Opinion Player X vs Player Y

Juzzo

Juzzo

#3,182
Joined
16 Jun 2013
Messages
5,465
Likes
11,297
AFL Club
Adelaide
#3,182
bluesbrothers said:
Greene for me.. Although he can be erratic scoring wise, I think he has the points on board when compared to Smith.
Click to expand...
Agree, I had Smith last year and he was very frustrating. And he hasn't played many games this year and may not stay in the side imo.
 
I

Imcjb

#3,183
Joined
2 Apr 2014
Messages
513
Likes
91
#3,183
This has probably been asked already but I did a quick search and couldnt find anything.

Collins vs Ruggles for my D7 for the rest of the year. Will downgrade to R Williams I guess. This will allow me to go Menadue to Zorko finalising my team.
 
Johnsy44

Johnsy44

#3,184
Joined
27 Mar 2015
Messages
4,906
Likes
5,442
AFL Club
Carlton
#3,184
Imcjb said:
This has probably been asked already but I did a quick search and couldnt find anything.

Collins vs Ruggles for my D7 for the rest of the year. Will downgrade to R Williams I guess. This will allow me to go Menadue to Zorko finalising my team.
Click to expand...
If it was me I would probably keep Collins as he has a nice ceiling and seems to have decent js (not saying Ruggles doesn't)
 
GrainFedBeef

GrainFedBeef

#3,188
Joined
6 Jul 2012
Messages
4,890
Likes
11,150
AFL Club
West Coast
#3,188
Imcjb said:
This has probably been asked already but I did a quick search and couldnt find anything.

Collins vs Ruggles for my D7 for the rest of the year. Will downgrade to R Williams I guess. This will allow me to go Menadue to Zorko finalising my team.
Click to expand...
I chose Ruggles, think both score higher in easier games and Geelong has a better run particularly over league finals. Collins has the slightly better JS.

Just monitor Ruggles this week, looked to have a sore shoulder towards end of the game (in a late incident).
 
MC's Mix

MC's Mix

#3,189
Joined
17 Jan 2015
Messages
1,109
Likes
1,700
AFL Club
Collingwood
#3,189
Hey boys, looking to upgrade Kerridge (+10 in a straight swap as my final forward (had to trade Hall down last week), leaving me with 2 contingency trades.

Current lineup: Zorko, Joey, Lynch (GCS), Westhoff, Greene, Kerridge (Naismith, Rose)


and am tossing up between the following:
Buddy - Leaning towards him, even if he is following his trend of falling away towards the end of the season.
Lynch (Crows) - My current 2nd - A few easy games to finish off the year could result in some handy scores.
JRoo - Usually consistent for a key forward, though has a tough run.
Lycett - NicNat's return the unknown, though should still score reasonably well. May somehow be useful in conjunction with Naismith if a ruck goes down.


What do you think?
Cheers in advance
 
Mr_Arrogance

Mr_Arrogance

#3,192
Joined
20 Jul 2012
Messages
930
Likes
276
AFL Club
Geelong
#3,192
MC's Mix said:
Hey boys, looking to upgrade Kerridge (+10 in a straight swap as my final forward (had to trade Hall down last week), leaving me with 2 contingency trades.

Current lineup: Zorko, Joey, Lynch (GCS), Westhoff, Greene, Kerridge (Naismith, Rose)


and am tossing up between the following:
Buddy - Leaning towards him, even if he is following his trend of falling away towards the end of the season.
Lynch (Crows) - My current 2nd - A few easy games to finish off the year could result in some handy scores.
JRoo - Usually consistent for a key forward, though has a tough run.
Lycett - NicNat's return the unknown, though should still score reasonably well. May somehow be useful in conjunction with Naismith if a ruck goes down.


What do you think?
Cheers in advance
Click to expand...
Or if Dalhaus is back this week, could wait the one week and pick him up after he drops massively?
 
Brettthejett

Brettthejett

#3,193
Joined
22 Jan 2013
Messages
3,858
Likes
1,652
AFL Club
Collingwood
#3,193
Mitchell has - Carlton (tassie), Melb (mcg), north (mcg), WC (domain also possible rest game) and collingwood (mcg)
Rocky has - Port (gabba), Adel (adel), Carlton (mcg), geelong (gabba) and Saints (etihad)

Like mitchell with the easier draw but the rest factor is the main concern, for this reason id go with rocky
 
Johnsy44

Johnsy44

#3,199
Joined
27 Mar 2015
Messages
4,906
Likes
5,442
AFL Club
Carlton
#3,199
Bomber18 said:
Gibbs v Ward ?
Click to expand...
Both very valid picks
But I think I'm leaning towards Gibbs, in some pretty decent form and has a very nice run home. He also seems to be a pretty big POD. If you do decide to go Ward, I'm sure he will still do pretty well but my vote goes towards Gibbs
 
Bomber18

Bomber18

Leadership Group
#3,200
Joined
11 Nov 2012
Messages
27,409
Likes
65,138
AFL Club
Essendon
#3,200
Johnsy44 said:
Both very valid picks
But I think I'm leaning towards Gibbs, in some pretty decent form and has a very nice run home. He also seems to be a pretty big POD. If you do decide to go Ward, I'm sure he will still do pretty well but my vote goes towards Gibbs
Click to expand...
Thanks mate, good to hear a Blues supporter back me on Gibbs. Slightly worried about a Robbo tag though :S When's murphy back?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top