Strategy Round 11: Trades

[jaca]

Parker will be one I have my eye on for R12 for a similar reason.

 

[Herbie66]

https://supercoachscores.com/threads/pit-averages-durability-v-higher-ceiling-iii.3998/

2013-2018
View attachment 19566

Hello Duncan 😀

You are not human (I mean that in the nicest way).

I did a PIT midfield search by Author 😀

should have tried durability.

thanks for finding and posting , wonder what happened to 2019.

 

[Connoisseur]

Hello Duncan 😀

You are not human (I mean that in the nicest way).

I did a PIT midfield search buly Author 😀

should have tried durability.

thanks for finding and posting , wonder what happened to 2019.

Tried searching for the same but then went back about 5-6 pages to end of SC 2019 and preseason. Unsure if there is an updated version inclusive of 2019 figures.

 

[Zimmer]

Parker will be one I have my eye on for R12 for a similar reason.

I nearly brought him in a couple of weeks ago. Still on my radar. Very consistent.

 

[jaca]

I mean obviously Fyfe is a better scorer, but...

 

[Montyjnr]

Fyfe worth the risk IMO. I just don’t enjoy SuperCoach when he’s playing and I don’t have him.

 

[Zimmer]

Fyfe worth the risk IMO. I just don’t enjoy SuperCoach when he’s playing and I don’t have him.

Interesting. I've steered clear completely. Great player obviously, just know he's not durable enough.

 

[THCLT]

Fyfe worth the risk IMO. I just don’t enjoy SuperCoach when he’s playing and I don’t have him.

Nothing encapsulate my approach more this year than any previous years...Just try and ENJOY SC.

I would encourage all to do likewise...AND don't be too hard on yourself when your search for enjoyment doesn't exactly translate into an increase in weekly SC scores.

 

[Connoisseur]

Nothing encapsulate my approach more this year than any previous years...Just try and ENJOY SC.

I would encourage all to do likewise...AND don't be too hard on yourself when your search for enjoyment doesn't exactly translate into an increase in weekly SC scores.

Welcome, H Andrews
3rd time lucky, perhaps.

H Andrews when selected by Connoisseur since 2018: 69.91 from 11 (11/11 below 100)
H Andrews when not selected by Connoisseur since 2018: 91.83 from 36 (13/36 100+)

H Andrews debuted in @Connoisseur side on RD14 2018 (22SC from 11% TOG).

 

[THCLT]

So this is my current team. Bit low on trades and cash but hoping to get rid of Rankine, Hamill.
I don't know if I should Trade Pickett out next round or this
Preferably I would like to only use 3 trades

Anybody is welcome to comment on my current set up

I'll have a look and get back to you with 'my' take on what's best for your team going forward.
There's not much to work with from my initial observation so I may have to look at some drastic dissecting in order to balance out the investment in your team.

 

[BarginHunter]

This will be tough to fix , 9 upgrades to do and very little cash to do it.

Certainly wouldn't be trading out Pickett (he might be your season long M8)

I would definitely keep Rankine as well.

Hamill - > Watson (Fremantle)
Hoskin-Elliott - > Simpkin or Darling/Kennedy/Oscar McInerney

or Sier via DPP

maybe bring Schoenberg (Adelaide) in on your mid bench or wait a week
for Wicks

to be honest not sure what else , maybe @THCLT can come up with a master trade plan for you (he is good at that)

Thanks i like what your cooking. ill give it some thought

 

[BarginHunter]

I'll have a look and get back to you with 'my' take on what's best for your team going forward.
There's not much to work with from my initial observation so I may have to look at some drastic dissecting in order to balance out the investment in your team.

ok, will be looking forward to what you can do. im eager to learn and thank you for giving me some of your time

 

[Darkie]

Surprised for the lack of love for Shuey this week:

- Take out injury-affected 33 in R5, and he's averaging 110.5 from his other 6 games
- Already had his BYE
- B/E of only 45 (only played 2 games since injury game, scored 130 and 116)
- Oh yeah, and he's only $488k!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Am I missing something?

I had a look at him recently. If you think he’ll score differently this year then he looks good. Otherwise he’s arguably quite fairly priced given his history, and is a couple of notches below the top mids:

https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pu-west-coast-eagles--luke-shuey

 

[Darkie]

T Brown > O'Halloran/mid rookie
Rankine > Wicks
Simpson > Titch

I need Rankine to go up $2,800 for this to work. His BE was 76 and he scored 83 - please someone tell me this is enough for a $2.8k price rise??

I think it should be, by around $200!

 

[Willyorwonty]

I wasn't going solely by average; but a mix of scoring history, sustainability, breakout potential etc.

Players like Clarry/Fyfe/Titch etc who have shown multiple seasons of elite scoring versus flash in the pan seasons like Duncan is having.

Duncan has averaged over 100 points per season for each of the previous 3 seasons and again this year. He averaged 110 about 4 seasons ago too. Also averages 20+ games a season, which is more durable than most. I think you're confusing him with someone else, because he is consistently good (and underrated).

 

[Darkie]

This will be tough to fix , 9 upgrades to do and very little cash to do it.

Certainly wouldn't be trading out Pickett (he might be your season long M8)

I would definitely keep Rankine as well.

Hamill - > Watson (Fremantle)
Hoskin-Elliott - > Simpkin or Darling/Kennedy/Oscar McInerney

or Sier via DPP

maybe bring Schoenberg (Adelaide) in on your mid bench or wait a week
for Wicks

to be honest not sure what else , maybe @THCLT can come up with a master trade plan for you (he is good at that)

@BarginHunter - I would seriously consider trading out any player you see as meaningfully overpriced. Take their price and divide by $5,000 - if you think they’ll average say 15 or 20 less than this, consider trading them to someone who can score similarly but who may be much cheaper.

Dumont to someone like Simpkin would be one to consider if you don’t have him.

 

[Ironhawk]

@BarginHunter - I would seriously consider trading out any player you see as meaningfully overpriced. Take their price and divide by $5,000 - if you think they’ll average say 15 or 20 less than this, consider trading them to someone who can score similarly but who may be much cheaper.

Dumont to someone like Simpkin would be one to consider if you don’t have him.

Dumont hasn't had a score lower than 80 this season. 3 80's, 2 90's and 5 100+, last 4 matches have all been 110+. Maybe slightly overpriced right now, but not by 15-20.

 

[Eagling]

Duncan has averaged over 100 points per season for each of the previous 3 seasons and again this year. He averaged 110 about 4 seasons ago too. Also averages 20+ games a season, which is more durable than most. I think you're confusing him with someone else, because he is consistently good (and underrated).

An average of 100 isn't elite midfield numbers.

 

[Backbone]

Worth doing
Jelly Pickett brander
To
Fyfe titch schoenberg?

 

[Willyorwonty]

An average of 100 isn't elite midfield numbers.

He finished 5th for aggregate points in 2017. It's hardly an aberration as you suggest. The guy is a star, but gets overlooked for Dangerfield and Kelly in recent years.

I wouldn't be worried at all if he was mid 7-8.