Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[Bluze]

Olliver vs Neale

 

[quite ironic]

Williams V Mills

for D2 spot?

Williams

 

[quite ironic]

Olliver vs Neale

Oliver - younger, bigger upside, more wins and uncertainty of Neale possibly being tagged.

 

[Pieman17]

Constable V Atkins

Constable/Atkins and Burgess V Scrimshaw and Gibbons.

It would be one out of Hore,Duursma and Scrimshaw/Burgess on field each week. Everyone else on the bench.

 

[bloke]

Z Williams + Oliver vs Laird + M Crouch?

 

[NT.Thunder]

Z Williams + Oliver vs Laird + M Crouch?

I like Oliver and Williams.

I'm a little concerned with Laird this season and Smith and Milera back and improving.

 

[Blue Bloods]

I like Oliver and Williams.

I'm a little concerned with Laird this season and Smith and Milera back and improving.

Agree, but still think Laird will find space and score well. Maybe drop a few points but still top 1-5 back

 

[Lgndhen23]

Libba vs b.smith

 

[NT.Thunder]

Agree, but still think Laird will find space and score well. Maybe drop a few points but still top 1-5 back

Yeah both he and Lloyd will be top 5 with Whitfield and a couple randoms I reckon, probably going to watch for a while though. Was keen on Lloyd and for nearly the same price I can add a Fyfe or Oliver which makes more sense to me considering I was swing Duursma anyway.

 

[Blue Bloods]

Yeah both he and Lloyd will be top 5 with Whitfield and a couple randoms I reckon, probably going to watch for a while though. Was keen on Lloyd and for nearly the same price I can add a Fyfe or Oliver which makes more sense to me considering I was swing Duursma anyway.

Fyfe and Oliver will score about the same as others of that price on their line.

Lloyd could score 10 or more points from the next best on his line. I would prefer the extra 10 points option but only if you believe Lloyd can continue his 2018 form.

 

[Blue Bloods]

Libba vs b.smith

Libba but only because of the price difference

 

[jaca]

MCrouch vs. Beams.

Trying to get out of a R14 pickle.

 

[The Underdogs]

Hey guys!

Sicily/ Kelly/ Cousins vs Witherden/ Dunkley/ Hatley + 30k

 

[aleceee]

Macrae + Goldy vs Steele + Grundy

Thanks, very stuck on this decision.

 

[quite ironic]

Macrae + Goldy vs Steele + Grundy

Thanks, very stuck on this decision.

Similar dilemma for myself but have locked in Steele at M5 and Sloane is the x in my scenario.

Leaning towards Macrae + Goldy personally.

 

[Beast_Mode]

Brayshaw + Gray/Dunkley
vs
Oliver + Billings

 

[quite ironic]

Brayshaw + Gray/Dunkley
vs
Oliver + Billings

Brayshaw + Dunkley

 

[WindyHillWizard]

Macrae and Brad Couch (+$60k) vs Fyfe and Matt Crouch

 

[Darkie]

Williams V Mills

for D2 spot?

Williams comfortably.

 

[Darkie]

MCrouch vs. Beams.

Trying to get out of a R14 pickle.

Crouch comfortably. Haven't spent a lot of time considering Beams, I think there are too many mids at Collingwood for him to be an absolute top scorer, and he's not a durable pick or a great C pick in my view.