Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[Bermi]

All this talk around Dunkley is tempting me for F3 replacing T Kelly. Dunkley + $2600 left over cash vs Kelly + $13100? Was already very nervous about going in with 13k, feel like it's not a good move to make that even worse!

I wish we knew for sure if Dunkley will play Mid ALL year, hmmm.

 

[Bermi]

Does anyone here have Jack Higgins mobile number? I really need to talk to him about something.

Actually, I wouldn't mind a few of the AFL Coaches' phone numbers!

 

[quite ironic]

Sloane and Libba
Vs
Macrae and Constable

Probably my final x v y

Both options has 5 premium mids but option 1 has Libba on field with 2 rookie where as option 2 has 3 rookies on field (including Constable).

Conversely I could go Sloane and Constable and bank the 160k to use on rookies needed (Scrimshaw, Ridley etc), Goldy to Grundy or just bank it and use it for round 1 and 2 trades.

Thoughts?

 

[BigRuss]

Brouch & Greene Vs Dunkley & Moore

 

[BigRuss]

Sloane and Libba
Vs
Macrae and Constable

Probably my final x v y

Both options has 5 premium mids but option 1 has Libba on field with 2 rookie where as option 2 has 3 rookies on field (including Constable).

Conversely I could go Sloane and Constable and bank the 160k to use on rookies needed (Scrimshaw, Ridley etc), Goldy to Grundy or just bank it and use it for round 1 and 2 trades.

Thoughts?

Ive been a big pusher for Macrae all pre season but hes found his way out of my side the last few days, more a casualty on going Goldy - Grundy than anything.

That being said id still take him and Constable comfortably over Sloane & Libba. Libba's had 2 recons and the probability of a re-occurence goes up significantly with each one, just not worth it with so many other good mid priced players this year IMO.

 

[BC]

M5
Dusty v M Crouch v Selwood
Cheers

 

[Cricket98]

Brayshaw vs Steele

 

[PC]

Brouch & Greene Vs Dunkley & Moore

Probably Dunkley and Moore BR, but it could go either way 5 rounds in.

 

[quite ironic]

Brayshaw vs Steele

Steele

 

[quite ironic]

Brayshaw vs Sloane for M4.

Already have Steele at M5.

 

[bomberboy]

Brayshaw vs Sloane for M4.

Already have Steele at M5.

My gut says Sloane, so that's what I'll tell you.

Crouch and Kelly
Vs
Fyfe and Billings

 

[NT.Thunder]

My gut says Sloane, so that's what I'll tell you.

Crouch and Kelly
Vs
Fyfe and Billings

I'm struggling a little with this but I must have a short memory noting the pain Billings caused me last year.
I'm trying to get Fyfe in regardless - if he's fit and firing there are few that can compete with his SC scoring ceiling and his draw looks good early in the piece.

 

[bwright]

Laird + Butters
or
Crisp + Walsh

 

[inwhiterooms]

Whitfield + Dusty vs Andrews/Witherden + Neale?

 

[HoleyFrijole$]

Dusty & Fyfe v Treloar & Coniglio/Neale

(Best players in comp, or consistent players with big preseasons)

 

[Pieman17]

Dusty & Fyfe v Treloar & Coniglio/Neale

(Best players in comp, or consistent players with big preseasons)

Can you get Fyfe and Cog ?

If not number 1.

 

[HoleyFrijole$]

Can you get Fyfe and Cog ?

If not number 1.

Can do Fyfe and Cog

 

[Pieman17]

Can do Fyfe and Cog

I like that duo.

 

[HoleyFrijole$]

I like that duo.

Gives me Cripps Oliver Fyfe Coniglio M Crouch B Crouch for the M1-6

 

[teatai]

Williams V Mills

for D2 spot?