Opinion Questions For Rowsus

Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Babylove

#641
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
444
Likes
64
AFL Club
Collingwood
#641
Hi Rowsus. What are your thoughts on Webster? I have been tossing up downgrading him to either Martin or Georgiou and using the cash to upgrade Liberatore to Jelwood and upgrading Hurn to someone like Hibberd (if I go Webster to Georgiou I can do both). It would mean I would have two playing defensive rookies with Langdon & Langford currently on my bench, and would give my 4 round 8 premiums in the midfield. But Jelwood & Hibberd look like more sure players than Liberatore & Hurn. The Webster to Georgiou would also leave enough cash to go Thurlow to Currie if need be and have a bit of cash left over.

This would also still leave Suckling at D4 but even Webster to Georgiou wouldn't give me enough to upgrade him to anything more than a low $400k player and I'm not much more confident in them than Suckling.

Also What are your thoughts on Guthrie as a POD to Suckling? There has been a bit of talk that he could get more midfield time and looked good through NAB Cup. However he has the round 8 bye, and Suckling does have some good SC form. Also I would probably have to downgrade Webster to bring him in as I don't have much spare cash and may need to upgrade Thurlow.
 
Rowsus

Rowsus

Statistician
#643
Joined
19 Mar 2012
Messages
29,132
Likes
64,898
AFL Club
Melbourne
#643
Bobbie said:
Cheers Rowsus. Do you think there are any other rucks I should be considering (not Jacobs! Burnt big time last year & can't go there again)?
Click to expand...
No, the choices are starting to get thin for round 1 now.
 
Rowsus

Rowsus

Statistician
#644
Joined
19 Mar 2012
Messages
29,132
Likes
64,898
AFL Club
Melbourne
#644
Babylove said:
Hi Rowsus. What are your thoughts on Webster? I have been tossing up downgrading him to either Martin or Georgiou and using the cash to upgrade Liberatore to Jelwood and upgrading Hurn to someone like Hibberd (if I go Webster to Georgiou I can do both). It would mean I would have two playing defensive rookies with Langdon & Langford currently on my bench, and would give my 4 round 8 premiums in the midfield. But Jelwood & Hibberd look like more sure players than Liberatore & Hurn. The Webster to Georgiou would also leave enough cash to go Thurlow to Currie if need be and have a bit of cash left over.

This would also still leave Suckling at D4 but even Webster to Georgiou wouldn't give me enough to upgrade him to anything more than a low $400k player and I'm not much more confident in them than Suckling.

Also What are your thoughts on Guthrie as a POD to Suckling? There has been a bit of talk that he could get more midfield time and looked good through NAB Cup. However he has the round 8 bye, and Suckling does have some good SC form. Also I would probably have to downgrade Webster to bring him in as I don't have much spare cash and may need to upgrade Thurlow.
Click to expand...
Hi Baby,
I'm not a fan of Webster, I think he should be avoided. He may have better JS this season, but he's not a good scorer. If you didn't have by now, I can't see a good reason to get him, and if Georgiou gets picked, he looks a better option.
I don't think there is a lot between Suckling and Guthrie, I'd let bye structure decide that.
At the moment I would keep Libba over Jelwood. There has to be some doubt about his preseason.
I have both Hibberd and Hurn, and Hibberd also has a question mark over him, but if he is fit to go, then he should be better than Hurn over the season.
 
B

Babylove

#647
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
444
Likes
64
AFL Club
Collingwood
#647
Rowsus said:
Hi Baby,
I'm not a fan of Webster, I think he should be avoided. He may have better JS this season, but he's not a good scorer. If you didn't have by now, I can't see a good reason to get him, and if Georgiou gets picked, he looks a better option.
I don't think there is a lot between Suckling and Guthrie, I'd let bye structure decide that.
At the moment I would keep Libba over Jelwood. There has to be some doubt about his preseason.
I have both Hibberd and Hurn, and Hibberd also has a question mark over him, but if he is fit to go, then he should be better than Hurn over the season.
Click to expand...
Thanks Rowsus. Is anyone else hating the split round? It's giving me too much time to think about my team.
 
W

Walsupremacy

Draftee
#648
Joined
12 Mar 2014
Messages
6
Likes
0
AFL Club
Essendon
#648
Hey Rowsus..thinking about changing from Ryder to Hmac....is this a good move or is it just last minute doubts?
cheers
 
blue dreamer

blue dreamer

#651
Joined
21 Mar 2012
Messages
4,202
Likes
6,469
AFL Club
Carlton
#651
Rowsus said:
Hi Baby,
I'm not a fan of Webster, I think he should be avoided. He may have better JS this season, but he's not a good scorer. If you didn't have by now, I can't see a good reason to get him, and if Georgiou gets picked, he looks a better option.
I don't think there is a lot between Suckling and Guthrie, I'd let bye structure decide that.
At the moment I would keep Libba over Jelwood. There has to be some doubt about his preseason.
I have both Hibberd and Hurn, and Hibberd also has a question mark over him, but if he is fit to go, then he should be better than Hurn over the season.
Click to expand...
Side question, similar vein, what do you think of Mav Weller JS and scoring, with his suspension this week could allow some of us to collect the Langdon (e)
 
B

Bridgebuff

Rising Star Winner
#652
Joined
29 Mar 2013
Messages
232
Likes
10
AFL Club
Adelaide
#652
Hi Rowsus,

Are you able to quantify how many points one needs to gain out of a floating donut each week to make up for the fact that the donut does not appreciate in price and therefore slows down our progress towards a full premium team.

Also would you say that as a rule of thumb it is bad to jump on a midpricer on the bubble that is due for a big price increase UNLESS we have very good intel that this player is taking his game to another level because we already missed out on the big scores.
 
Rowsus

Rowsus

Statistician
#654
Joined
19 Mar 2012
Messages
29,132
Likes
64,898
AFL Club
Melbourne
#654
blue dreamer said:
Side question, similar vein, what do you think of Mav Weller JS and scoring, with his suspension this week could allow some of us to collect the Langdon (e)
Click to expand...
I honestly don't know enough about him. His Price makes him pretty awkward, I wouldn't have him.
 
Rowsus

Rowsus

Statistician
#656
Joined
19 Mar 2012
Messages
29,132
Likes
64,898
AFL Club
Melbourne
#656
Bridgebuff said:
Hi Rowsus,

Are you able to quantify how many points one needs to gain out of a floating donut each week to make up for the fact that the donut does not appreciate in price and therefore slows down our progress towards a full premium team.

Also would you say that as a rule of thumb it is bad to jump on a midpricer on the bubble that is due for a big price increase UNLESS we have very good intel that this player is taking his game to another level because we already missed out on the big scores.
Click to expand...
There's many different opinions on the first part. Let's say the average Rookie makes $160k in 7 price changes. That $160k is earmarked for improvements from around round 9 or 10 on, and hopefully earns 30 pts/game to the end of the season. That's 360 points. So you probably need 40 points/round to justify it. Very hard to achieve.

No, I wouldn't jump on a bubbling Midpricer, unless one of your fringe Premiums looks really terrible.
 
C

camo15

Draftee
#657
Joined
12 Mar 2014
Messages
18
Likes
0
AFL Club
Hawthorn
#657
Should I bring in Honeychurch for M Crouch? Not sure about his JS compared to Crouch's chances at starting soon.
 
Rowsus

Rowsus

Statistician
#658
Joined
19 Mar 2012
Messages
29,132
Likes
64,898
AFL Club
Melbourne
#658
camo15 said:
Should I bring in Honeychurch for M Crouch? Not sure about his JS compared to Crouch's chances at starting soon.
Click to expand...
.
A bird in the hand approach is usually best with Rookies. I'd take Crouch out for now.
 
S

SonOfGod

Rising Star Nominee
#659
Joined
12 Jan 2014
Messages
134
Likes
6
#659
Rowsus.

I made the last minute decision to stack my backline with rookies as there are now an abundance of them down there who will make money. So I have 3 guns and 5 rookies down in DEF. Then I made the decision to ditch Caddy (who scored well but surprisingly lower than I thought given his impact) and I want to upg him to a keeper over 500k. I already have Danger, Martin and Roughy.

So it comes down to Riewoldt v Harvey v Petrie, all proven supercoach scorers. Whose your best bet to score the best? I am slightly leaning towards Petrie, but I wouldn't be surprised if Rooey defies the odds again. But it could be mighty tough given the state of the Saints list atm.

I just don't have enough faith in those fwds priced from 400-500k, although I do have Parker and think he could break out. I want to have practically a set and forget FWD line structure of 5 premos + Higgins + 2 rookies as well a S&F Ruck combo as all the cash making opportunities are in DEF and MID at the moment and very, very limited in the RUC and FWD.

Thoughts?

BTW - I'm only going for a league win so not concerned about the byes atm.
 
Last edited:
B

Bridgebuff

Rising Star Winner
#660
Joined
29 Mar 2013
Messages
232
Likes
10
AFL Club
Adelaide
#660
Rowsus said:
1.Just personal opinion. I think he will be just below last season, and will score better in the 2nd half of the season than the first. Mainly based on Brisbanes tougher draw, and the perception they will win less games this season.

2.It sounds like you are committing 2 trades on the back of 1 games eveidence. I would hold off, and stick with your original thoughts.
Click to expand...
Hi Rowsus, Based on your previous comment, do you think that Libatore is a better choice than Rockliff? He would also work better for my bye round. My main concern is that I am not sure if Libba can back up his fantastic 2013
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top