Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[MAM1]

Gibbons vs constable?

 

[Darkie]

Gibbons vs constable?

I would field Constable. See the rookie roulette thread for some further discussion on this.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Option A:
Sicily (D4) & Hayes (M9)
Vs
Option B:
Fyfe (M7) + one of Young/Answerth (D6)

 

[Lukus193]

Jeremy Cameron vs Caleb Daniel for F4?

Both semi POD options, but I’m favouring Cameron due to his upcoming draw (saints, hawks, Carlton, Melbourne and GC) and the fact that GWS will be winning more games than the dogs.

 

[Pieman17]

Jeremy Cameron vs Caleb Daniel for F4?

Both semi POD options, but I’m favouring Cameron due to his upcoming draw (saints, hawks, Carlton, Melbourne and GC) and the fact that GWS will be winning more games than the dogs.

Daniel for me.

 

[HomerJ]

Lloyd vs Sicily as a trade in option this week?

 

[Pieman17]

Lloyd vs Sicily as a trade in option this week?

Lloyd

 

[Darkie]

Jeremy Cameron vs Caleb Daniel for F4?

Both semi POD options, but I’m favouring Cameron due to his upcoming draw (saints, hawks, Carlton, Melbourne and GC) and the fact that GWS will be winning more games than the dogs.

Daniel by a long way for me. Cameron won’t have 30 touches and kick 7 very often.

 

[Sojaldo]

Will Hayes vs Shai Bolton?

 

[quite ironic]

Will Hayes vs Shai Bolton?

2nd opinion on this please!

Downgrade of Scrimshaw to Hayes or Bolton?

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

2nd opinion on this please!

Downgrade of Scrimshaw to Hayes or Bolton?

3rd opinion maybe guys?

 

[Pieman17]

3rd opinion maybe guys?

Will Hayes vs Shai Bolton?

2nd opinion on this please!

Downgrade of Scrimshaw to Hayes or Bolton?

Hayes

 

[Weedys Crop]

Sicily v Laird trade option

 

[Darkie]

Sicily v Laird trade option

Very close call in my eyes. I go at Laird last week in part because I couldn't quite afford Sicily alongside Daniel. Would have been a real 50-50 if I could though.

Worth considering their bye rounds if you have Smith/Williams/Whitfield, albeit I think slingshotting Smith to Sicily (or similar) could be a good strategy around the byes.

 

[Nest]

Bont v Macrae trade option. Bont 6k more averaging 8 more so far, but its Macrae.

 

[Darkie]

Bont v Macrae trade option. Bont 6k more averaging 8 more so far, but its Macrae.

Exactly.

I'm inclined to say Macrae, but it's closer than I would have thought.

Worth checking BEs in case you want both.

 

[Ironhawk]

Pendlebury v Yeo?

Both seem to be in similar form, possibly leaning towards Pendles if Adams is out injured for any length of time.

 

[Bomber18]

Bont v Macrae trade option. Bont 6k more averaging 8 more so far, but its Macrae.

Exactly.

I'm inclined to say Macrae, but it's closer than I would have thought.

Worth checking BEs in case you want both.

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1125209326920933377

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1122630745824976896

If this helps at all...

Seems like Bont still is getting decent mid time but is also effective up fwd. Macrae seems to be getting pushed out of the CBAs a bit more of late

 

[Yasi]

Hoff vs Darling (+ 80 k)

Expecting about the same average from here but with Hoff giving ruck backup value

 

[GodEmperorTrump]

Bont vs Treloar(considering Adams missing a stretch)