Player X vs. Player Y

[TeeButOne]

Zerrett & McLean Vs Dusty & Daniher

Dusty & McLean

McLean & Daniher are pretty much the same price, and I can't see Daniher being a solid selection at all.

 

[Darkie]

Zerrett & McLean Vs Dusty & Daniher

Zerrett has a massive BE, I wouldn't bring him in this week. Dusty will go up in price as well, and gives you a very good VC/C option. Clearly Dusty over Zerrett if the other two are similarly priced.

 

[Johnsy44]

Grundy vs Nic Nat and cash

 

[TeeButOne]

Grundy vs Nic Nat and cash

Who are you planning on trading out for either of these guys? If it's a luxury, non-injury trade, I'd rather go with the value option (plus you'll feel great watching Naitanui and knowing you have him in your team).

 

[Johnsy44]

Who are you planning on trading out for either of these guys? If it's a luxury, non-injury trade, I'd rather go with the value option (plus you'll feel great watching Naitanui and knowing you have him in your team).

Moving on from Lycett and Lobb so will be grabbing a premium ruck and rookie, either crowden or Richards. Have Olango at R3

 

[Steuby]

R.Gray v M. Walters v T.Mclean

 

[MC's Mix]

R.Gray v M. Walters v T.Mclean

On points only:
Gray > McLean > Walters

If I were picking for my squad right now I'd choose McLean, simply because of Gray's bye week.

 

[inwhiterooms]

R.Gray v M. Walters v T.Mclean

Same conundrum here. It's down to McLean and Gray for me, don't like Walters chances of getting up for this week with that nasty hand injury.

 

[DoggyODFL]

Ablett to Mitchell or Macrae?

I do like the POD of 1.6% team ownership of Macrae
I know I will have to get Mitchell at some point (and Danger) - will I make enough cash for those 2 down the track

 

[30BucketsofRo]

Ablett to Mitchell or Macrae?

I do like the POD of 1.6% team ownership of Macrae
I know I will have to get Mitchell at some point (and Danger) - will I make enough cash for those 2 down the track

Who do you want more?
I'd take Titch first personally

 

[Steuby]

Ablett to Mitchell or Macrae?

I do like the POD of 1.6% team ownership of Macrae
I know I will have to get Mitchell at some point (and Danger) - will I make enough cash for those 2 down the track

Titchell for me

1. Better history to back it up
2. Relatively higher % to finish as a MID keeper
3. Confidence to put C/VC on

I know jack and bontempelli are different players but:
- Bont (last year) like Jack was looking to breakout into the super premium category after a strong previous season (107 for both)
- Bont scored 120, 140 ,133 in the first 3 rounds and averaged 123.5 after 7 rounds, looking to be an absolute must-have
- Proceeds to average 105 for the season (96.5 after round 7)

What i'm trying to say is that although they're different players, we must take into consideration a larger sample and jack macrae's initial 3 rounds (120, 142 , 131) could potentially be his best scores for the whole season

I'm not saying don't get Macrae, but Titchell for me is a less 'risky' player and would likely be in your team come years end

 

[BigRuss]

Ablett to Mitchell or Macrae?

I do like the POD of 1.6% team ownership of Macrae
I know I will have to get Mitchell at some point (and Danger) - will I make enough cash for those 2 down the track

Big Macrae fan here and think he’ll comfortably finish in the top 10 mids this year. That being said, it looks like we need Titch for the captain scores. Chances are you’ve probably missed 3 of his best 5 scores for the year but he’ll still bang out 120s most weeks from here on out.

Keep you eye on Macrae the next month or so and if he’s still travelling well, bring him in as part of the upgrade cycle.

 

[DoggyODFL]

Who do you want more?
I'd take Titch first personally

Titchell for me

1. Better history to back it up
2. Relatively higher % to finish as a MID keeper
3. Confidence to put C/VC on

I know jack and bontempelli are different players but:
- Bont (last year) like Jack is looking to breakout into the super premium category after a strong previous season (107 for both)
- Bont scored 120, 140 ,133 in the first 3 rounds and averaged 123.5 after 7 rounds, looking to be an absolute must-have
- Proceeds to average 105 for the season (96.5 after round 7)

What i'm trying to say is that although they're different players, we must take into consideration a larger sample and jack macrae's initial 3 rounds (120, 142 , 131) could potentially be his best scores for the whole season

I'm not saying don't get Macrae, but Titchell for me is a less 'risky' player and would likely be in your team come years end

Big Macrae fan here and think he’ll comfortably finish in the top 10 mids this year. That being said, it looks like we need Titch for the captain scores. Chances are you’ve probably missed 3 of his best 5 scores for the year but he’ll still bang out 120s most weeks from here on out.

Keep you eye on Macrae the next month or so and if he’s still travelling well, bring him in as part of the upgrade cycle.

Thanks - was leaning more towards Mitchell, good to be reminded by others of the logic in the decision

 

[Santoz]

Big Macrae fan here and think he’ll comfortably finish in the top 10 mids this year. That being said, it looks like we need Titch for the captain scores. Chances are you’ve probably missed 3 of his best 5 scores for the year but he’ll still bang out 120s most weeks from here on out.

Keep you eye on Macrae the next month or so and if he’s still travelling well, bring him in as part of the upgrade cycle.

McRae & McLean look like they're benefiting the most from Bont playing forward.

 

[Bob Loblaw]

Motlop Vs Cam-Ellis Yolman (for Draft) - Is this allowed?

 

[TommyGobbler]

Zerrett & McLean Vs Dusty & Daniher

Merrett & McLean

 

[TommyGobbler]

Savage v Sicily+90k

 

[blue dreamer]

Coniglio v Gray?

 

[THCLT]

Motlop Vs Cam-Ellis Yolman (for Draft) - Is this allowed?

Savage v Sicily+90k

Coniglio v Gray?

Depends on your current structure, how many Rookies you're currently playing on-field in the MIDs and FWDs.

Cogs will probably outscore Gray, however Gray more likely than Cogs to end as one of the top players for his position.

 

[pjay79]

R.Gray vs J.Hogan + cash