Opinion Rate My AFL SuperCoach Team

[NT.Thunder]

My most recent draft has:
D4: Roberton
M5: Coniglio
R2: Gawn
F4: Bonar

 

[Connoisseur]

Most recent draft:
D4: S Docherty
M5: P Dangerfield
R2: N Naitanui
F4: S Hill

 

[Herbie66]

D4 DoeDee
M5 Whitfield
R2 Gawn
F4 D Smith
***Still working on rookies but have 10 players priced between 123 - 208k built in to give me some flexibility ....

good to see I am.not the only one thinking of starting Whitfield in the mids

 

[Tails]

good to see I am.not the only one thinking of starting Whitfield in the mids

Hasn't moved since SC opened and highly unlikely to either ... just suits every structure that I've come up with thus far ...

 

[NT.Thunder]

It can be done if you dig deep enough...
Includes the following: Laird, Sicily & Doc (D1-3) and Whitfield (F1)
Those $180k+ Rookies are: Mcasey, Young, Rowell, Stephens & Bonar (only 2 bolded as definite starters)

Has me intrigued that's for sure

 

[Herbie66]

Hasn't moved since SC opened and highly unlikely to either ... just suits every structure that I've come up with thus far ...

I like it a lot , especially if Bonar , Cockatoo , Budarick , Cahill , Mahony , Williams are in the picture Round 1.

Could allow M9 to be fielded instead of a F5&6 with the right links and a FM at F8.

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Here's where I'm at with my latest version:
D4 S Hill
M5 Treloar
R2 Gawn
F4 D Smith

***I have 5 x $180k+ Rookies built into this version with only 2 being definite starters.

D4 Roberton
M5 TKelly
R2 Grundy
F4 S Hill

D4 Doc
M5 Danger
R2 Gawn
F4 Hill

6 rookies/returning players 170-280k

 

[OnTopBar]

It can be done if you dig deep enough...
Includes the following: Laird, Sicily & Doc (D1-3) and Whitfield (F1)
Those $180k+ Rookies are: Mcasey, Young, Rowell, Stephens & Bonar (only 2 bolded as definite starters)

My D1-3 are Williams, Houston and Doc which equate to the same value, I also have Whitfield at F1, so I would assume that you don't have Dusty and have MP's at F2-3 like Stevens and Lynch, plus not many of the 140-150k rookies.

 

[madmunza]

ATM I have
D4: Roberton
M5: Oliver
R2: Gawn
F4: C Jones
I'm sure it will change

 

[Professor]

Hill
Telly
Goldy
Bonar

 

[THCLT]

Has me intrigued that's for sure

My F2 & F3 are nothing to write home about hence I didn't post them...Hahaha.

Just wanted to put a team together with 10-11 definite Keepers which I'm keen to start with and only including Rookies who I feel are a genuine chance of starting R1 and the rest filled with more expensive ones. I'm hoping that I can find at least 3 other cheap Rookies to replace my more expensive ones come R1 so I can use that extra $180K or so injection to bring one of my F2/3/4 up to a proper Premium.

That's the plan anyways, now I just wait for the preseason matches and shuffle my Rookies as they reveal themselves.

 

[THCLT]

D4 Doc
M5 Danger
R2 Gawn
F4 Hill

6 rookies/returning players 170-280k

See what I mean...

 

[Herbie66]

It's great to see all the teams posted to help get an idea of what's possible, but really, this can only be cemented after we know what and where the R1 Rookies are. What's more interesting for me is to see who's occupying positions D4, F5, R2 & F4 in your favourite iteration. I view these positions as a good starting platform whilst we gauge and hopefully slot in our 'preferred' Rookies as they are announced.

Here's where I'm at with my latest version:
D4 S Hill
M5 Treloar
R2 Gawn
F4 D Smith
***I have 5 x $180k+ Rookies built into this version with only 2 being definite starters.

F2&3

maybe from Dawson , Gresham , Petracca , Lipinski , Stephenson , Rozee and I forgot one

EDIT

Parish

 

[THCLT]

F2&3

maybe from Dawson , Gresham , Petracca , Lipinski , Stephenson , Rozee and I forgot one

Someone's been paying attention to the Q4R thread...

 

[Pieman17]

Most recent draft:
D4: S Docherty
M5: P Dangerfield
R2: N Naitanui
F4: S Hill

Good to see it’s not just me with Nic Nat.

 

[Herbie66]

Someone's been paying attention to the Q4R thread...

Well over a few years I have learnt that the majority of your posts serve a meaning and purpose and when you ask questions I generally pay attention ?

 

[NT.Thunder]

My F2 & F3 are nothing to write home about hence I didn't post them...Hahaha.

Just wanted to put a team together with 10-11 definite Keepers which I'm keen to start with and only including Rookies who I feel are a genuine chance of starting R1 and the rest filled with more expensive ones. I'm hoping that I can find at least 3 other cheap Rookies to replace my more expensive ones come R1 so I can use that extra $180K or so injection to bring one of my F2/3/4 up to a proper Premium.

That's the plan anyways, now I just wait for the preseason matches and shuffle my Rookies as they reveal themselves.

I assumed they were jack Steven and Lynch but even then I struggled to see how it would fit under. Maybe Bradshaw?

 

[NT.Thunder]

I assumed they were jack Steven and Lynch but even then I struggled to see how it would fit under. Maybe Bradshaw?

Someone's been paying attention to the Q4R thread...

Jus saw this

 

[The Myth]

Started mid last year, which got me a bit more into AFL. Am an NRL nut.

So this will be my first full season.

Def: Laird, Houston, Doc, Roberton, Hill, Young (Gould, Rivers)
Mid: Macrae, JKelly, Bont, Oliver, TKelly, Rowell Flanders, Pickett (McHenry, Mead, Hibberd)
Ruck: Grundy Gawn (Comben)
Fwd: Whitfield, Dusty, D.Smith, Bonar, Cockatoo, Rankine (Brander, King)

My knowledge of AFL players is limited, any recommendations for a rookie?

 

[Herbie66]

Started mid last year, which got me a bit more into AFL. Am an NRL nut.

So this will be my first full season.

Def: Laird, Houston, Doc, Roberton, Hill, Young (Gould, Rivers)
Mid: Macrae, JKelly, Bont, Oliver, TKelly, Rowell Flanders, Pickett (McHenry, Mead, Hibberd)
Ruck: Grundy Gawn (Comben)
Fwd: Whitfield, Dusty, D.Smith, Bonar, Cockatoo, Rankine (Brander, King)

My knowledge of AFL players is limited, any recommendations for a rookie?

Heap better coaches in here that are willing to give advice , but their is not much not to like about that side until the rookie picture becomes clearer.

Hibberd & Mead are both under injury clouds at the moment.

Flanders could be a iffy one , no idea who to replace him with though , maybe Starcevich or monitor Simpson , Mahony , Budarick etc

Looks pretty darn good to me