Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[Darkie]

Macrae and Brad Couch (+$60k) vs Fyfe and Matt Crouch

Option two unless you really need the cash.

 

[Diabolical]

Heeney & Libba v Billings & B Crouch

 

[poopingHindi]

Heeney & Libba v Billings & B Crouch

the first option for me.
Heeney will be one of the top forwards and Libba is the best available stepping stone IMO.

too much risk with the others...although Crouch does have a fairly big upside too.

 

[WindyHillWizard]

Heeney & Libba v Billings & B Crouch

Heeney and Libba. At least one top 2/3 keeper plus a good mid pricer

 

[DMCC10]

Option 1: Fyfe + Butters + Duursma (E)
Option 2: JOM + Hanley + B.Scott (E)

 

[HomerJ]

Grundy, Fyfe & Cogs vs Goldy, Macrae & Cripps

 

[Darkie]

Heeney & Libba v Billings & B Crouch

I agree with the other responses, including their rationale.

 

[quite ironic]

Option 1: Fyfe + Butters + Duursma (E)
Option 2: JOM + Hanley + B.Scott (E)

Option 1 pretty easily for mine.

Grundy, Fyfe & Cogs vs Goldy, Macrae & Cripps

Option 2 I like better personally.

 

[Seymour Skinner]

Dunkley (F4) + BCrouch (M5) + Collins (D4) + 15k.

vs

Moore + Sloane + Hanley + 76k.

 

[Darkie]

Option 1: Fyfe + Butters + Duursma (E)
Option 2: JOM + Hanley + B.Scott (E)

Option 1 in my view. JOM and Hanley only played one JLT game each and their TOG was lowish. I was keen on Hanley through summer but wanted to see more from him to be confident starting him. Also not sure that JOM will be able to handle any tags that come his way.

 

[EyeloveRichmond]

I've been swapping Sicily and Laird so many times. If you had to start one, who would you start? Is Sicily's role really going to change that much that has people scared? Will he be playing more fwd and will this hinder his scoring potential?

Also Sloane v M.Crouch? Who do you select? Sloane seems a bit of a POD this year from what i've seen, is probably at his lowest price he'll be if he has a decent year, i've been burnt by him in the past but i get the feeling he is over his injury concerns and in for a big year. Any input/thoughts would be much appreciated on both questions, cheers.

 

[Ben's Beasts]

M5
Dusty v M Crouch v Selwood
Cheers

M Crouch.

Brayshaw vs Steele

Steele.

My gut says Sloane, so that's what I'll tell you.

Crouch and Kelly
Vs
Fyfe and Billings

M Crouch and T Kelly.

Whitfield + Dusty vs Andrews/Witherden + Neale?

Whitfield & Dusty.

Williams V Mills

for D2 spot?

Williams.

Olliver vs Neale

Oliver.

Z Williams + Oliver vs Laird + M Crouch?

Z Williams & Oliver.

MCrouch vs. Beams.

Trying to get out of a R14 pickle.

M Crouch.

Macrae + Goldy vs Steele + Grundy

Thanks, very stuck on this decision.

Steele & Grundy.

Macrae and Brad Couch (+$60k) vs Fyfe and Matt Crouch

Fyfe & M Crouch.

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Grundy, Fyfe & Cogs vs Goldy, Macrae & Cripps

Grundy, Fyfe and Coniglio for mine.

 

[jaca]

Thanks for the input Ben. Still feel like my side is a long way off settled...

 

[Inside50]

Cripps v Fyfe

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Cripps v Fyfe

Cripps.

 

[Inside50]

Cripps.

Thanks Ben. Cripps is safe, how much upside do you think he has off a 119 average?

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Thanks Ben. Cripps is safe, how much upside do you think he has off a 119 average?

Think he goes at around 125 this season. My first picked mid.

 

[teatai]

Would appreciate thoughts??
Macrae + Darling (F3) + Greene (F4)
vs
Oliver (M2) + Dunkly (F3) + Worpel (F4)

 

[teatai]

Cripps v Fyfe

Cripps too