Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[Johnsy44]

How important is Moore? Is he likely to keep up this good form?

Trading Heeney

Heeney - Moore
Vs
Heeney - Tkelly/Boak

Also keep Hore or trade to duursma

 

[DoggyODFL]

T Kelly v Rockliff v Sheed?

 

[BigRuss]

T Kelly v Rockliff v Sheed?

Rockliff - Kelly - Sheed

 

[Seedsman]

Trade Gibbons or Atkins for Constable?

 

[Darkie]

Boak vs Andrews?

I started Andrews and didn't seriously consider Boak as a top end keeper. Boak has started well but I'd be less sure about his role with Wines coming back. I don't mind him, but would prefer Andrews if I was in your position.

 

[Darkie]

T Kelly v Rockliff v Sheed?

Sheed a distant third for me, the others pretty close. Kelly more likely to be a top player on his line, Rocky more likely to really hurt you with some big scores and his points per dollar.

 

[Sojaldo]

I started Andrews and didn't seriously consider Boak as a top end keeper. Boak has started well but I'd be less sure about his role with Wines coming back. I don't mind him, but would prefer Andrews if I was in your position.

I'm unsure about Boak too. Do you think Andrews will be close to a top 6 defender? I started Williams too so I'm worried about being caught with too many players that may not finish in the top 6.

My idea is to free up $$ from Heeney so I can turn Collins into Moore but am I just creating problems for myself?

 

[Darkie]

I'm unsure about Boak too. Do you think Andrews will be close to a top 6 defender? I started Williams too so I'm worried about being caught with too many players that may not finish in the top 6.

My idea is to free up $$ from Heeney so I can turn Collins into Moore but am I just creating problems for myself?

It’s a valid concern, but I think he will be in there or quite close. He averaged over 100 between about round five and his injury last year (check out Footywire), is still young and potentially improving, and has recently been encouraged to mark rather than spoil.

With that said if you’re using two trades to do Collins and Heeney to Moore and Andrews, then I’m not sure that’s worth it. I’d try to get Moore another way, and personally I’m holding Heeney.

 

[Beast_Mode]

Bailey Smith to Libba (Butters pushed to the bench and I take Clarke's 65. However, I'm still stuck with Hore)
vs
Hore to Darcy Moore (Butters on Field, and get Moore's score rather than Clarke's)

 

[Herbie66]

Bailey Smith to Libba (Butters pushed to the bench and I take Clarke's 65. However, I'm still stuck with Hore)
vs
Hore to Darcy Moore (Butters on Field, and get Moore's score rather than Clarke's)

Clarke plays tonight or do you mean Clark ?

EDIT

and we have a Hunter Clark , Dylan Clarke & a Ryan Clarke as well ?

 

[Beast_Mode]

Clarke plays tonight or do you mean Clark ?

Whoops. Jordan Clark

 

[Sojaldo]

It’s a valid concern, but I think he will be in there or quite close. He averaged over 100 between about round five and his injury last year (check out Footywire), is still young and potentially improving, and has recently been encouraged to mark rather than spoil.

With that said if you’re using two trades to do Collins and Heeney to Moore and Andrews, then I’m not sure that’s worth it. I’d try to get Moore another way, and personally I’m holding Heeney.

Another option is to hold Heeney, forget about Moore, and instead trade Collins to Rozee, and possibly Balta to Petrucelle.

I think both trades should increase my $$ generation

 

[Darkie]

Another option is to hold Heeney, forget about Moore, and instead trade Collins to Rozee, and possibly Balta to Petrucelle.

I think both trades should increase my $$ generation

I think if they keep playing, it will, but I’ve heard some job security concerns about both. Might be worth forming a view/seeing if anyone else has an informed opinion on that from this point onwards.

 

[WindyHillWizard]

Rozee vs Moore.

Moore is about $50k more expensive so not sure he is worth it, especially with the injury risk. Rozee with the slightly better b/e but that could all change in one week.

Moore feels like he could average more and stay on field longer ad upgrades are done.

Thoughts?

 

[Zim^zuM]

Rockliff and rozee

Vs

Neale and petrucelle

 

[Dustman]

Thinking of starting Z Clarke over English

 

[freowho]

Thinking of starting Z Clarke over English

I was just trying to think of a reason to watch this game tonight and you just reminded me I can see how Zac Clarke goes.
Still don't know if I'll last half the game.

 

[Dustman]

I was just trying to think of a reason to watch this game tonight and you just reminded me I can see how Zac Clarke goes.
Still don't know if I'll last half the game.

Hope he does ok,tough against Gawn.JLT he was only against Phillips, but did have 15 touches, 4 tackles and a goal. Hopefully Woosha gives him a good go. Speaking purely from the SuperCoach pocket.

 

[Darkie]

Rozee vs Moore.

Moore is about $50k more expensive so not sure he is worth it, especially with the injury risk. Rozee with the slightly better b/e but that could all change in one week.

Moore feels like he could average more and stay on field longer ad upgrades are done.

Thoughts?

Moore In my view. Was a high priority starter for me, and Rozee is someone I don't mind not bringing in for a correction (I don't dislike him, but I don't feel like I'm missing out not having him). Port still have a number of players to come back, I'm not sure which of these rookies are going to keep making the cut.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Rockliff and rozee

Vs

Neale and petrucelle

R & R for me