Player X vs. Player Y

[freowho]

I know I it's hard to compare rookies... But L.MURPHY VS WATERMAN?
Who looks like keeping their spot more? I want to trade Langdon and want to know who you think I should go to.

Waterman has a clear best 22 replacement in JJK, otherwise it's chooklotto.

 

[Ntay4]

What reason do you have to lose faith in Neale after two scores of 95+? Very sideways to Oliver and too soon for Danger imo.

Heard that Neale might be getting pushed out of his role that he had last season to make way for the freo rookies. Oliver also looks to be on another level this season with high scores against the cats and lions - whom have very solid midefields

 

[Steuby]

Heath Shaw vs Luke Ryan

 

[OzRulesFootball]

Heath Shaw vs Luke Ryan

I started both but Shaw the safer option with Zac Williams out for season and Nathan Wilson off to Freo and now Tom Scully out for 3 months. Shaw will likely be the main guy running ball out of back half which he was starting to lose that role to these other 3 guys later last season.

 

[bomberboy]

Taranto vs Curnow vs Acres.

Leaning towards Taranto.

My other forwards are:
Heeney, Billings, McLean, Sicily and Fritsch.

 

[craig freer]

Brayshaw to Cogs or Armitage to Oliver?

Thanks in advance.

 

[madmunza]

Brayshaw to Cogs or Armitage to Oliver?

Thanks in advance.

Armitage to Cogs

 

[IDIG]

Taranto vs Curnow vs Acres.

Leaning towards Taranto.

My other forwards are:
Heeney, Billings, McLean, Sicily and Fritsch.

Yeah Taranto seems like a decent option at his price. i'm not sure he can keep up this level of scoring but if he does, you'll put yourself in a ridiculously good position for the year.

Brayshaw to Cogs or Armitage to Oliver?

Thanks in advance.

Brayshaw to Cogs looks good to me. I'm not ready to give up on Armitage quite yet, i reckon a decent score is just around the corner...hopefully!

 

[Maccas marvels]

Taranto vs Curnow vs Acres.

Leaning towards Taranto.

My other forwards are:
Heeney, Billings, McLean, Sicily and Fritsch.

Hey Bomber boy, for me it would be Curnow. Reminds me of buddy in 07 and think he can be a big POD in your fwd line giving you the opportunity to move Sicily back if need be

 

[Johnsy44]

Shaw vs Simpson vs Curnow vs Taranto vs Bonner

 

[TeeButOne]

Shaw vs Simpson vs Curnow vs Taranto vs Bonner

Agree with Maccas marvels' comment above, very excited at what Curnow could produce this year, and much prefer the ability to bring him in for Hibberd via Sicily (as opposed to straight-swapping for Simpson or Shaw) (although I'd put Shaw 2nd behind Curnow from your list).

 

[Couch Coach]

Westhoff vs McLean

Westhoff: Has averaged 99 before in 2013 but generally 80-90 so sub keeper level
McLean: Projecting well for SC growth but in an unstable bulldogs team

Also considered
C Curnow: Projecting well for SC growth but not sure he can keep up keeper level this year
T Taranto: Has only played WB and Collingwood to date

 

[XabiFernando]

Westhoff vs McLean

Westhoff: Has averaged 99 before in 2013 but generally 80-90 so sub keeper level
McLean: Projecting well for SC growth but in an unstable bulldogs team

Also considered
C Curnow: Projecting well for SC growth but not sure he can keep up keeper level this year
T Taranto: Has only played WB and Collingwood to date

McLean (although I have him so I'm biased), not a lot to suggest there is upside with Westhoff.

Second one is lineball, but probably Taranto given midfield time

 

[bomberboy]

Thanks fellas. Think I'm gonna go with Curnow, fits with my research pre-season.

 

[XabiFernando]

Heeney v Yeo, Yeo gets a 50 point headstart.

Reason being I would have to DPP Sicily if I brought in heeney, which would mean Naughton plays at D6.

 

[BigRuss]

Garlett Vs Murphy to replace ZGL?

 

[Santoz]

Barry vs L Murphy

 

[Bomber18]

Garlett Vs Murphy to replace ZGL?

Murphy for me. Still think Murphy has decent scoring potential but iffy JS. Better chance to get to 300k than Garlett but also could get dropped with a few poor games. Just need Murphy to reach R5-6, where the crows have a run of easy games at home

 

[TommyGobbler]

Fisher v Christensen

 

[Darkie]

Fisher v Christensen

Christensen. Has done what you need before, in his ongoing role.