Player X vs. Player Y
- Thread starter Jurn Stern
- Start date
- Joined
- 6 Jul 2012
- Messages
- 4,890
- Likes
- 11,150
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Have Savage at D6 with Austin and Duman on bench.
Qualifying final, although, always best to win. Duman feels to risky to put on field.
Best defender I don't have is Simpson. Feels like for $515k better off him than all the other choices who have lately posted 1 poor score.
Savage or Austin > Sicily. Difference of $166k or $38k cash left.
$166k cash means I may be able to go Petracca to Hawkins in Preliminary in one trade, worst case 2 trades or bring Hawkins in for Fyfe (trading Fritsch this week).
Do we just assume Savage unlikely to be back in two weeks and trade him.
Qualifying final, although, always best to win. Duman feels to risky to put on field.
Best defender I don't have is Simpson. Feels like for $515k better off him than all the other choices who have lately posted 1 poor score.
Savage or Austin > Sicily. Difference of $166k or $38k cash left.
$166k cash means I may be able to go Petracca to Hawkins in Preliminary in one trade, worst case 2 trades or bring Hawkins in for Fyfe (trading Fritsch this week).
Do we just assume Savage unlikely to be back in two weeks and trade him.
TMac v Hurn v Brayshaw v McGovern v B.Smith
With Savage injury I'm considering one of the above trades, leaning towards TMac especially with S.May suspension this week and he seems to have a base of about 80 but could score 110+ against any team.
Dont like Brayshaw as much just because his big numbers have come against easy team and after GC the dees have reasonably difficult run home.
The WCE guys I cannot get a read on, never been a fan of the Gov as he can easily go missing, Hurn has crossed my mind but still come back to TMac.
I have thrown in Brodie Smith as a super risky POD coming back from injury, has history that he can score well but he is coming back from LTI... Probably not for me.
Would love to know what others thoughts are.
fyi i already have the big guns in Laird, Simpson, Yeo, Lloyd and have Hurley aswell
With Savage injury I'm considering one of the above trades, leaning towards TMac especially with S.May suspension this week and he seems to have a base of about 80 but could score 110+ against any team.
Dont like Brayshaw as much just because his big numbers have come against easy team and after GC the dees have reasonably difficult run home.
The WCE guys I cannot get a read on, never been a fan of the Gov as he can easily go missing, Hurn has crossed my mind but still come back to TMac.
I have thrown in Brodie Smith as a super risky POD coming back from injury, has history that he can score well but he is coming back from LTI... Probably not for me.
Would love to know what others thoughts are.
fyi i already have the big guns in Laird, Simpson, Yeo, Lloyd and have Hurley aswell
- Joined
- 6 Jan 2013
- Messages
- 19,073
- Likes
- 80,337
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
I'm entertaining a Tomahawk + Daw combo for my last two trades 
(I'm not sure if a scientific study has ever been completed on the statistical success rate of this approach, but for adrenaline junkies like supercoachscores members, I like the vibe and feel ya man
)
- Joined
- 6 Jul 2012
- Messages
- 4,890
- Likes
- 11,150
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Luckily you can still watch Hawkins from the SC coaches box this weekend; as Walters to Hawkins is the likely trade for Team Philzsay in the lead up to the huge SCS Premier League Beasts FC v Philzsay Preliminary Final...
Similary I dont trust Petracca vs WCE with Hogan out of the side. Fyfe playing, so Menegola for me ($600 short of Hawkins),