Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[Darkie]

Yeah, i went with Fyfe and Neale. I have serious JRoo and Balta issues though, rough start.

JRoo's wife just had a baby, I'm guessing he hasn't slept that well. Hopefully it's that rather than Lynch. I've got Balta too (albeit on the bench), if he keeps getting picked (Rance out, apparently Balta was training under him, so it can't hurt) I think he'll play better ... got some ruck time, gave away heaps of frees, has a lot of TOG upside, and one or two things didn't seem to go his way.

Next week might look better for those two.

 

[Feerits Elf]

Atkins & Petrucelle

v

Constable & Parker

 

[Tamuhawk]

Ridley (D4) & Constable (M9 bench spot)
Vs
Cousins (M6) & Burgess (F8 bench spot with dpp link with Moore, Moore would then become D4 instead of F5)

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Ridley (D4) & Constable (M9 bench spot)
Vs
Cousins (M6) & Burgess (F8 bench spot with dpp link with Moore, Moore would then become D4 instead of F5)

Think the 200k player is better for the backline where he is on field and you keep Moore on field. Think the replacement for Cousin is not dissimilar given mids depth of rookies whereas fwd/def it may be.

Grappling with the same except I have Libba in minds and could drop him to a Cousins and bring in Ridley for Scrimshaw or Hore. Not sure in that instances it is the same as the gap of Libba to Cousins is greater than Cousins to Constable/Atkins etc.

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Atkins & Petrucelle

v

Constable & Parker

too hard!

Petro may have better scoring than Parker (maybe) but Parker has better JS. Same that Atkins may have better js than Constable.

I have them all!

 

[Steuby]

Grundy & Steel

vs

Macrae & Goldstein

 

[Woodsey]

Collins and Neale v Duursma and Macrae

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Grundy & Steel

vs

Macrae & Goldstein

Macrae & Goldy for me

 

[Loboda1963]

Grundy & BCrouch or Goldy & Neale

 

[Feerits Elf]

too hard!

Petro may have better scoring than Parker (maybe) but Parker has better JS. Same that Atkins may have better js than Constable.

I have them all!

Yeah, I just don't see how people take both Constable and Atkins if they bat to M6 unless they passed on Gibbons.

Walsh
Butters
Constable
Scott
Atkins
Gibbons

 

[benderiffic]

The ultimate x v y
Lloyd, Duursma, Oliver, Gawn, Petrucelle
V
Williams, Smith, Zorko, Goldie, greene

 

[bloke]

This might be straight forward but would you go

Gawn + B Crouch vs Goldy + Fyfe

I just hate having 2 $700k rucks

 

[AngryAnt]

The ultimate x v y
Lloyd, Duursma, Oliver, Gawn, Petrucelle
V
Williams, Smith, Zorko, Goldie, greene

Option A

Three super premos vs speculative mid pricers, go the super premos and rookies

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

The ultimate x v y
Lloyd, Duursma, Oliver, Gawn, Petrucelle
V
Williams, Smith, Zorko, Goldie, greene

First option for me with 3 solid premos

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

This might be straight forward but would you go

Gawn + B Crouch vs Goldy + Fyfe

I just hate having 2 $700k rucks

Very very tight, Goldy/Fyfe just

 

[benderiffic]

First option for me with 3 solid premos

The issue is I will be batting 3 deep in forwards and def

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

The issue is I will be batting 3 deep in forwards and def

Not the worst structure I would have thought.
I am 3 deep in both those lines even though my D3 is Williams and F3 is Darling.

 

[Presto]

The ultimate x v y
Lloyd, Duursma, Oliver, Gawn, Petrucelle
V
Williams, Smith, Zorko, Goldie, greene

By far the first option, although it also depends on the rest of your team

 

[benderiffic]

Not the worst structure I would have thought.
I am 3 deep in both those lines even though my D3 is Williams and F3 is Darling.

6 deep mid?

 

[blue dreamer]

Rather convoluted x v y

With the team drops AND Rance injury (he is currently my D2).

I have the following X v Y.

Need to lock in the ruckman this week with the defender as my first trade next week

Mummy & Witherden/May/Adam Kennedy (thanks to Herbie) v Pierce & Hurn/Crisp/Howe/Suckling/McGovern (or one of the defenders named with Mummy).

Mummy being covered by Hoff atm.

Also which of the defenders.