Strategy 2023: Player X v Player Y

[Ironhawk]

Keays v Finlayson

My initial thought was Keays, but the more I look at it, the more I am favouring Finlayson. It's fairly even, but I will say Finlayson.

 

[PC]

My initial thought was Keays, but the more I look at it, the more I am favouring Finlayson. It's fairly even, but I will say Finlayson.

Even this week if Dixon and Lycett are out?

 

[Ironhawk]

Even this week if Dixon and Lycett are out?

There's 7 weeks left.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Need a Titch replacement...

LDU v Miller

 

[Miller is a Steele]

Need a Titch replacement...

LDU v Miller

Confirmed to be sub if that changes your mind.

Of those 2, I’d go Miller. Named in the middle and I think the Suns will go all out for a win this week and unleash him.

 

[BarginHunter]

TT vs Cogs

 

[Ironhawk]

Need a Titch replacement...

LDU v Miller

I prefer LDU. Not entirely sure why, but just a gut feeling - I think the Suns might put the cue in the rack, and their more secure players (those not playing to keep their spot) might just cruise the rest of the season. North are not a better team than the Suns of course, but LDU is their best player, and I don't see the Roos dropping their level at all - their level is just not high.

Could be completely wrong on this one.

 

[Ironhawk]

TT vs Cogs

Cogs. Taranto has dropped a bit lately, not entirely sure why, but Cogs surprisingly seems the one in better form.

 

[Courtesans]

Dont have English let alone have the VC on him, already cactus this week half a game into the first game!

 

[BarginHunter]

Cogs. Taranto has dropped a bit lately, not entirely sure why, but Cogs surprisingly seems the one in better form.

Sorry i meant TT=Thomas
Not Taranto 😬

 

[Ironhawk]

Sorry i meant TT=Thomas
Not Taranto 😬

Still Cogs then.

Sorry about that.

 

[Zim^zuM]

Petracca vs Cerra vs Parish vs Sicily as a in for Oliver.

2 trades left

 

[Ironhawk]

Petracca vs Cerra vs Parish vs Sicily as a in for Oliver.

2 trades left

Petracca would be my preference here.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

I prefer LDU. Not entirely sure why, but just a gut feeling - I think the Suns might put the cue in the rack, and their more secure players (those not playing to keep their spot) might just cruise the rest of the season. North are not a better team than the Suns of course, but LDU is their best player, and I don't see the Roos dropping their level at all - their level is just not high.

Could be completely wrong on this one.

Confirmed to be sub if that changes your mind.

Of those 2, I’d go Miller. Named in the middle and I think the Suns will go all out for a win this week and unleash him.

Thanks both, will be tossing and turning between those 2 all weekend I reckon.
I prefer Miller's history but the $30k saving in LDU does mean that I can turn Sheldrick into a better F6 next week.
Decisions...

 

[NT.Thunder]

Cripps versus Steele to run the season out.

 

[Ironhawk]

Cripps versus Steele to run the season out.

With little confidence - Cripps

 

[Darkie]

With little confidence - Cripps

Agree with this.

 

[mwross91]

Green problems:

Touk vs. LDU vs. Steele vs. Cripps


Leaning towards Touk or LDU.

North actually have a pretty decent run home and if he's fit I think he outscores the rest?
Touk obviously the biggest upside - proven premo and new caretaker coach probably means he just gets back in the middle?

Steele and Cripps seem like traps?

 

[Quarterback]

Which one of these D/F players has the best job security in your opinion?
B Long v O Lord v C Sharman.

 

[Ironhawk]

Green problems:

Touk vs. LDU vs. Steele vs. Cripps


Leaning towards Touk or LDU.

North actually have a pretty decent run home and if he's fit I think he outscores the rest?
Touk obviously the biggest upside - proven premo and new caretaker coach probably means he just gets back in the middle?

Steele and Cripps seem like traps?

In other X v Y's this week I have gone for LDU over Touk and Cripps over Steele. LDU v Cripps - prefer LDU.

Which one of these D/F players has the best job security in your opinion?
B Long v O Lord v C Sharman.

All have been dropped at points. Sharman is the only one who was playing last round, so probably has the best JS to answer the question. All are terrible scorers, I'd advise against all of them.