Discussion Re-Signings, Retirements, Delistings, Trade & Drafting

Philzsay

Leadership Group
Joined
21 Mar 2012
Messages
10,454
Likes
14,993
AFL Club
Essendon
ST KILDA has confirmed the premature retirement of midfielder Brad Crouch due to chronic knee issues.

Crouch played in round one this year against Geelong but missed the rest of the season and underwent arthroscopic surgery to address ongoing degenerative knee issues.

The injury eventually became too much for the 30-year-old, who has called time on his 161-game career.

https://www.afl.com.au/news/1260015...rad-crouch-retires-due-to-knee-injury-aged-30

Hang on, didn't St Kikda only just re-list him picking him up in the recent rookie draft?
 
Joined
7 Sep 2020
Messages
13,233
Likes
46,539
Hang on, didn't St Kikda only just re-list him picking him up in the recent rookie draft?
Yeh another part of the article

"We've been working with Brad for several months now as he has worked through his knee issues and we were hoping that we could get him back to a place where he could make an impact on-field, which is why we retained his place via our rookie list.

"However, we respect that Brad needs to think about his long-term health first and support him in this decision.
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
15,440
Likes
59,661
AFL Club
Hawthorn
It's such a beautiful day. We may have been completely embarrassed in the GF but it's all worth it now!

My Giants' fandom lasted all of 2 months :LOL:
I was wondering about the avatar change. Not sure I could switch to a rival team to support, no matter how badly the Hawks go.

Be interesting to see if Horse has been shoulder tapped as the initial Tassie coach or not yet.
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
15,440
Likes
59,661
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Joined
22 Feb 2013
Messages
9,669
Likes
20,537
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Well boys, I have thought long and hard about it but I decided to hang up my boots and retire from SuperCoach.
Maybe it is the old man calf strains or the many SC concussions I have had over my career, but I can't find the motivation to hit another pre-season and I know I don't have the care factor in me for another long season. I am absolutely not excited about all the flexing and dealing with multiple byes and every Thurs night has a game and all the loop-de-looping you need to do to be competitive.

Why did I feel the need to post like this and not fade into the background like others before me? Probably cause it's nice to be feeling like I've gone out on a high. Being a part of the SCS Premier League for a good few years has been an amazing experience and I would rather exit on my own terms than have Rowsus give me some bad news. Truth is, SCSPL has been the main driver keeping me interested over at least the last two seasons. Whenever I have felt my SC interest slipping, SCSPL has dragged my focus back on target. Overall ranking has always been the goal, but a very close second was getting as high as possible in the PL ladder. Didn't matter how rubbish the weekly score was, how terrible my C played or whatever injury bad luck I copped, I just wanted that PL win. I got close a couple of years back with a loss in the prelim but that is secondary to just being a member of PL. It has been an honour and a privilege to be part of it.

No doubt I will miss playing. SuperCoach and particularly SuperCoachScores have been a massive part of my life over the last more than a decade. I will struggle not to reflexively check the app for setting VCs, Cs and Es, and it will take a while to break the urge to look at the SC scores on FootyInfo Lite during a game. Checking the SCS forums many many times a day/hour has been like breathing to me for so long, and I enjoy reading the opinion and strategy posts, not to mention the good and bad luck stories. That said, I am looking forward to solely focusing on watching the Hawks rebuild and hopefully seeing some more wins and success come our way.

SCS has changed over the years, but it has remained a fantastic online home to live in. Some of it is due to the hard work of the mods, much of it is because we all have a common love of sport and don't let other issues/topics get in the way. You are all a great bunch and I have made some fantastic friends both in 3D and digital only. I'm sure to forget someone, but thanks to the following folks for making SCS a tip top spot - @Ricky Bobby, @Bomber18, @Goodie's Guns, @Lost In The Sky, @KLo30, @Connoisseur, @BigRuss, @Shannon, @Beg2Differ, @wogitalia, @THCLT, @Monya Meow Meow, @Zimmer, @freowho, @Darkie, @Ironhawk, @Bermi, @Peter56, @Tamuhawk, @Courtesans, @doc ron, @Tails, @jaca, @Diabolical. Special thanks to - @Professor (I enjoyed our chats Jim), @IDIG (we will always have Goldy C), @Deeman1 (top bloke Ash), @Creeker (I probably still owe you a Jimmy or three Pete!), @Rowsus (the guru of SCS), @Ben's Beasts (everyone wants to be like Ben), @Philzsay (text me if you need a someone to go with to watch the Hawks beat the Bombers at the G), @Impromptu (what a great site you have here Jay!). Appreciate all the chats and rants and fun times. I have been glad to be able to do my little bit to help SCS be a good place to be a part of.

Best of luck with season 2025 everyone, may all your players score 100s.
Over and out, PC (aka Jack)

1737939030369.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Joined
7 Jul 2012
Messages
11,789
Likes
34,936
AFL Club
West Coast
Well boys, I have thought long and hard about it but I decided to hang up my boots and retire from SuperCoach.
Maybe it is the old man calf strains or the many SC concussions I have had over my career, but I can't find the motivation to hit another pre-season and I know I don't have the care factor in me for another long season. I am absolutely not excited about all the flexing and dealing with multiple byes and every Thurs night has a game and all the loop-de-looping you need to do to be competitive.

Why did I feel the need to post like this and not fade into the background like others before me? Probably cause it's nice to be feeling like I've gone out on a high. Being a part of the SCS Premier League for a good few years has been an amazing experience and I would rather exit on my own terms than have Rowsus give me some bad news. Truth is, SCSPL has been the main driver keeping me interested over at least the last two seasons. Whenever I have felt my SC interest slipping, SCSPL has dragged my focus back on target. Overall ranking has always been the goal, but a very close second was getting as high as possible in the PL ladder. Didn't matter how rubbish the weekly score was, how terrible my C played or whatever injury bad luck I copped, I just wanted that PL win. I got close a couple of years back with a loss in the prelim but that is secondary to just being a member of PL. It has been an honour and a privilege to be part of it.

No doubt I will miss playing. SuperCoach and particularly SuperCoachScores have been a massive part of my life over the last more than a decade. I will struggle not to reflexively check the app for setting VCs, Cs and Es, and it will take a while to break the urge to look at the SC scores on FootyInfo Lite during a game. Checking the SCS forums many many times a day/hour has been like breathing to me for so long, and I enjoy reading the opinion and strategy posts, not to mention the good and bad luck stories. That said, I am looking forward to solely focusing on watching the Hawks rebuild and hopefully seeing some more wins and success come our way.

SCS has changed over the years, but it has remained a fantastic online home to live in. Some of it is due to the hard work of the mods, much of it is because we all have a common love of sport and don't let other issues/topics get in the way. You are all a great bunch and I have made some fantastic friends both in 3D and digital only. I'm sure to forget someone, but thanks to the following folks for making SCS a tip top spot - @Ricky Bobby, @Bomber18, @Goodie's Guns, @Lost In The Sky, @KLo30, @Connoisseur, @BigRuss, @Shannon, @Beg2Differ, @wogitalia, @THCLT, @Monya Meow Meow, @Zimmer, @freowho, @Darkie, @Ironhawk, @Bermi, @Peter56, @Tamuhawk, @Courtesans, @doc ron, @Tails, @jaca, @Diabolical. Special thanks to - @Professor (I enjoyed our chats Jim), @IDIG (we will always have Goldy C), @Deeman1 (top bloke Ash), @Creeker (I probably still owe you a Jimmy or three Pete!), @Rowsus (the guru of SCS), @Ben's Beasts (everyone wants to be like Ben), @Philzsay (text me if you need a someone to go with to watch the Hawks beat the Bombers at the G), @Impromptu (what a great site you have here Jay!). Appreciate all the chats and rants and fun times. I have been glad to be able to do my little bit to help SCS be a good place to be a part of.

Best of luck with season 2025 everyone, may all your players score 100s.
Over and out, PC (aka Jack)

View attachment 83327
Sorry to see you hang up the boots mate, You've been a fantastic contributor to this site for a long time now and will definitely be missed!!
I've really enjoyed our battles in the SCS Premier League over the years and can relate to getting a win in the PL being a high priority each and every week, lol

Definitely know how feel about the motivation factor and all the other points you listed, think a lot of us older players have felt the same at times. Who knows.... a break for a season might just recharge the batteries for another crack at it in the future!!

Take care mate, and have a good time watching your Hawks in 2025!!
 
Joined
16 Mar 2012
Messages
3,676
Likes
8,043
AFL Club
Essendon
Well boys, I have thought long and hard about it but I decided to hang up my boots and retire from SuperCoach.
Maybe it is the old man calf strains or the many SC concussions I have had over my career, but I can't find the motivation to hit another pre-season and I know I don't have the care factor in me for another long season. I am absolutely not excited about all the flexing and dealing with multiple byes and every Thurs night has a game and all the loop-de-looping you need to do to be competitive.

Why did I feel the need to post like this and not fade into the background like others before me? Probably cause it's nice to be feeling like I've gone out on a high. Being a part of the SCS Premier League for a good few years has been an amazing experience and I would rather exit on my own terms than have Rowsus give me some bad news. Truth is, SCSPL has been the main driver keeping me interested over at least the last two seasons. Whenever I have felt my SC interest slipping, SCSPL has dragged my focus back on target. Overall ranking has always been the goal, but a very close second was getting as high as possible in the PL ladder. Didn't matter how rubbish the weekly score was, how terrible my C played or whatever injury bad luck I copped, I just wanted that PL win. I got close a couple of years back with a loss in the prelim but that is secondary to just being a member of PL. It has been an honour and a privilege to be part of it.

No doubt I will miss playing. SuperCoach and particularly SuperCoachScores have been a massive part of my life over the last more than a decade. I will struggle not to reflexively check the app for setting VCs, Cs and Es, and it will take a while to break the urge to look at the SC scores on FootyInfo Lite during a game. Checking the SCS forums many many times a day/hour has been like breathing to me for so long, and I enjoy reading the opinion and strategy posts, not to mention the good and bad luck stories. That said, I am looking forward to solely focusing on watching the Hawks rebuild and hopefully seeing some more wins and success come our way.

SCS has changed over the years, but it has remained a fantastic online home to live in. Some of it is due to the hard work of the mods, much of it is because we all have a common love of sport and don't let other issues/topics get in the way. You are all a great bunch and I have made some fantastic friends both in 3D and digital only. I'm sure to forget someone, but thanks to the following folks for making SCS a tip top spot - @Ricky Bobby, @Bomber18, @Goodie's Guns, @Lost In The Sky, @KLo30, @Connoisseur, @BigRuss, @Shannon, @Beg2Differ, @wogitalia, @THCLT, @Monya Meow Meow, @Zimmer, @freowho, @Darkie, @Ironhawk, @Bermi, @Peter56, @Tamuhawk, @Courtesans, @doc ron, @Tails, @jaca, @Diabolical. Special thanks to - @Professor (I enjoyed our chats Jim), @IDIG (we will always have Goldy C), @Deeman1 (top bloke Ash), @Creeker (I probably still owe you a Jimmy or three Pete!), @Rowsus (the guru of SCS), @Ben's Beasts (everyone wants to be like Ben), @Philzsay (text me if you need a someone to go with to watch the Hawks beat the Bombers at the G), @Impromptu (what a great site you have here Jay!). Appreciate all the chats and rants and fun times. I have been glad to be able to do my little bit to help SCS be a good place to be a part of.

Best of luck with season 2025 everyone, may all your players score 100s.
Over and out, PC (aka Jack)

View attachment 83327
Enjoy your retirement Jack. Family and a social life do come first.
Hoping it's a Timmy Watson retirement and we will see you back on the field next year.
Hope the Hawks shine for you. Nah, I just can't go there. I have to retract that comment.
Take care bud. I'll miss your classic rants.
 

Rowsus

Statistician
Joined
19 Mar 2012
Messages
29,683
Likes
67,953
AFL Club
Melbourne
Well boys, I have thought long and hard about it but I decided to hang up my boots and retire from SuperCoach.
Maybe it is the old man calf strains or the many SC concussions I have had over my career, but I can't find the motivation to hit another pre-season and I know I don't have the care factor in me for another long season. I am absolutely not excited about all the flexing and dealing with multiple byes and every Thurs night has a game and all the loop-de-looping you need to do to be competitive.

Why did I feel the need to post like this and not fade into the background like others before me? Probably cause it's nice to be feeling like I've gone out on a high. Being a part of the SCS Premier League for a good few years has been an amazing experience and I would rather exit on my own terms than have Rowsus give me some bad news. Truth is, SCSPL has been the main driver keeping me interested over at least the last two seasons. Whenever I have felt my SC interest slipping, SCSPL has dragged my focus back on target. Overall ranking has always been the goal, but a very close second was getting as high as possible in the PL ladder. Didn't matter how rubbish the weekly score was, how terrible my C played or whatever injury bad luck I copped, I just wanted that PL win. I got close a couple of years back with a loss in the prelim but that is secondary to just being a member of PL. It has been an honour and a privilege to be part of it.

No doubt I will miss playing. SuperCoach and particularly SuperCoachScores have been a massive part of my life over the last more than a decade. I will struggle not to reflexively check the app for setting VCs, Cs and Es, and it will take a while to break the urge to look at the SC scores on FootyInfo Lite during a game. Checking the SCS forums many many times a day/hour has been like breathing to me for so long, and I enjoy reading the opinion and strategy posts, not to mention the good and bad luck stories. That said, I am looking forward to solely focusing on watching the Hawks rebuild and hopefully seeing some more wins and success come our way.

SCS has changed over the years, but it has remained a fantastic online home to live in. Some of it is due to the hard work of the mods, much of it is because we all have a common love of sport and don't let other issues/topics get in the way. You are all a great bunch and I have made some fantastic friends both in 3D and digital only. I'm sure to forget someone, but thanks to the following folks for making SCS a tip top spot - @Ricky Bobby, @Bomber18, @Goodie's Guns, @Lost In The Sky, @KLo30, @Connoisseur, @BigRuss, @Shannon, @Beg2Differ, @wogitalia, @THCLT, @Monya Meow Meow, @Zimmer, @freowho, @Darkie, @Ironhawk, @Bermi, @Peter56, @Tamuhawk, @Courtesans, @doc ron, @Tails, @jaca, @Diabolical. Special thanks to - @Professor (I enjoyed our chats Jim), @IDIG (we will always have Goldy C), @Deeman1 (top bloke Ash), @Creeker (I probably still owe you a Jimmy or three Pete!), @Rowsus (the guru of SCS), @Ben's Beasts (everyone wants to be like Ben), @Philzsay (text me if you need a someone to go with to watch the Hawks beat the Bombers at the G), @Impromptu (what a great site you have here Jay!). Appreciate all the chats and rants and fun times. I have been glad to be able to do my little bit to help SCS be a good place to be a part of.

Best of luck with season 2025 everyone, may all your players score 100s.
Over and out, PC (aka Jack)

View attachment 83327
Sorry to see you go, Jack.
I hope you pop your head in now and then, and say hi.
One of the originals. Member No. 801, and joined before the site was 1 year old.
 

Bomber18

Leadership Group
Joined
11 Nov 2012
Messages
27,643
Likes
65,935
AFL Club
Essendon
Well boys, I have thought long and hard about it but I decided to hang up my boots and retire from SuperCoach.
Maybe it is the old man calf strains or the many SC concussions I have had over my career, but I can't find the motivation to hit another pre-season and I know I don't have the care factor in me for another long season. I am absolutely not excited about all the flexing and dealing with multiple byes and every Thurs night has a game and all the loop-de-looping you need to do to be competitive.

Why did I feel the need to post like this and not fade into the background like others before me? Probably cause it's nice to be feeling like I've gone out on a high. Being a part of the SCS Premier League for a good few years has been an amazing experience and I would rather exit on my own terms than have Rowsus give me some bad news. Truth is, SCSPL has been the main driver keeping me interested over at least the last two seasons. Whenever I have felt my SC interest slipping, SCSPL has dragged my focus back on target. Overall ranking has always been the goal, but a very close second was getting as high as possible in the PL ladder. Didn't matter how rubbish the weekly score was, how terrible my C played or whatever injury bad luck I copped, I just wanted that PL win. I got close a couple of years back with a loss in the prelim but that is secondary to just being a member of PL. It has been an honour and a privilege to be part of it.

No doubt I will miss playing. SuperCoach and particularly SuperCoachScores have been a massive part of my life over the last more than a decade. I will struggle not to reflexively check the app for setting VCs, Cs and Es, and it will take a while to break the urge to look at the SC scores on FootyInfo Lite during a game. Checking the SCS forums many many times a day/hour has been like breathing to me for so long, and I enjoy reading the opinion and strategy posts, not to mention the good and bad luck stories. That said, I am looking forward to solely focusing on watching the Hawks rebuild and hopefully seeing some more wins and success come our way.

SCS has changed over the years, but it has remained a fantastic online home to live in. Some of it is due to the hard work of the mods, much of it is because we all have a common love of sport and don't let other issues/topics get in the way. You are all a great bunch and I have made some fantastic friends both in 3D and digital only. I'm sure to forget someone, but thanks to the following folks for making SCS a tip top spot - @Ricky Bobby, @Bomber18, @Goodie's Guns, @Lost In The Sky, @KLo30, @Connoisseur, @BigRuss, @Shannon, @Beg2Differ, @wogitalia, @THCLT, @Monya Meow Meow, @Zimmer, @freowho, @Darkie, @Ironhawk, @Bermi, @Peter56, @Tamuhawk, @Courtesans, @doc ron, @Tails, @jaca, @Diabolical. Special thanks to - @Professor (I enjoyed our chats Jim), @IDIG (we will always have Goldy C), @Deeman1 (top bloke Ash), @Creeker (I probably still owe you a Jimmy or three Pete!), @Rowsus (the guru of SCS), @Ben's Beasts (everyone wants to be like Ben), @Philzsay (text me if you need a someone to go with to watch the Hawks beat the Bombers at the G), @Impromptu (what a great site you have here Jay!). Appreciate all the chats and rants and fun times. I have been glad to be able to do my little bit to help SCS be a good place to be a part of.

Best of luck with season 2025 everyone, may all your players score 100s.
Over and out, PC (aka Jack)

View attachment 83327
A very nice post @PC - thanks for taking the time! Certainly resonate with your thoughts. Hope you enjoy watching the Hawks games without a fantasy lens!
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,885
Likes
153,979
AFL Club
Carlton
Well boys, I have thought long and hard about it but I decided to hang up my boots and retire from SuperCoach.
Maybe it is the old man calf strains or the many SC concussions I have had over my career, but I can't find the motivation to hit another pre-season and I know I don't have the care factor in me for another long season. I am absolutely not excited about all the flexing and dealing with multiple byes and every Thurs night has a game and all the loop-de-looping you need to do to be competitive.

Why did I feel the need to post like this and not fade into the background like others before me? Probably cause it's nice to be feeling like I've gone out on a high. Being a part of the SCS Premier League for a good few years has been an amazing experience and I would rather exit on my own terms than have Rowsus give me some bad news. Truth is, SCSPL has been the main driver keeping me interested over at least the last two seasons. Whenever I have felt my SC interest slipping, SCSPL has dragged my focus back on target. Overall ranking has always been the goal, but a very close second was getting as high as possible in the PL ladder. Didn't matter how rubbish the weekly score was, how terrible my C played or whatever injury bad luck I copped, I just wanted that PL win. I got close a couple of years back with a loss in the prelim but that is secondary to just being a member of PL. It has been an honour and a privilege to be part of it.

No doubt I will miss playing. SuperCoach and particularly SuperCoachScores have been a massive part of my life over the last more than a decade. I will struggle not to reflexively check the app for setting VCs, Cs and Es, and it will take a while to break the urge to look at the SC scores on FootyInfo Lite during a game. Checking the SCS forums many many times a day/hour has been like breathing to me for so long, and I enjoy reading the opinion and strategy posts, not to mention the good and bad luck stories. That said, I am looking forward to solely focusing on watching the Hawks rebuild and hopefully seeing some more wins and success come our way.

SCS has changed over the years, but it has remained a fantastic online home to live in. Some of it is due to the hard work of the mods, much of it is because we all have a common love of sport and don't let other issues/topics get in the way. You are all a great bunch and I have made some fantastic friends both in 3D and digital only. I'm sure to forget someone, but thanks to the following folks for making SCS a tip top spot - @Ricky Bobby, @Bomber18, @Goodie's Guns, @Lost In The Sky, @KLo30, @Connoisseur, @BigRuss, @Shannon, @Beg2Differ, @wogitalia, @THCLT, @Monya Meow Meow, @Zimmer, @freowho, @Darkie, @Ironhawk, @Bermi, @Peter56, @Tamuhawk, @Courtesans, @doc ron, @Tails, @jaca, @Diabolical. Special thanks to - @Professor (I enjoyed our chats Jim), @IDIG (we will always have Goldy C), @Deeman1 (top bloke Ash), @Creeker (I probably still owe you a Jimmy or three Pete!), @Rowsus (the guru of SCS), @Ben's Beasts (everyone wants to be like Ben), @Philzsay (text me if you need a someone to go with to watch the Hawks beat the Bombers at the G), @Impromptu (what a great site you have here Jay!). Appreciate all the chats and rants and fun times. I have been glad to be able to do my little bit to help SCS be a good place to be a part of.

Best of luck with season 2025 everyone, may all your players score 100s.
Over and out, PC (aka Jack)

View attachment 83327
All the best Jack, hope we see you around the site or at the annual catch up at the exchange.
 
Top