Discussion Re-Signings, Retirements, Delistings, Trade & Drafting
- Thread starter Herbie66
- Start date
Don't really rate Burton at all, just a nothing player, at this stage just a worse version of Scharenberg and without the KPD defensive capability.
Burton for Wingard straight swap is ridiculous, Burton + Pick 15 for Wingard is reasonable but unders, Burton + Pick 15 + 2019 1st round pick is overs.
Wingard for Burton + Pick 15 + 2019 2nd round pick is about right
Burton for Wingard straight swap is ridiculous, Burton + Pick 15 for Wingard is reasonable but unders, Burton + Pick 15 + 2019 1st round pick is overs.
Wingard for Burton + Pick 15 + 2019 2nd round pick is about right
You're taking the piss, right? Becoming a very important part of the Hawks structure and backline.
Would rather we keep Burton over the Chad. The kid would have gone top 15 if it wasn't for his leg and although he didn't reach the same heights this season, his 2017 was very good.
I am not sold on Wingard, don't worry I would be more than happy with him as a Hawk but I wouldn't sell the farm to get him off Port this season.
Would rather we keep Burton over the Chad. The kid would have gone top 15 if it wasn't for his leg and although he didn't reach the same heights this season, his 2017 was very good.
I am not sold on Wingard, don't worry I would be more than happy with him as a Hawk but I wouldn't sell the farm to get him off Port this season.
I feel like the rise of Sicily hindered Burton’s development to the point he almost lost his identity. When Hodge left, Burton seemed the obvious replacement to play the qtr back role but then there were talks of him playing forward and then as Prochard suggested, he lost his ability to impact a game. I probably didn’t watch him as closely as you Jack but I definitely watched him as I took a chance on him in my SC for a few weeks and he didn’t show much!
Personally I’d give him up for Chad. Wingard is a match winner on his day, whereas Burton almost seems surplus to Hawthorn’s needs.
Personally I’d give him up for Chad. Wingard is a match winner on his day, whereas Burton almost seems surplus to Hawthorn’s needs.
All we need is Tippett to return then our ducks are sorted 
Mummy , Tip Rat & Clarke.
Lots of $$$ for those nice F/M presents
Mummy , Tip Rat & Clarke.Lots of $$$ for those nice F/M presents
I'm still of the opinion that Burton can play at his 2017 form and even improve beyond that into the future.
Probably a tad biased but I'd be pretty disappointed to see him go, and I don't think Wingard is worth Burto and 2 first rounders, especially now that Scully in is the mix.
However, I did see that the Hawks are looking at Jack Scrimshaw from the Suns as a Birchall style player which sheds some light on why they're willing to let Burto go.
Probably a tad biased but I'd be pretty disappointed to see him go, and I don't think Wingard is worth Burto and 2 first rounders, especially now that Scully in is the mix.
However, I did see that the Hawks are looking at Jack Scrimshaw from the Suns as a Birchall style player which sheds some light on why they're willing to let Burto go.
Now that's keen!
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/po...e/news-story/3e003d486e52c0ae921f369d5f807c49
PORT Adelaide’s desire to secure Ryan Burton in the Chad Wingard trade is set to see them send some of their medical department across to the United States to assess the young Hawk this weekend.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/po...e/news-story/3e003d486e52c0ae921f369d5f807c49
PORT Adelaide’s desire to secure Ryan Burton in the Chad Wingard trade is set to see them send some of their medical department across to the United States to assess the young Hawk this weekend.
If his body holds up this will be a good deal for Carlton (and a fair one for the Giants)
CARLTON has secured a deal for Greater Western Sydney midfielder Will Setterfield.
The Blues sent their future second-round pick as well as pick No.43 in this year's NAB AFL Draft to GWS, in exchange for the 190cm on-baller and pick No.71.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-10-12/blues-giants-settle-on-deal-for-young-mid-will-setterfield
CARLTON has secured a deal for Greater Western Sydney midfielder Will Setterfield.
The Blues sent their future second-round pick as well as pick No.43 in this year's NAB AFL Draft to GWS, in exchange for the 190cm on-baller and pick No.71.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-10-12/blues-giants-settle-on-deal-for-young-mid-will-setterfield