jaca]

I've got JJ (who you own) and Houli in the mix. Houli interests me.

 

[Ben's Beasts]

I've got JJ (who you own) and Houli in the mix. Houli interests me.

Houli out of my price range unfortunately.

I have only $435,400 to spend.

 

[Pearcey47]

Houli out of my price range unfortunately.

I have only $435,400 to spend.

Nick Haynes?

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Nick Haynes?

Would he be your preference above all of Williams, Pittard, Howe and McVeigh?

 

[blue dreamer]

Tom Mcdonald?

 

[Pearcey47]

Tom Mcdonald?

He is $477K

 

[Pearcey47]

Would he be your preference above all of Williams, Pittard, Howe and McVeigh?

Maybe McVeigh then Haynes. Then Pittard, Williams, Howe of those you listed, in that order.

 

[blue dreamer]

Bartel replacement if required;

Z Williams v Pittard v Howe v McVeigh

Thoughts?

Houli out of my price range unfortunately.

I have only $435,400 to spend.

Tom Mcdonald?

He is $477K

Oops, sorry mate, I was looking at possible Bartel replacements myself and can afford T Mac that's why I put him there without rechecking his costs and your funds position.

 

[Zimmer]

Hall or Motlop onfield?

 

[DoggyODFL]

Hall or Motlop onfield?

I'd back Hall in

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Bartel replacement if required;

Z Williams v Pittard v Howe v McVeigh

Thoughts?

Urgh, wish I chose Howe over Pittard!