Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
25,302
Likes
34,856
AFL Club
Collingwood
Fwd cover to replace Mozzie. 1 trade & $229k to play with.

Coleman v Gardner v Ham v ????
Leaning towards Coleman, with his DPP.
Might have misread it , why do you need to go down if you have $ 229 to play with ? or is that Mosquito + existing Bank ?
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
4,069
Likes
13,588
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Pick 2 to field...

Riccardi (76) vs. Steven Motlop vs. Keiden Coleman
Riccardi for one. Lock that in.

Coleman has been consistent so far with 3 scores between 59-68 from his 3 games. Motlop similar scoring the last two weeks (59 and 64), but has had more lower scores earlier in the season. I would say Coleman just, but I wouldn't expect miracles from either.
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
4,069
Likes
13,588
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Draft final and I need an 80 to win....

De Goey vs Hartlett.
De Goey has gone 80+ 4/7 times, the other 3 in the 60's.

Hartlett has gone 80+ 8/16 times, sub 60 on 4 of the others.

I would give a slight edge to Hartlett, as De Goey is in his second game back from injury. Yes he scored 4 goals last game, but Port are FAR better than Gold Coast, it will be a lot harder to score 4 this time in a night game at the Gabba.

Good luck.
 
Joined
16 Dec 2013
Messages
2,143
Likes
1,718
AFL Club
Collingwood
Draft cash league going down to the wire, De Goey vs Rozee for an on-field spot? Can't see De Goey kicking a bag against Port and that's where all his scoring comes from. Although Rozee throwing up multiple 40s throughout the year scares me off...
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
4,069
Likes
13,588
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Draft cash league going down to the wire, De Goey vs Rozee for an on-field spot? Can't see De Goey kicking a bag against Port and that's where all his scoring comes from. Although Rozee throwing up multiple 40s throughout the year scares me off...
Refer to my post before yours on De Goey, I mentioned similar concerns with relying on goals. I would back in Rozee here.
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
4,069
Likes
13,588
AFL Club
Hawthorn
I have been reading back through this topic over the last few days. Let's just say a lot of my responses were pretty awful, and I apologise for some poor advice throughout the year. I'll look through the responses again over coming days and give a summary of my responses, however I think it will be close as to whether I had more right or wrong responses for the season.

Although I did respond to over 450 X v Y queries, I did realise that I overlooked one when rereading this topic from Rd 16. Apologies to @Bones for missing that post.

Greenwood vs Parish?

Hopefully parish gets more mid time with McGrath out but Essendon have a tough finish (Gee, PTA, Mel).
I know it is too late now, but at that stage I think I likely would have chosen Greenwood, I did have both in my team, so from experience I hope you went that way based on the final 3 rounds.
 
Joined
24 Apr 2013
Messages
8,919
Likes
3,998
AFL Club
Carlton
I have been reading back through this topic over the last few days. Let's just say a lot of my responses were pretty awful, and I apologise for some poor advice throughout the year. I'll look through the responses again over coming days and give a summary of my responses, however I think it will be close as to whether I had more right or wrong responses for the season.

Although I did respond to over 450 X v Y queries, I did realise that I overlooked one when rereading this topic from Rd 16. Apologies to @Bones for missing that post.


I know it is too late now, but at that stage I think I likely would have chosen Greenwood, I did have both in my team, so from experience I hope you went that way based on the final 3 rounds.
I appreciate the responses more than the accuracy so all good :p
Just curious though, let me know what your hit rate was ;)
 
Top