Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[TommyGobbler]

Clayton Oliver & Steven May

Vs.

Andrew Brayshaw & Jordan Ridley

 

[dicksilverman]

Clayton Oliver & Steven May

Vs.

Andrew Brayshaw & Jordan Ridley

option 2

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Clayton Oliver & Steven May

Vs.

Andrew Brayshaw & Jordan Ridley

Not sure if it can be done but can you get Oliver and Brayshaw this week then May and Ridley shortly once they’ve both bottomed out?

 

[TommyGobbler]

Not sure if it can be done but can you get Oliver and Brayshaw this week then May and Ridley shortly once they’ve both bottomed out?

These are my Round 8 & 9 trade targets. Need to fix up forward line this week so I'll need to pick one option or the other. I'm leaning towards Brayshaw/Ridley. Another 100+ from Brayshaw this week prob locks him in.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Oliver or Walsh?

 

[Darkie]

Steele and Oliver easily for mine.

Same reaction from me.

 

[BomberSam]

Who are the best 2 options out of:

Zorko, Sidebottom, Heeney, Hind?

 

[meataxe]

Who are the best 2 options out of:

Zorko, Sidebottom, Heeney, Hind?

That's a hard one.

Sidebottom first pick for me, with his CBAs last round encouraging.

Zorko I feel can be tagged out, especially with Neale out. Heeney just coming back from injury. Hind least proven out of the 4. Push comes to shove, would pick Zorko second.

 

[AngryAnt]

Zorko to be tagged by who in upcoming weeks?

Touk Miller in round 9, although Miller has become more of an offensive midfielder this season.

 

[Paully]

Oliver or Walsh?

Same question from me. I'm leaning towards Oliver?

 

[whydoihavetoo]

Oliver or Walsh?

Oliver - more runs on the board than Walsh. That being said, I like Walsh more than anyone not named Oliver at the 560-610k price range

 

[Stormzy]

Zorko vs Andy Brayshaw my gut says Brayshaw but I've seen more support around Zorko so would like to hear some ideas. Thanks

 

[SuchIsLife]

Sidebottom vs Oliver?

 

[Quasimodo]

Zorko vs Andy Brayshaw my gut says Brayshaw but I've seen more support around Zorko so would like to hear some ideas. Thanks

I've got the same decision and leaning Brayshaw with a better overall team match-up and the lower BE. Also gives me a chance to look at the Lions mid situation post Neale, although fairly likely to bring Zorko in over the next few weeks regardless.

Besides Supercoach Gold is projecting a higher score for Brayshaw this week and that's never wrong ... right?

 

[Shannon]

Sidebottom vs Oliver?

Oliver easily for mine.
Think he will be a top 3 mid this year.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Zorko vs Andy Brayshaw my gut says Brayshaw but I've seen more support around Zorko so would like to hear some ideas. Thanks

One I've been wrestling with all week and still no closer to the decision. Would be nice to own a Freo player for that last game of the round. Luckily won't need to decide until Saturday.

 

[Bermi]

Who to play on field between Chapman, Koschitzke or Mansell?

I'm leaning to Chapman, with Koschitzke as the Emergency, but I really don't know.

 

[bloke]

Sidebottom vs Greene vs Impey ?

 

[whydoihavetoo]

Walsh vs Petracca

 

[AngryAnt]

I've got the same decision and leaning Brayshaw with a better overall team match-up and the lower BE. Also gives me a chance to look at the Lions mid situation post Neale, although fairly likely to bring Zorko in over the next few weeks regardless.

Besides Supercoach Gold is projecting a higher score for Brayshaw this week and that's never wrong ... right?

It would depend on the relative strength of each line as well. Which rookie does the player you're brining in replace on field in their respective line? Does Zorko replacing Rowe yield a better points return than Brayshaw vs someone like Scott or Jordon?
If it were purely x vs y then you would go Brayshaw, but Zorko is potential top 6 in his line and could strengthen what is looking like peoples' weakest line now.