Position Forwards Discussion

Which forwards will you be starting outside of Danger/Heeney? (new poll 4/3/19)

  • Gray $526k

    Votes: 11 8.6%
  • Mundy $521k

    Votes: 17 13.3%
  • Menegola $543k

    Votes: 18 14.1%
  • McLean $514k

    Votes: 6 4.7%
  • Kelly $506k

    Votes: 28 21.9%
  • Boak $477k

    Votes: 11 8.6%
  • Billings $438k

    Votes: 29 22.7%
  • Gresham $430k

    Votes: 3 2.3%
  • Worpel $396k

    Votes: 20 15.6%
  • Greene $354k

    Votes: 33 25.8%

  • Total voters
    128
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,810
AFL Club
Collingwood
O'meara has being at M5 for me in every draft for the last month id say, i was considering him before the Tich injury.
I am however worried about restings but he got through 20 games last year so i am pretty keen on taking the gamble, Hawthorns pre-bye draw seems better to me that's why Silicy is also a likely starter based on JLT proving he won't lose to many intercept possessions.
Love JOM , he was something VVS in those first 2 seasons at the Suns.

Think it is just lucky he is starting to get some continuity and confidence in his body now , would love him to go 107-110+ just not sure he ever will now.

Was reading reports of the Hawthorn practice game and they were saying after 15-20 seconds of a bounce teams were getting loose players and basically back to 3-12-3 , full backs at halfway when team going forward etc etc.

Personally I think instead of introducing new rules , the AFL should make the umpires govern the current rules in place eg pay holding the ball , incorrect disposal , throw the ball in/up quicker (if ruckman are not there too bad).

Hopefully I am wrong and the congestion clears.
 
Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,022
Likes
2,337
AFL Club
North Melb.
After reading this Mundy is firming up as my F3 - 1% ownership, played at least 18 games in his last 8 seasons and more mid-time are all ticks in my book.
A combination of Gray, Dunkley, Mclean and Wingard have all rotated through F3 but they have all had question marks - whether they be role or injury related.
Freo veteran not planning on slowing down in 15th season

EVERGREEN veteran David Mundy has given no thought to scaling back his workload, declaring he is ready to play every game and reinforce Fremantle's injury-hit midfield ahead of his 15th campaign.
Coming off another ultra-consistent season when he finished runner-up to departed gun Lachie Neale in the Doig Medal, Mundy has ticked off a near-faultless summer and is showing no signs of slowing down.

The 33-year-old was typically polished and omnipresent in last Friday's intraclub, helping Michael Walters steer the 'purple' team's engine room without seeming to move out of second gear.
With Freo coach Ross Lyon conceding some anxiety about his midfield stocks, much will depend on Mundy, Walters and superstar Nat Fyfe, especially during early fixtures against North Melbourne, Gold Coast and St Kilda which could lay the platform for a finals push.
That top-flight trio is set to also rotate through attack, similar to recent seasons, but Mundy has been preparing as if he will play the entire year on the ball.

"That's what I'm working towards, absolutely," Mundy told AFL.com.au.
"Even the last couple of years when I've played a lot more forward, especially through this pre-season phase, I've always trained with the mids.
"I've always mentally and physically tried to prepare myself to play mid, because each end has its challenges but midfield is physically more demanding than any other role that I've played or experienced."

Mundy's ability to back up from midfield batterings and arduous travel has been a hallmark of his distinguished career, and the former skipper has no intention of voluntarily missing matches in 2019.
"It's not something I really think about. Even mentally, I don't come into a season thinking ‘if I bang out 15 or 16 (games), that's a good result'," he said.
"My absolute focus at the moment is to be ready to go round one against the Kangaroos here and to really get our season off to a really good start – it's something we've lacked the last couple of years, especially.
"You speak about teams that have missed the finals last year and we're one of those teams and we're desperate to change our fortunes."
The Dockers' game style has been tough to identify since they plunged into a rebuild during a disastrous 2016, and they ranked bottom-three for scoring in the past three seasons.
But Mundy hoped the talent and character of players brought into the club in recent years would drive Fremantle back towards September again.
"It's why we play. Finals football is a different beast and a very exciting time," Mundy said.
"We've been trying to share stories of our successful period here and the feeling around the club – not only finals but throughout the year – and how you get caught up in, not the hype so much, but the process Monday to Friday and everything kind of gameday just takes care of itself.
"That's been my experience, even just in life, the really daunting tasks in front of you can be broken down into simple steps and it's just a matter of following the steps and doing the processes as well as you can.
"Ross says it all the time, that's not going to guarantee success on gameday for us, but it will give you your best chance."

Mundy, renowned as a fastidious preparer, has been held up by Lyon as an example for the young Dockers of what it takes to succeed in a ruthless competition.
Since making his debut in 2005, he has played at least 21 games in 11 of the next 13 seasons, and completing 'extras' – such as ice baths, yoga and stretching – have been keys to his longevity.
It has added up and Mundy is on the verge of joining fellow Freo great Matthew Pavlich as the only WA-based players to notch 300 AFL games – a feat he could achieve the Dockers' marquee Len Hall Tribute Game against the Western Bulldogs in round six.
"It will obviously be really special," Mundy said.
"I would have liked to have won a few more games early days and the last couple of years, but I'll go over to the season launch to get inducted into the AFL life members in a couple of weeks and hopefully get six more (games) out this year."

Whether Mundy pushes on beyond 2019 will be discussed throughout the season, and the 2010 Doig medallist has no desire to remain on the list purely to be an experienced head.
But after booting a career-high 19 goals and averaging 22.5 disposals last year, it's difficult to envisage Mundy's standards dropping to a point where a decision is not largely, if not entirely, in his hands.
"I was having these (contract) conversations a little bit last year – and I guess it's the virtue of being a bit older and going onto year-by-year contracts," he said.
"But personally I'll be evaluating myself on my performance, whether I still think I hold some value for the team and pulling my weight and playing my role.
"I certainly don't want to hang around here for the sake of hanging around or to be necessarily just an experienced head on a list. I want to be a really valuable contributing member of our playing group and our team.
"Running around at training at the moment I feel really great and really positive that I'm in the best mindset and physically good place to do that."
 
Joined
13 Dec 2018
Messages
785
Likes
1,660
AFL Club
Geelong
I think Mundy may start well but possible decline in the second half of the year, just my gut feeling at this stage.
I don't think you can go wrong with him this year barring injury though, So many solid fwd options who will play mids this year.
 
Joined
15 Oct 2018
Messages
3,912
Likes
12,177
AFL Club
Essendon
Don't like to place too much weight on positional lineups - but I'm still far more inclined to pick Dunkley over McLean purely because in my view the back half of 2018 is a better 2019 indicator than the first half of 2018.
I was more referring to how they will line up at centre bounces with 6 inside mids on the field (Macrae, Dunkley, Bont, Wallis, McLean, Libba), 3 will likely be forward and the other 3 in the square at any given time.
 
Joined
8 Oct 2018
Messages
10,254
Likes
36,905
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
I was more referring to how they will line up at centre bounces with 6 inside mids on the field (Macrae, Dunkley, Bont, Wallis, McLean, Libba), 3 will likely be forward and the other 3 in the square at any given time.
Totally agree ... so many M/F options it nearly borders on stupidity ... at what cost though ... can't see a dominant ruck or key forward in the team to take the pressure off ... why they didn't make a play at say Preuss bewilders me ...
 
Joined
15 Oct 2018
Messages
3,912
Likes
12,177
AFL Club
Essendon
I thought McLean injured his shoulder half way through last year?
Dunkley is a better contested possession winner and a slightly slightly better tackler than McLean (both are good), but McLean is better at clearances by virtue of his pace. Don't think either are a standout as better than the other but I would give the edge to Dunkley at the minute. McLean lost his spot in the midfield because of his shoulder (those were the reports).
 
Joined
9 Mar 2014
Messages
4,259
Likes
7,602
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Can’t find any forwards really above 400k I like outside of Dangerfield and Heeney.

Can anyone make cases for people between 400-550k? There are basically none in there I’m confident about.

Last year I had Lambert, McLean etc I really liked.

If Wingard is named round 1 he is a lock for mine but not sure that will be the case, may look to rookie upgrade to him as he’ll be playing a heap of midfield this year where he is a proven 100+ scorer.

Will Petrecca or Billings finally take the next step now that they are past the second year blues stage and should be fitter and stronger players??

Is Toby Greene worth the gamble even though I’m doing everything I can to stay away from mid priced (250-400k) players this year.

Tom McDonald, Mundy, Hawkins, Buddy, Gray all have concerns.

Gunston is consistent but will he do any better than a 90-95 season, it seems unlikely but that’s consistency which it is nice to often lock down.

Will Tim Kelly have 2nd year blues?

Will Dunkley and Mclean get enough midfield time?

Will De Goey play early on and enough midfield to score big?



Would love some guys opinions on 400-550k players this year that they like or don’t like at all..
 
Joined
30 Jul 2014
Messages
1,640
Likes
4,608
AFL Club
Sydney
From my untrained eye, T Kelly looked like he was a bit laboured, potentially carrying a few extra kilos?
 
Joined
16 Jun 2013
Messages
5,465
Likes
11,297
AFL Club
Adelaide
Can’t find any forwards really above 400k I like outside of Dangerfield and Heeney.

Can anyone make cases for people between 400-550k? There are basically none in there I’m confident about.

Last year I had Lambert, McLean etc I really liked.

If Wingard is named round 1 he is a lock for mine but not sure that will be the case, may look to rookie upgrade to him as he’ll be playing a heap of midfield this year where he is a proven 100+ scorer.

Will Petrecca or Billings finally take the next step now that they are past the second year blues stage and should be fitter and stronger players??

Is Toby Greene worth the gamble even though I’m doing everything I can to stay away from mid priced (250-400k) players this year.

Tom McDonald, Mundy, Hawkins, Buddy, Gray all have concerns.

Gunston is consistent but will he do any better than a 90-95 season, it seems unlikely but that’s consistency which it is nice to often lock down.

Will Tim Kelly have 2nd year blues?

Will Dunkley and Mclean get enough midfield time?

Will De Goey play early on and enough midfield to score big?



Would love some guys opinions on 400-550k players this year that they like or don’t like at all..
I like Gresh and maybe T Lynch if ok to go R1.
 
Joined
13 Jan 2015
Messages
833
Likes
647
AFL Club
Brisbane
Can’t find any forwards really above 400k I like outside of Dangerfield and Heeney.

Can anyone make cases for people between 400-550k? There are basically none in there I’m confident about.

Last year I had Lambert, McLean etc I really liked.

If Wingard is named round 1 he is a lock for mine but not sure that will be the case, may look to rookie upgrade to him as he’ll be playing a heap of midfield this year where he is a proven 100+ scorer.

Will Petrecca or Billings finally take the next step now that they are past the second year blues stage and should be fitter and stronger players??

Is Toby Greene worth the gamble even though I’m doing everything I can to stay away from mid priced (250-400k) players this year.

Tom McDonald, Mundy, Hawkins, Buddy, Gray all have concerns.

Gunston is consistent but will he do any better than a 90-95 season, it seems unlikely but that’s consistency which it is nice to often lock down.

Will Tim Kelly have 2nd year blues?

Will Dunkley and Mclean get enough midfield time?

Will De Goey play early on and enough midfield to score big?



Would love some guys opinions on 400-550k players this year that they like or don’t like at all..
defitnetly i.m.o
 
Joined
20 Jan 2016
Messages
394
Likes
708
AFL Club
Carlton
I can't fit him in, because of all my other speculatives, but does anyone think that Jeremy Cameron will have even more of a license to wander this year? If he had a bit more of a Hogan, Hawkins, type role this year, I reckon he could score pretty well. He's got the attributes to do it. I think this might happen this year, regardless of whether GWS play two rucks.
 

Bomber18

Leadership Group
Joined
11 Nov 2012
Messages
27,409
Likes
65,138
AFL Club
Essendon
Can’t find any forwards really above 400k I like outside of Dangerfield and Heeney.

Can anyone make cases for people between 400-550k? There are basically none in there I’m confident about.

Last year I had Lambert, McLean etc I really liked.

If Wingard is named round 1 he is a lock for mine but not sure that will be the case, may look to rookie upgrade to him as he’ll be playing a heap of midfield this year where he is a proven 100+ scorer.

Will Petrecca or Billings finally take the next step now that they are past the second year blues stage and should be fitter and stronger players??

Is Toby Greene worth the gamble even though I’m doing everything I can to stay away from mid priced (250-400k) players this year.

Tom McDonald, Mundy, Hawkins, Buddy, Gray all have concerns.

Gunston is consistent but will he do any better than a 90-95 season, it seems unlikely but that’s consistency which it is nice to often lock down.

Will Tim Kelly have 2nd year blues?

Will Dunkley and Mclean get enough midfield time?

Will De Goey play early on and enough midfield to score big?



Would love some guys opinions on 400-550k players this year that they like or don’t like at all..
Yeah, I think I have all these questions as well. Tom Lynch would be the one I'd lock in if he was fit. Unfortunately, his knee injury sounds like it hasn't progressed that smoothly at all.

Billings interests me. Did have a good finish in 2017 and did reasonably well to end 2018. Playing more up the ground in the JLT for a solid 100 score. One I'm monitoring a bit more closely.

Otherwise, I'm also wondering whether just to go really cheap at F3 and F4 and go Greene, Daniher, Moore types to make some cash and hold up a spot til we can find the right answers.
 
Top