Round 17: Trades
- Thread starter IDIG
- Start date
If you want to keep loopholing McGovern you should:
Downgrade Cameron to a cheap Magpie. Collingwood plays Sunday, Sunday, Sunday all after WCE next few weeks.
Only Magpie donut with DPP (Mid/Fwd) is Karnezies $230k if you wanted to keep the swing set.
Otherwise John Marsh $117k, Caolan Mooney $178k or Tim Broomhead $123k are all pure FWD.
Note: Broomhead has played 2 games already this season, recently too, Rounds 13 & 14. So to be bringing him as a donut could be dangerous as he may well get picked again.
That Collingwood player could also be useful if your VC goes big and you don't want to use Pendles as your C.
Downgrade Cameron to a cheap Magpie. Collingwood plays Sunday, Sunday, Sunday all after WCE next few weeks.
Only Magpie donut with DPP (Mid/Fwd) is Karnezies $230k if you wanted to keep the swing set.
Otherwise John Marsh $117k, Caolan Mooney $178k or Tim Broomhead $123k are all pure FWD.
Note: Broomhead has played 2 games already this season, recently too, Rounds 13 & 14. So to be bringing him as a donut could be dangerous as he may well get picked again.
That Collingwood player could also be useful if your VC goes big and you don't want to use Pendles as your C.
Last edited:
A small concern with bringing in Mitchell is that you only have M/D premiums not rookies so i'm not sure the points on ground gained per week is gonna make it worthwhile. Even bringing in Wingard doesn't seem a priority although i do understand it's to gain points this week as well as provide season long cover (whcih i dont hate) but trades in hand are a bit of a worry for mine. Are you focusing more on league or overall?
Like it mate. Reckon Rockliff now becomes a bit of a POD as alot of teams would've gone Gaz to Rockliff if he wasnt out suspended.
I'm with ya, Libba without a doubt. Cotchin while he has been goood of late, let's not forget the other weeks when he's been less good
Barlow is good but my concern is restings. If he doesn't get rested, he'd be not far behind Libba imo.
I find it interesting you're prioritising Hooker to Bartel over Ablett to midfielder (especially with Rockliff in your squad) this week. I haven't checked break evens etc but i'd almost always try to avoid the midfield donut instead of semi upgrading. I dont think it makes a big difference either way, just found it interesting.
Option 2 for me but i'd be holding the trade/McGovern and holding the 3 trades. As long as he's playing that would be enough for me. If you were starting him or lopping him that would be a different story though
How many trades left mate? Without a rookie link i don't like the idea of bringing in Mitchell as you're kinda depending on one of your premiums to miss to make it worth it. With Leuey back i'd be waiting to see how that affects Martin as he's scoring quite well at the moment.
How many trades left GG? Is this plan in the scenario you keep Gaz?
Like it mate. Reckon Rockliff now becomes a bit of a POD as alot of teams would've gone Gaz to Rockliff if he wasnt out suspended.
I'm with ya, Libba without a doubt. Cotchin while he has been goood of late, let's not forget the other weeks when he's been less good
Barlow is good but my concern is restings. If he doesn't get rested, he'd be not far behind Libba imo.
I find it interesting you're prioritising Hooker to Bartel over Ablett to midfielder (especially with Rockliff in your squad) this week. I haven't checked break evens etc but i'd almost always try to avoid the midfield donut instead of semi upgrading. I dont think it makes a big difference either way, just found it interesting.
Option 2 for me but i'd be holding the trade/McGovern and holding the 3 trades. As long as he's playing that would be enough for me. If you were starting him or lopping him that would be a different story though
How many trades left mate? Without a rookie link i don't like the idea of bringing in Mitchell as you're kinda depending on one of your premiums to miss to make it worth it. With Leuey back i'd be waiting to see how that affects Martin as he's scoring quite well at the moment.
Thoughts on Daniel McStray from the Lions, DEF???
$117K and whilst I don't think he'll score too great will at least be some DEF cover for me. Was he the starting sub in his first game??
Thinking maybe the double downgrade this week now that Rockliff is out and his price wound change.
McGovern ----> Honeychurch
O'Brien/Shenton ----> McStray (via Hunt DPP)
Creating a decent amount of funds to hopefully go Shenton to Rockliff. Then again everything depends on what this specialist has to say about Gazza.
$117K and whilst I don't think he'll score too great will at least be some DEF cover for me. Was he the starting sub in his first game??
Thinking maybe the double downgrade this week now that Rockliff is out and his price wound change.
McGovern ----> Honeychurch
O'Brien/Shenton ----> McStray (via Hunt DPP)
Creating a decent amount of funds to hopefully go Shenton to Rockliff. Then again everything depends on what this specialist has to say about Gazza.
Hi Guys and Girls,
I would apprecaite some advice on my options for this week.
I have 5 trades and $218,200 in bank.
I have decided that GAJ will probably need to be traded out either this week or next so the way I see it these are my options:
Option 1.
Ablett to JPK and Shenton to Sloane (leaveing $59,500 in cash and 3 trades)
Dangerfield goes to forwards with Martin/Wingard in F6 and F7, Taylor becomes M9.
Option 2.
What are peoples thoughts on Birchall, he has had two poor weeks in a row (and due to drop another $40k to around $360k) this may be the last oppurtunity to fix him.
Birchall to Bartel and Ablett to SJ
(leaves 3 trades and $259k to make one more trade of Shenton to JPK or other mid >588k next week. Leaving 2 trades for injuries and Martin/Wingard as F6 and F7 and Taylor as M9)
What are others peoples thoughts and do you see any other options which suit my team.
Cheers in advace
I would apprecaite some advice on my options for this week.
I have 5 trades and $218,200 in bank.
I have decided that GAJ will probably need to be traded out either this week or next so the way I see it these are my options:
Option 1.
Ablett to JPK and Shenton to Sloane (leaveing $59,500 in cash and 3 trades)
Dangerfield goes to forwards with Martin/Wingard in F6 and F7, Taylor becomes M9.
Option 2.
What are peoples thoughts on Birchall, he has had two poor weeks in a row (and due to drop another $40k to around $360k) this may be the last oppurtunity to fix him.
Birchall to Bartel and Ablett to SJ
(leaves 3 trades and $259k to make one more trade of Shenton to JPK or other mid >588k next week. Leaving 2 trades for injuries and Martin/Wingard as F6 and F7 and Taylor as M9)
What are others peoples thoughts and do you see any other options which suit my team.
Cheers in advace
- Joined
- 26 Feb 2014
- Messages
- 3,147
- Likes
- 3,311
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Hi Guys and Girls,
I would apprecaite some advice on my options for this week.
I have 5 trades and $218,200 in bank.
I have decided that GAJ will probably need to be traded out either this week or next so the way I see it these are my options:
Option 1.
Ablett to JPK and Shenton to Sloane (leaveing $59,500 in cash and 3 trades)
Dangerfield goes to forwards with Martin/Wingard in F6 and F7, Taylor becomes M9.
Option 2.
What are peoples thoughts on Birchall, he has had two poor weeks in a row (and due to drop another $40k to around $360k) this may be the last oppurtunity to fix him.
Birchall to Bartel and Ablett to SJ
(leaves 3 trades and $259k to make one more trade of Shenton to JPK or other mid >588k next week. Leaving 2 trades for injuries and Martin/Wingard as F6 and F7 and Taylor as M9)
What are others peoples thoughts and do you see any other options which suit my team.
Cheers in advace
I would apprecaite some advice on my options for this week.
I have 5 trades and $218,200 in bank.
I have decided that GAJ will probably need to be traded out either this week or next so the way I see it these are my options:
Option 1.
Ablett to JPK and Shenton to Sloane (leaveing $59,500 in cash and 3 trades)
Dangerfield goes to forwards with Martin/Wingard in F6 and F7, Taylor becomes M9.
Option 2.
What are peoples thoughts on Birchall, he has had two poor weeks in a row (and due to drop another $40k to around $360k) this may be the last oppurtunity to fix him.
Birchall to Bartel and Ablett to SJ
(leaves 3 trades and $259k to make one more trade of Shenton to JPK or other mid >588k next week. Leaving 2 trades for injuries and Martin/Wingard as F6 and F7 and Taylor as M9)
What are others peoples thoughts and do you see any other options which suit my team.
Cheers in advace
With that said, I'd choose option 2. I like SJ and Bartel is a gun - Birchall is a liability now so get him out.
- Joined
- 26 Nov 2012
- Messages
- 366
- Likes
- 415
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Karnezis a chance for games if he keeps on the field. Kicked 4 in the magoos last week. Second forward role is there for the taking although Reid will be ahead of him and will play second match in the reserves this week after a half last week.
Broomhead was best of the listed players in the magoos and must be a chance for action in the next 2 weeks if you wish to avoid that situation. Pies rate him.
Mooney no chance of getting a game.
Broomhead was best of the listed players in the magoos and must be a chance for action in the next 2 weeks if you wish to avoid that situation. Pies rate him.
Mooney no chance of getting a game.
- Joined
- 26 Nov 2012
- Messages
- 366
- Likes
- 415
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Hi Guys and Girls,
I would apprecaite some advice on my options for this week.
I have 5 trades and $218,200 in bank.
I have decided that GAJ will probably need to be traded out either this week or next so the way I see it these are my options:
Option 1.
Ablett to JPK and Shenton to Sloane (leaveing $59,500 in cash and 3 trades)
Dangerfield goes to forwards with Martin/Wingard in F6 and F7, Taylor becomes M9.
Option 2.
What are peoples thoughts on Birchall, he has had two poor weeks in a row (and due to drop another $40k to around $360k) this may be the last oppurtunity to fix him.
Birchall to Bartel and Ablett to SJ
(leaves 3 trades and $259k to make one more trade of Shenton to JPK or other mid >588k next week. Leaving 2 trades for injuries and Martin/Wingard as F6 and F7 and Taylor as M9)
What are others peoples thoughts and do you see any other options which suit my team.
Cheers in advace
I would apprecaite some advice on my options for this week.
I have 5 trades and $218,200 in bank.
I have decided that GAJ will probably need to be traded out either this week or next so the way I see it these are my options:
Option 1.
Ablett to JPK and Shenton to Sloane (leaveing $59,500 in cash and 3 trades)
Dangerfield goes to forwards with Martin/Wingard in F6 and F7, Taylor becomes M9.
Option 2.
What are peoples thoughts on Birchall, he has had two poor weeks in a row (and due to drop another $40k to around $360k) this may be the last oppurtunity to fix him.
Birchall to Bartel and Ablett to SJ
(leaves 3 trades and $259k to make one more trade of Shenton to JPK or other mid >588k next week. Leaving 2 trades for injuries and Martin/Wingard as F6 and F7 and Taylor as M9)
What are others peoples thoughts and do you see any other options which suit my team.
Cheers in advace
Two highly rated players in and mids sorted.