Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[_Slip_]

I don’t normally do X vs Y but I’ve traded this combo multiple times over the last fortnight and I still can’t decide.

B.Smith (D) & Steele (M)
vs
Milera(D) & Rockliff (M)

I can see B.Smith going at 85 for the season and Steele at 95 - 100

Milera 90 - 95 and Rocky 90 - 100

Help please.

 

[_Slip_]

Last minute tweaks. (my estimates)

It's a coin toss for me.

Macrae (120) and Goldy (110)
vs
Merret (110) and Grundy (120)

Option 2 * I think Merrett is a better upgrade option

 

[Mr_Arrogance]

I don’t normally do X vs Y but I’ve traded this combo multiple times over the last fortnight and I still can’t decide.

B.Smith (D) & Steele (M)
vs
Milera(D) & Rockliff (M)

I can see B.Smith going at 85 for the season and Steele at 95 - 100

Milera 90 - 95 and Rocky 90 - 100

Help please.

if you only see steele going at 95-100 then I dont think you should be considering him. at that price you should be aiming for a keeper

 

[_Slip_]

if you only see steele going at 95-100 then I dont think you should be considering him. at that price you should be aiming for a keeper

Thank you

 

[Leroy]

Last minute tweaks. (my estimates)

It's a coin toss for me.

Macrae (120) and Goldy (110)
vs
Merret (110) and Grundy (120)

Lots on here steering away from Merret after an interrupted pre-season, figuring he might be slow to start. If you rate Goldy as 110 then go with A.

 

[Tranterpants]

I don’t normally do X vs Y but I’ve traded this combo multiple times over the last fortnight and I still can’t decide.

B.Smith (D) & Steele (M)
vs
Milera(D) & Rockliff (M)

I can see B.Smith going at 85 for the season and Steele at 95 - 100

Milera 90 - 95 and Rocky 90 - 100

Help please.

Option 1 - Option 2 could be a bust..

 

[armesy]

Lots on here steering away from Merret after an interrupted pre-season, figuring he might be slow to start. If you rate Goldy as 110 then go with A.

I am not buying into Merret's issues. He had a good pre season up until the ankle which was just 2 weeks, more than a freshen up if anything.
JLT 2 - 63 SC 59%TOG

Grundy's injury was just as bad.

 

[PowerBrokers]

B Smith + Gibbons
VS
Collins + Libba

Trying to balance which midpricer & rookie is better, any advice would be appreciated

 

[Leroy]

I am not buying into Merret's issues. He had a good pre season up until the ankle which was just 2 weeks, more than a freshen up if anything.
JLT 2 - 63 SC 59%TOG

Grundy's injury was just as bad.

Good work, back your judgement and best of luck

 

[PowerBrokers]

Also,
D2 tossup between

Callum Mills VS Harris Andrews

 

[quite ironic]

Scrimshaw + Hately
Vs
Collins + Gibbons

For D5 and Mid Bench spots (Walsh and Butters on mid ground)


Duursma + Gibbons
Vs
Wilkie + Bewley

 

[aleceee]

B Smith (D3) + Burgess (D8) + D Moore (F4)
Vs
Scrimshaw (D4) + Wilkie (D8) + Darling (F4)

Could also go Scrimshaw instead of Burgess in option A, just want to keep the DPP link if possible.

 

[quite ironic]

B Smith (D3) + Burgess (D8) + D Moore (F4)
Vs
Scrimshaw (D4) + Wilkie (D8) + Darling (F4)

Could also go Scrimshaw instead of Burgess in option A, just want to keep the DPP link if possible.

Option 2 for mine

 

[inwhiterooms]

B.Smith + Libba + Dunkley
vs
Duursma (D6) + Neale + Billings

 

[Beast_Mode]

Lloyd + Libba
vs
B. Smith + Dusty

 

[_Slip_]

Lloyd + Libba
vs
B. Smith + Dusty

Option B

 

[Mr_Arrogance]

Lloyd + Libba
vs
B. Smith + Dusty

I instantly said "B" but then thought I should stop and think and give my guesstimates on what i think they might average.
100+90
85+105
so that surprised me that I instantly thought B but I actually consider them fairly on par when thinking about it

 

[R3ckless]

Coniglio + Yeo
vs
Oliver + M Crouch

 

[Adrenaline]

1. martin vs crouch

2. oliver vs fyfe vs cogs

 

[Steuby]

Coniglio + Yeo
vs
Oliver + M Crouch

Oliver + M Crouch

1. martin vs crouch

2. oliver vs fyfe vs cogs

1. Crouch just
2. In terms of total points I feel: Oliver > Fyfe >Cogs