Opinion 2024 AFL SuperCoach Planning Thread

Diabolical

Leadership Group
Joined
17 Jun 2014
Messages
9,618
Likes
37,716
AFL Club
Essendon
What age do players generally become too great of a risk? I know there will always be a couple of exceptions, but I wouldn’t mind knowing the tipping point when form falls away or above average games start being missed for that player.

I am starting to see Libba appearing in a few teams. I realise that he is coming off a career best season, but he turns 32 this year, so I am seeing warning lights. How likely is he to stay on the park and repeat that form?

Similarly, Gawn turns 33 at the end of the year. Is he likely to play all games and go 110+?
 
Joined
6 Jul 2012
Messages
4,890
Likes
11,150
AFL Club
West Coast
What age do players generally become too great of a risk? I know there will always be a couple of exceptions, but I wouldn’t mind knowing the tipping point when form falls away or above average games start being missed for that player.

I am starting to see Libba appearing in a few teams. I realise that he is coming off a career best season, but he turns 32 this year, so I am seeing warning lights. How likely is he to stay on the park and repeat that form?

Similarly, Gawn turns 33 at the end of the year. Is he likely to play all games and go 110+?
30 is meant to be a level everyone becomes cautious

Libba entered last year 30 and took his average up 12 SC points. That's includes his injury impacted level.

Games last three seasons 21, 22, 25.

Main contributor I expect is CBAs went to 78% from 59/69/59 which all delivered 104-105. Maybe it was less Macrae in the middle. Potn he could become Petracca but then I cop a bye and need to find cash.
 
Joined
15 Jan 2018
Messages
1,973
Likes
5,007
AFL Club
Richmond
What age do players generally become too great of a risk? I know there will always be a couple of exceptions, but I wouldn’t mind knowing the tipping point when form falls away or above average games start being missed for that player.

I am starting to see Libba appearing in a few teams. I realise that he is coming off a career best season, but he turns 32 this year, so I am seeing warning lights. How likely is he to stay on the park and repeat that form?

Similarly, Gawn turns 33 at the end of the year. Is he likely to play all games and go 110+?
I think gawn is 105-110ave i dont see him as a keeper and i dont see him playing every game. Bring in marshall/english round 6.
 
Joined
24 Feb 2015
Messages
6,697
Likes
30,160
AFL Club
Sydney
10 tons for Jackson vs 7 for Dusty at similar prices, would you pick anyone else with a bigger scope for points?
Yeah I forgot Dusty also has the bye early so I'm reconsidering. Jackson I'll take if Darcy isn't playing early. I'll watch the Harmes, Jordan, Lynch types and that'll likely determine my structure
 
Joined
12 Jan 2014
Messages
3,763
Likes
11,759
AFL Club
West Coast
Interesting thought on Gawn turning 33 this year. Had a look at rucks and best years for guys in that 32/33 age bracket that I could think of are as follows.

Goldy. His DOB is July and in the year he turned 32 ave was 112.
Sandi His DOB is December and in the year he turned 33 went 107. But he was really 32 during the season.
Big Cox His DOB August and the year he turned 32 went 107.

Gawn has his DOB 30th December so will be 32 for the entire season this year but I could only find Goldy as a close example of a 110 plus ruck.
Might have missed someone but going back to the Lade and Darren Jolly days might not be relevant in the modern game anyway. Although these guys all played on none really got back to their peak days, which is natural enough.

So I think a 105-110 ave for the season is a fair peg for Gawn but he could of course go on a tear at some point. If you are not happy with sub 110 season ave then do you need to reconsider him? Or hope he goes big early and trade out for Max cash (did you see what I did there:LOL:).
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
AFL 2024: Daniel Rioli talks shaking off injury, possible midfield move, Maurice Rioli
After a battling 2023, Richmond dasher Daniel Rioli is looking ahead to exciting times under new coach Adem Yze, which could involve a different role in the Tiger team.


Jon Ralph
Follow
@RalphyHeraldSun
3 min read
February 4, 2024 - 6:16PM



Richmond dasher Daniel Rioli says new coach Adem Yze has dangled the carrot of some midfield time as a shock weapon like cousin Cyril Rioli in his Hawthorn glory days.

It comes as Rioli backed in his close relative Maurice Rioli to put his new-found maturity on show in a make-or-break season at Punt Road.

Tigers defender Rioli has packed a full career’s worth of moments in his eight seasons as a triple premiership small forward with a Goal of the Year award before winning All Australian 40 honours in 2022 as a half back.


Now the 26-year-old has a new coach in Yze and potentially new challenges despite his desire to again dominate at half back after limping through 2023 with a niggling ankle injury.

Rioli said instead of spending time on the training track he too often had his ankle in a bucket of ice as fluid in the joint saw him playing hurt for interim coach Andrew McQualter.


McQualter missed out on the new role for former Demons star Yze, who honed his coaching skills in a side with star small forward Cyril Rioli during their premiership era.

Daniel Rioli is again injury free and told the Herald Sun he still wasn’t sure how to take Yze’s suggestion of some midfield minutes.

“He wants me to play mostly half back but he made a comment to me: “What is your nickname? What about ‘Silk”,” Rioli told the Herald Sun after the club’s intraclub clash on Wednesday.

“He said if we needed a ‘Cyril’ or a Shaun Burgoyne to provide spark in the midfield why not? They were ‘Mr Fix-it’ players. He did make that comment and obviously I want to play half back this year. I haven’t played a lot of midfield time in my AFL career so I am excited if that does come about. Midfield, forward, back to the backline, I am happy. He has got a lot of confidence in our players and I am thrilled to play under him.”

“Last year was a bit of a roller coaster for us. We all have confidence in Yze’s game plan and what he brings to the club.”

Last year Rioli’s stats were almost identical to his breakout 2022 as a defender – resulting in a fifth-placing in the Jack Dyer Medal.

But too often he hobbled into games and played through contests despite re-injuring his ankle.

“It was tough with the injury and I just tried to do the right thing for the team to get out there. A nice off-season helped. I got off my legs for a bit and I am cherry ripe now but there was heaps of fluid on my ankle that kept bugging me through the year,” he said.

“I couldn’t even walk on it at some stages. The ankle was a bit blue and I had to be at home with an ice bucket every night and that got me through but I had a good physio who looked after me.”

Post-season Rioli and partner Paris Lawrence escaped for some sightseeing to Tokyo before returning to his home in the Tiwi Islands over Christmas.

The club had urged third-year forward Maurice Rioli to rededicate himself to his fitness across the off-season given his tank did not allow him to get to enough contests in a ten-game 2023 AFL season.

He returned in adequate rather than outstanding shape but Daniel Rioli said he had made up for lost time since then.

“Obviously Maurice has got a long way to go. He’s still young and he’s pretty raw to this game so we know what a good pressure player he is. He is now (in good shape). I go home a lot and have a lot of bush tucker which puts me over that scale a bit,” he said.

“We both try to come back in reasonable shape but obviously the club has good programs through training. He has been good. He is still young and learning and if he doesn’t come back as fit he’s got a good program with physios and coaches who talk him through things

“He is still getting to that stage where he is maturing. He is only 21 years old and this year he needs to get into it and show the people what he’s made of.”
 
Top