Strategy 2024: Round 4 Trades

Joined
5 Feb 2014
Messages
1,354
Likes
6,817
AFL Club
Carlton
@Athomas has Mackay's role changed slightly or is he still relying on 3+ goals a game to ton up.
He’s averaging about 10% ruck contests, up from 3-4% last year.

But I would say it’s mainly he’s kicking accurately this season.

Being up around the ball more does help the floor a little, but his HO win rate still very low so just a few extra disposals here and there.
 
Joined
2 Mar 2023
Messages
1,931
Likes
7,044
AFL Club
Essendon
I'd be a little careful with Heeney, Yeo did a proper job on Bont last week and I can see the same happening this week, it's nearly a Monty that Heeney will go forward to break the tag, much the same as Bont.

Bonts heat map from last week, note the almost non existent disposals from CBA's and I'd assume stoppages as well.

Thanks. Very helpful
 
Joined
24 Feb 2015
Messages
6,697
Likes
30,160
AFL Club
Sydney
Thoughts on top 8 forward by year's end, is his scoring sustainable for a ~95-100 average. I'm $8k shy of Flanders so probably between him and Zorko, struggling to see anyone else worth looking at.
He’s averaging about 10% ruck contests, up from 3-4% last year.

But I would say it’s mainly he’s kicking accurately this season.

Being up around the ball more does help the floor a little, but his HO win rate still very low so just a few extra disposals here and there.
 
Joined
2 Apr 2024
Messages
46
Likes
150
Welcome to the site!

I would say that Rozee to Mckay is at risk of chasing points. A month ago it would have been considered a pretty big downgrade, which for me is a good cross check.

If you’re keen to strengthen your forward line, Flanders looks a great alternative to me. Much more sustainable scoring/role in my view.
Thanks for the advice, it's only my second year doing supercoach so still finding my feet.

I know cash generation is big, any other insights you might have with my team setup? Is getting rid of coffield and hore important right now?
Would trading out Jordon to max king be a smart ay
 
Joined
2 Mar 2014
Messages
2,837
Likes
5,190
AFL Club
Essendon
Rd 4 pending team selections.

Out:

Wines, Fisher, Jordon

In:

MCrouch, Dempsey, Heeney

**Edit: Big watch on Elijah Hollands this week with a view to straight flip Harley Reid to him in the mids next week. Looking at the poor man's Sam Flanders role & 20+ possies.
 
Joined
9 Dec 2020
Messages
2,370
Likes
12,058
AFL Club
Essendon
Do they outweigh the reasons to get him in your opinion? I don't see why not.
Honestly I’d love to but I think I want to see his TOG get a bit higher before I grab him. Fitness seems to be an issue and has faded in some 4th quarters so I think his ceiling is a bit too low till that all sorts out.
But wouldn’t be surprised to see him go 120+ just from loving the match up!
 

Darkie

Leadership Group
Joined
12 Apr 2014
Messages
25,401
Likes
65,467
AFL Club
Collingwood
Thanks for the advice, it's only my second year doing supercoach so still finding my feet.

I know cash generation is big, any other insights you might have with my team setup? Is getting rid of coffield and hore important right now?
Would trading out Jordon to max king be a smart ay
No probs. Your side looks good to me, especially for someone in their second year!

A few thoughts that come to mind:

- Cash gen is very important, especially early in the year when almost all the good rookies debut, and when you get to deploy that cash for longest. You can’t build a good side without cash gen.

- You generally want a player to have a path to making 150k to be worth trading in. Take their price, divide by 5000, and that’s roughly what they are priced to score. They need to beat that by 30+ points to make 150k, which is often a high hurdle. Very low priced players (largely rookies) and those who haven’t had their first price rise are much more likely than others.

- In general, try to fill your forward line with players who aren’t actually playing as forwards. Key position forwards in particular can be volatile, but often more down than up.

- Where possible, try to have the better scoring rookies on field and vice versa. Eg ideally you’d have Sanders on field ahead of Berry. This might only add 10 or so points per week on current averages, but gives some direction in terms of where making upgrades will be most impactful.

- Your defence bench looks concerning, but you can probably live with it if you are uncomfortable with the new rookie options on that line (I am weighing this up myself), given best 18 rounds to come and then DPPs that could allow you to swing McKercher or Roberts back (and Sanders on field).

- Don’t trade to cover a single donut.

- When weighing up which rookies to trade out, look at both near term cash gen (based on breakevens/recent scores) as well as medium term prospects - ie if they can get to what you expect them to score x 5,000, that might still be appealing even if they don’t make a lot this week or next.

Overall I would say my priorities for your side would be cash gen, strengthening F3+ and then the defence bench if you find an option that you find appealing. Good luck.
 
Top