Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[Darkie]

In line with my thinking, but dunkley role unknown, see butters as bloody good footballer who can progress and phillips as player who new rules and team will suit and can expect improvement. All forwards have so many unknowns against them. At the moment have phillips, tempted to throw the dice in favor of butters stepping up.

Fair call. FWIW I would order them the way you listed them - ie Philips over Butters.

 

[Pieman17]

First one easily!

That’s what I had. The cash gen is too big really. Cheers.

 

[Shaunpro1]

Fantasia vs Jiath

 

[BomberSam]

Nat Fyfe, Tom Phillips and Sam Berry

Vs.

Rowell, Taranto and Impey?

 

[Gruffles]

Fantasia vs Jiath

Fantasia

 

[Gruffles]

Nat Fyfe, Tom Phillips and Sam Berry

Vs.

Rowell, Taranto and Impey?

Option 1.

 

[Montyjnr]

Jordon vs Lazzaro

 

[freowho]

Jordon vs Lazzaro

Neither. Probably better having a donut to play like Valente or restructuring.

 

[dlanod]

Thoughts on Simpkin vs Sloane vs Dan Rich (Laird moving into the middle for the moment)?

Simpkin just makes me nervous with his finish to the year, Rich averaged 95 (taking out his injury affected 22) last year which makes him a cheap DEF keeper, and no idea what happened with Sloane last year but his price makes him tempting unless it was literally because Adelaide sucked so did he, i.e. less points for the team as a whole.

 

[Maso]

Trying to decide on 1 of Daniher F6 , Fantasia D6, D.Tyson M5, or a rookie player instead ?

 

[Maso]

Thoughts on Stephenson vs Sloane vs Dan Rich (Laird moving into the middle for the moment)?

Stephenson just makes me nervous with his finish to the year, Rich averaged 95 (taking out his injury affected 22) last year which makes him a cheap DEF keeper, and no idea what happened with Sloane last year but his price makes him tempting unless it was literally because Adelaide sucked so did he, i.e. less points for the team as a whole.

it would be Rich for me if thats only options

 

[dlanod]

it would be Rich for me if thats only options

LOL helps if I'm not an idiot and realise I'm getting Simpkin and Stephenson confused... but yeah, I'm leaning that ways too. It feels like he's probably a keeper. The others I'm less sure about.

 

[dlanod]

Trying to decide on 1 of Daniher F6 , Fantasia D6, D.Tyson M5, or a rookie player instead ?

I'm fully on the Daniher hype train. I keep looking at Tyson but he's look so average the last few years, whereas Daniher is both attributable to a known issue (injuries) and is now on a better team.

 

[Socrates2]

Trying to decide on 1 of Daniher F6 , Fantasia D6, D.Tyson M5, or a rookie player instead ?

All 4 options are reasonable.I'm banking on Daniher to kick a bag one week .

 

[Socrates2]

Gawn vs Hunter and $650,000

 

[Maso]

LOL helps if I'm not an idiot and realise I'm getting Simpkin and Stephenson confused... but yeah, I'm leaning that ways too. It feels like he's probably a keeper. The others I'm less sure about.

hmmmm if its simpkin id go him over Rich

 

[dlanod]

Gawn vs Hunter and $650,000

What are you going to do with the cash? Save for a house deposit?

 

[Brookesy]

T. Stewart & Daniher v Lloyd and Fullerton

 

[Juzzo]

Gawn vs Hunter and $650,000

 

[Socrates2]

What are you going to do with the cash? Save for a house deposit?

Get Danger and Jordan Clarke or Philips and Taranto if I follow through.
It also means two less rookies on the field.