SCS Supercoach Ultimate League

[KLo30]

​

 

[Deeman1]

@KLo30 and @Goodie's Guns

Can I have some clarification about the medical sub effect on selected players.

I believe I selected S P-Seton as a starting DEF for round 7, whom started as the Medical Sub for Carlton. I noticed on the Round 7 sheet, he had been recorded as a DNP and was replaced by A Bonar EMG (ironically he was also the medical sub, but was subbed out, lol).

I think P-Steton did actually play and was subbed on early due to injury and scored 60 odd, which was higher than Bonar who was 20 odd and subbed out.

Does a player whom starts as the Medial Sub automattically count as a DNP even if they do play in the end? I know that in this case it may be a thing of conveience that S P-Seton would have been a better result than Bonar coming in as EMG, but just thought I would ask the question?

I have checked the rules, but was unable to find anything, if it has been addressed can you please point me in the right direction

 

[Goodie's Guns]

@KLo30 and @Goodie's Guns

Can I have some clarification about the medical sub effect on selected players.

I believe I selected S P-Seton as a starting DEF for round 7, whom started as the Medical Sub for Carlton. I noticed on the Round 7 sheet, he had been recorded as a DNP and was replaced by A Bonar EMG (ironically he was also the medical sub, but was subbed out, lol).

I think P-Steton did actually play and was subbed on early due to injury and scored 60 odd, which was higher than Bonar who was 20 odd and subbed out.

Does a player whom starts as the Medial Sub automattically count as a DNP even if they do play in the end? I know that in this case it may be a thing of conveience that S P-Seton would have been a better result than Bonar coming in as EMG, but just thought I would ask the question?

I have checked the rules, but was unable to find anything, if it has been addressed can you please point me in the right direction

I’m not sure what Ken’s thoughts are, but my thinking is that SPS’s score should count given he was still on field for you. Had he not been subbed on, then yes Bonar should replace as a normal EMG replacement, but given SPS played in the end it should be his score counted.

Alternatively, had you noted in the sheet say Saturday night that Bonar is to replace SPS as he wasn’t selected for the Blues. Then Bonar would go into the 22 as a pre fixture starting change. Which is what I did the week before when Tom Lynch was outside the 22, and I replaced him with Rowe in my 22 prior to the Crows game.

 

[lappinitup]

Flagging a rule addition for after season discussion, which would mirror the AFL competition.

RULE 1
Teams would be allowed to designated players to an injury list which would rule them out of the season for SCSUL. Players would need to be out for the season or the vast majority of the season when designated. For example, James Sicily, Wayne Milera and Connor Budarick.

Players placed on the injured list would then be allowed to replaced during the draft process.

The players salary would still count under the cap, so teams will need the cap space to be able to draft a player.

The drafted players would only be allowed to be drafted for a period of one year. Free agents under the free agent conditions and rookies under the rookie conditions. Rookies would therefore become eligible for a 2nd Contract.

If a player is placed on the injured list prior to the Preseason Signing and Draft Period commencing the list space is eligible to be filled during this period. However, teams would not be required to replace the player at this time.

To mirror the AFL competition a Mid Season Draft would be implemented where injury list players could be replaced via draft at this time. The draft order would be reverse ladder position at this time. Only teams with sufficient contract and player space (less than 44) would eligible at this time.

RULE 2
If a Mid Season Draft is enacted, teams would be allowed to keep open a list place(s) to be able to be filled in the Mid Season Draft.

Teams must allow sufficient salary and contract cap space (or a designated price set by SCSUL) and must draft a player(s) to complete the 44 player roster requirements.

Players drafted during this period would be drafted under the same conditions as the Preseason Signing and Draft Period. OR same conditions with a maximum contract length of 2 years.


Edit: Discussion could include whether you are allowed to trade into a better salary cap position and use that salary or only be eligible to use the salary cap space available at the conclusion of the Preseason Signing and Draft Period. For example, trade from $140,000 cap space to $600,00. Therefore, allowing a team to go from picking a rookie to a premium such as David Mundy OR only allow the original $140,000 to pick up Nathan Krueger.

Is the introduction of new rules slated for next year or this year?

I like the idea, just don't think it is fair to introduce in the middle of this season, when teams have structured up according to the rules at the time.

Admittedly, I missed this thread, as I thought all activity had moved to our own Sub thread. Didn't have time to spend on here last week - however I know a mid season draft this season would be useless to me as I have traded and structured according to the rules.

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Flagging a rule addition for after season discussion, which would mirror the AFL competition.

RULE 1
Teams would be allowed to designated players to an injury list which would rule them out of the season for SCSUL. Players would need to be out for the season or the vast majority of the season when designated. For example, James Sicily, Wayne Milera and Connor Budarick.

Players placed on the injured list would then be allowed to replaced during the draft process.

The players salary would still count under the cap, so teams will need the cap space to be able to draft a player.

The drafted players would only be allowed to be drafted for a period of one year. Free agents under the free agent conditions and rookies under the rookie conditions. Rookies would therefore become eligible for a 2nd Contract.

If a player is placed on the injured list prior to the Preseason Signing and Draft Period commencing the list space is eligible to be filled during this period. However, teams would not be required to replace the player at this time.

To mirror the AFL competition a Mid Season Draft would be implemented where injury list players could be replaced via draft at this time. The draft order would be reverse ladder position at this time. Only teams with sufficient contract and player space (less than 44) would eligible at this time.

RULE 2
If a Mid Season Draft is enacted, teams would be allowed to keep open a list place(s) to be able to be filled in the Mid Season Draft.

Teams must allow sufficient salary and contract cap space (or a designated price set by SCSUL) and must draft a player(s) to complete the 44 player roster requirements.

Players drafted during this period would be drafted under the same conditions as the Preseason Signing and Draft Period. OR same conditions with a maximum contract length of 2 years.


Edit: Discussion could include whether you are allowed to trade into a better salary cap position and use that salary or only be eligible to use the salary cap space available at the conclusion of the Preseason Signing and Draft Period. For example, trade from $140,000 cap space to $600,00. Therefore, allowing a team to go from picking a rookie to a premium such as David Mundy OR only allow the original $140,000 to pick up Nathan Krueger.

Is the introduction of new rules slated for next year or this year?

I like the idea, just don't think it is fair to introduce in the middle of this season, when teams have structured up according to the rules at the time.

Admittedly, I missed this thread, as I thought all activity had moved to our own Sub thread. Didn't have time to spend on here last week - however I know a mid season draft this season would be useless to me as I have traded and structured according to the rules.

See bolded

 

[lappinitup]

haha makes sense.

Apologies, still kicking myself I missed changing my team this week.

First week I haven't check main forum and was the worst week to do so!

 

[lappinitup]

I’m not sure what Ken’s thoughts are, but my thinking is that SPS’s score should count given he was still on field for you. Had he not been subbed on, then yes Bonar should replace as a normal EMG replacement, but given SPS played in the end it should be his score counted.

Alternatively, had you noted in the sheet say Saturday night that Bonar is to replace SPS as he wasn’t selected for the Blues. Then Bonar would go into the 22 as a pre fixture starting change. Which is what I did the week before when Tom Lynch was outside the 22, and I replaced him with Rowe in my 22 prior to the Crows game.

Interesting question!

This is a rare example where the player subbed on scores more than a starting 22 player, would usually work against you.

 

[KLo30]

@KLo30 and @Goodie's Guns

Can I have some clarification about the medical sub effect on selected players.

I believe I selected S P-Seton as a starting DEF for round 7, whom started as the Medical Sub for Carlton. I noticed on the Round 7 sheet, he had been recorded as a DNP and was replaced by A Bonar EMG (ironically he was also the medical sub, but was subbed out, lol).

I think P-Steton did actually play and was subbed on early due to injury and scored 60 odd, which was higher than Bonar who was 20 odd and subbed out.

Does a player whom starts as the Medial Sub automattically count as a DNP even if they do play in the end? I know that in this case it may be a thing of conveience that S P-Seton would have been a better result than Bonar coming in as EMG, but just thought I would ask the question?

I have checked the rules, but was unable to find anything, if it has been addressed can you please point me in the right direction

I’m not sure what Ken’s thoughts are, but my thinking is that SPS’s score should count given he was still on field for you. Had he not been subbed on, then yes Bonar should replace as a normal EMG replacement, but given SPS played in the end it should be his score counted.

Alternatively, had you noted in the sheet say Saturday night that Bonar is to replace SPS as he wasn’t selected for the Blues. Then Bonar would go into the 22 as a pre fixture starting change. Which is what I did the week before when Tom Lynch was outside the 22, and I replaced him with Rowe in my 22 prior to the Crows game.

SPS's score will count.

I went out late afternoon, at which point SPS wasn't playing, and made the change to ensure "accurate" scores for teams to follow. Didn't even realise he had played until now (and I have him in a keeper league).

 

[lappinitup]

SPS's score will count.

I went out late afternoon, at which point SPS wasn't playing, and made the change to ensure "accurate" scores for teams to follow. Didn't even realise he had played until now (and I have him in a keeper league).

He was actually good too!!

 

[KLo30]

SCSUL MOTHER'S DAY ROUND​

Round 8 will have a pink edge as SCSUL celebrate the women in their lives with the inaugural Mother's Day round.

 

[KLo30]

​

 

[KLo30]

​

 

[KLo30]

​

 

[Diabolical]

View attachment 29853​

Does this mean the Round 9 doc is now available? If so, sorry, I can’t work out how to find it. Posts earlier say to look for “shared with me” but not sure where I find that? I tried typing it in search.

 

[Darkie]

Does this mean the Round 9 doc is now available? If so, sorry, I can’t work out how to find it. Posts earlier say to look for “shared with me” but not sure where I find that? I tried typing it in search.

I generally use the app (which is worth downloading for anyone who doesn’t have it).

In there, at the top left and probably next to where you searched, there is an icon made up of three horizontal lines.

If you click on that, it gives a list of options, and “Shared with me” is one of those.

Personally I have “Starred” the main 2021 sheet as well, which helps in finding it (Starred being another one of the options in that dropdown list).

 

[KLo30]

Does this mean the Round 9 doc is now available? If so, sorry, I can’t work out how to find it. Posts earlier say to look for “shared with me” but not sure where I find that? I tried typing it in search.

Yes, Round 9 sheet is now available. I don't know how you are accessing the sheets, so not quite sure how to guide you to "Shared with me".

 

[Diabolical]

I generally use the app (which is worth downloading for anyone who doesn’t have it).

In there, at the top left and probably next to where you searched, there is an icon made up of three horizontal lines.

If you click on that, it gives a list of options, and “Shared with me” is one of those.

Personally I have “Starred” the main 2021 sheet as well, which helps in finding it (Starred being another one of the options in that dropdown list).

Thank you ... you are a genius. You are right I was typing right next to those three lines without realising I could click them!!

Sorry @KLo30 I am not a good self learner with IT, often needing very basic instructions ... I think my IT department at work cringe every time I ring them after they change something!

All good now though, I’m in!

 

[Darkie]

Thank you ... you are a genius. You are right I was typing right next to those three lines without realising I could click them!!

Sorry @KLo30 I am not a good self learner with IT, often needing very basic instructions ... I think my IT department at work cringe every time I ring them after they change something!

All good now though, I’m in!

No worries! I’m okay with some tech things, but similarly terrible with others.

The horizontal lines seem to be called a “burger bar” by some of our IT people (might be a standard term, might not) and I think it’s intended to signify a menu.

Probably not the most intuitive icon for developers to have chosen from my perspective, but it does make some sense once you know it!

 

[KLo30]

REMINDER​

WEEKLY TRADE DEADLINE

• 7:30pm Wednesday for players in Thursday teams.
• 7:30pm Thursday for players in Friday+ teams.

 

[KLo30]

​