Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[Deeman1]

Probably Logue with his higher ceiling and floor compared to Answerth's many shockers this year.

Would risk a 0, but agreed ideally that would be the way to go ?

Edit: won't risk a 0, as Answerth will be E ?

 

[Darkie]

Any one got any thoughts on Logue v Answerth?

Leaning towards Logue, can't loop ?

Agree with @Tamuhawk.

 

[Darkie]

Dunkley m8, Parker f7, hill m9 v libba m8, Westoff f7, Clarke m9

Is that the good Dunkley? If so the first one easily.

Not much point having Hoff at F7 if it compromises an on field spot in my view.

 

[Woodsey]

Westhoff v Heeney - The Hoff has looked better recently but with Dixon being dropped will he go back to Full Forward?

 

[Zim^zuM]

Hill vs Mclean (rookie ones)

 

[meataxe]

Tomahawk + 9 points, vs Tom Stewart - which one wins?

Cheers guys

 

[JoeyRulz]

Houli vs Rich.

Trading out Ryan this week. Slightly worried about a potential rest for Houli, but his scoring record at the MCG is remarkable. Rich would be a more conservative option.

 

[Grundogging]

Birchall vs. Birchall (possibly into Naish) vs. Logue

This might seem a bit weird but I potentially have to select D6 from between:

A) Birchall starting at D6​

​

B) Birchall as first leg of the D6 loop (could end up being Naish's score on Saturday night)​

​

C) Logue (either starting or second leg of D6 loop).​

Would normally just loop Birchall with Naish and relax, but the rumblings from tigerland that Houli may miss, possibly resulting in Naish being a late in (on Saturday night after Birchall and Logue have played which would normally be the perfect looping situation), which would in turn wreck the loop if I chose to take Birchall's score after tonight.

Should I just lock in one of Birchall or Logue now, or stick with looping Birchall / Logue and risk having to take Naish's score over Birchall's, in the situation where Birchall posts a good score again and Naish ends up being a late in for Houli?

 

[Zim^zuM]

Mclean vs langlands

 

[meataxe]

Mclean vs langlands

McLean was starting to score ok before getting injured, so go with him. Besides, can't recommended picking a bloke named "Doulton".